Blog

The best of Manchester United

Fans of Man United have been spoilt in recent years. Great players, great managers, great matches and lots and lots and lots of silverware. Choosing the greatest moments from the club’s history has been a challenge, but I think I’ve come up with a decent dozen. Read on and see if you agree.

1. The conquest of Europe – European Cup final 1968

In 1968, Manchester United’s team boasted arguably the best-ever players at the time from each of England, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Bobby Charlton had been the stand-out star in England’s World Cup triumph of two years earlier, Denis Law had in 1964 become the first (and still the only) Scot to win the Ballon d’Or for best player in Europe; and George Best, well, was George Best. And these three superstars were not alone. Behind and around them, Matt Busby had built a squad strong enough to twice win the league in England (64/65 and 66/67), a team capable of beating the best in Europe.

Ten years previously, before the Munich air disaster, United had looked like a team that could come to dominate in England and in Europe for years, The tragedy, though, had stopped them in their tracks. Their recovery under Busby was remarkable, and when they first returned to European Cup competition in 1965/6, they much fancied. This campaign, though, was brought to an end, poignantly, when they lost in the semi-final to Partizan Belgrade in the very stadium where they had played before the crash in Munich. Two years later they qualified again and were again amongst the favourites, perhaps with added belief having seen Celtic become the first British side to win the trophy in 1967.

In 1968 the European Cup was not the bloated competition it is today, being contested only by national champions in a knock-out format. United had four two-legged ties to negotiate to reach the final, and the draw was relatively kind to them. Hibernians of Malta, Sarajevo of Yugoslavia and Gornik Zabrze of Poland were all dealt with – not always in the most convincing manner – before a tough semi-final pitted them against the kings of Europe, Real Madrid. The second leg, played in Madrid, was a minor classic, with Real going 3-1 (3-2 on aggregate) ahead before two late goals, from David Sadler and Bill Foulkes, won it for United. They had made it to their first European Cup final, with the big bonus of it being played on ‘home’ soil, at Wembley.

United’s opponents were Benfica, serial winners of the Portuguese league, and twice champions of Europe (in 1961 and 1962). Led by the great Eusebio, they were seasoned contenders, but some judged them to be a little over-seasoned, still good but a little past their best before date. United, despite missing Law through injury, were deemed to be narrow favourites.

The first half was cagey. The Portuguese were petrified about Best, whom they fouled repeatedly bringing him down six times, but they also managed to get the ball forward from time to time. When they did, Eusebio was a genuine threat, and it was he who had perhaps the best chance of the half, hitting the crossbar with a snap shot.

The second half saw United start well and they struck eight minutes in when Charlton headed in a cross from David Sadler. The lead lasted until the 79th minute when Benfica equalised through Jaime Graca. The game looked headed for extra time when with only moments remaining, Eusebio broke clear of the United defence. With just keeper Alex Stepney to beat it should have been curtains for United, but the normally lethal striker’s shot was too close to Stepney and was saved. Eusebio, in a memorable scene of sportsmanship, stopped to congratulate his opponent.

Extra time saw Stepney play an important role at the other end. After three minutes, his long goal kick was headed on by Brian Kidd, celebrating his 19th birthday, and found its way to Best who put himself into a one-on-one with the Benfica keeper. Best was calmness personified as he skilfully rounded the keeper and passed the ball into the empty net. Two minutes more and Kidd was again in the action, heading in a rebound after Sadler’s initial effort had been saved. The teenager contributed again five minutes later, crossing from the right to Charlton whose sublime first touch found the net. From 1-1 to 4-1 in nine stunning minutes, United had the game won.

United had become the first English club to capture the European Cup, almost exactly a decade after the horror of Munich. Captain Charlton and centre-back Bill Foulkes had both survived the crash, and their delight would surely have been tinged by memories of colleagues lost. As it would have been for Busby. The manager had barely survived the crash, twice being given the last rites while suffering from his injuries in a German hospital, but had come back to lead his team to the greatest possible triumph. As recoveries go, it could not have been better.  

2. The treble – UEFA Champions League final 1999

When United won their historic first European Cup in 1968 most fans and pundits thought it would be the first of many. Incredibly, after falling to AC Milan in the 1969 semi-final, it was to be another 25 years before they would even contest the tournament again, by which time it had been renamed the UEFA Champions League.

United’s reappearance in the competition was inauspicious, losing on away goals in the second round to Galatasaray in 93/4 then failing to make it out of the group stage the following year. But, each year they gained more experience and made steady, if slow, progress. Nevertheless, as the 98/9 competition came around, United were yet to make it to their second final.

Having got past Polish side LKS Lodz in the qualifying round, United found themselves in a tough group comprising themselves, Bayern Munich, Barcelona and Brondby of Denmark. With the Danes expected to be makeweights, it meant one of the big three would have to fall. In the event it was Barca, who lost home and away to Bayern. United were solid throughout, remaining unbeaten against the two big teams and twice thrashing Brondby.

The quarter-final saw United pitted against Internazionale of Italy. A 2-0 win at home was followed by an unnecessarily nerve-wracking 1-1 draw in Milan, with Scholes putting the tie away only in the 88th minute. United had to face Italian opposition again in the semi, this time league champions Juventus. Juve were not perhaps the force they had been in previous years (they finished only seventh in Serie A in 1999) but were still tactically astute and very hard to beat. They were probably the better side in the first leg at Old Trafford, going ahead before Giggs nailed a crucial equaliser in injury-time. This still left United a very tough task – travelling to the Stadio Delle Alpi for the second leg, effectively needing a win to go through.

It was in Turin that United produced one of their greatest ever performances. The game looked up when Juventus stormed into a 2-0 lead after only 15 minutes. Lesser teams would have crumbled, but United, led by an inspired captain Roy Keane fought their way back into the game. On 24 minutes, it was the Irishman who rose highest to glance a Beckham corner into the net. Ten minutes later and Andy Cole crossed for Dwight Yorke to head in an equaliser. 2-2 and United were now ahead on away goals. Chances came and went for both sides before, with six minutes remaining, Yorke and Cole again combined, this time with Cole converting into an empty net to clinch one of the great comebacks.

United had made it to the final, but this too would not be easy. They would be facing Bayern Munich without two of their best players – Keane and Paul Scholes, both booked in Turin and suspended from the final. The first half saw United go behind early, conceding a free kick from Mario Basler. United then had more of the possession, but rarely threatened the Bayern goal. The second half saw a similar pattern. United were toothless while Bayern had several good chances. Alex Ferguson had to make changes, so brought on Sheringham and Solskjaer and put Giggs and Beckham back into their usual positions. The game, though, looked to be drifting inexorably away from his team.

With five minutes to go, an overhead kick from Bayern’s Carsten Jancker should have finished the match off, but the ball cannoned off the crossbar with Schmeichel well beaten. So, the game ticked into added time with the fourth official indicating just three minutes left for United to get their equaliser. In the 91st minute Neville won a corner. With United drinking at the last chance saloon, Schmeichel came up to compete for the ball. Beckham floated it over. It looked innocuous and Bayern should have cleared it, but the defender muffed his clearance and the ball came to Ryan Giggs. His first time effort was mishit but fell to the feet of Teddy Sheringham who reacted instantly to turn it into the net. United had got out of jail and could now focus on extra time.

Or not. Perhaps they could win this in added time. They kept attacking. With only a minute remaining. Solskjaer chased a long ball and won another corner. Beckham again swung it into the box. Sheringham was first to the ball, glancing it across the six yard box where the Norwegian stuck his foot out instinctively to guide the ball into the net. United, from being down and out, were 2-1 ahead and there was no time for Bayern to fight back. United had won the Champions League and had completed a historic and unforgettable treble – the league, the FA Cup and the Champions League. What a night, or to be more precise, what a three minutes!

3. The rescuer – Mark Robins saves Fergie’s United career

On 8th November 1986 Manchester United travelled to the Manor Ground to take on Oxford United in front of 13,000 fans. Oxford had narrowly avoided relegation the previous season and were again expected to struggle, but they proved on the day to be more than a match for their more-fancied opposition, goals from Aldridge and Slatter seeing them to a deserved 2-0 victory. One week later and United failed to beat newly-promoted Norwich at Old Trafford, drawing 0-0. Perhaps their new manager was not all he was cracked up to be. Who was this Alex Ferguson anyway?

Ferguson, of course, proved himself to be the greatest manager in British football history, with 26 years at the helm during the most successful period for any club side ever. But when he arrived at United there were doubts. Yes, he had achieved great things with Aberdeen – breaking up the Celtic-Rangers domination to win three Scottish leagues, four Scottish cups, the European Cup Winners’ Cup and even the European Super Cup – but Scotland was not England. And the task to revive a flagging United was tough.

It took an unlikely scorer – John Sivebaek with his only goal for United – to deliver Fergie’s first victory – 1-0 at home to QPR – and from this point his team improved although United still finished only 11th in the league. The following season (87/8) saw more improvement and a runners-up finish in the league to Liverpool, but in truth it was a distant second, and 1988/89 witnessed a reversion to the darker days with another mediocre mid-table finish. Despite some significant signings the 1989/90 season started poorly. A humiliating 5-1 defeat at Man City (then a mid-table side at best) was followed by a run of six defeats and two draws in eight games. As Christmas approached, United sat just above the relegation zone and there were calls from fans and journalists for Fergie to be sacked. A banner even appeared at Old Trafford reading “3 years of excuses and it’s still crap … Ta ra Fergie”.

Fergie survived the Christmas break, but faced a stern challenge at the start of the New Year, a trip to the City Ground to take on a strong Nottingham Forest in the third round of the FA Cup. Informed observers felt sure that Ferguson would lose his job if United lost. His chances of survival were not helped by a long injury list that included captain, Bryan Robson, Lee Sharpe and big summer signings Neil Webb and Paul Ince.

Perhaps United were helped by the game being played on a pudding of a pitch that allowed them to dig in and negate Forest’s superior passing game. They went into the break at 0-0 then took a crucial lead in the 56th minute. Lee Martin won the ball on the left touchline and passed infield to Mark Hughes who floated a ball with the outside of his foot to 20-year-old Mark Robins who headed it in. The game at this point was far from won and, in truth, United were lucky to survive – Leighton saved well from Crosby, Jemson was narrowly wide twice, then with three minutes to go a Jemson header was disallowed for no apparent reason – but survive they did. When the final whistle sounded it was Robins’ goal that had secured the vital win.

The rest, as they say, is history. United went on to win the Cup in 1990, beating Crystal Palace in a replay after a thrilling 3-3 draw in the final proper. Fergie had grabbed his first piece of silverware for United and, of course, it would not be the last. Perhaps from time to time he gave some thought and some thanks to unheralded 20-year-old whose goal had helped him keep his job.

https://www.goal.com/en-gb/lists/explained-did-mark-robins-save-sir-alex-ferguson-man-utd-manager/blt2976f6913b87fe3e

4. Grown men go crazy – United vs Sheffield Wed, 10 April 1993

When United won the FA Cup in 1990 it secured Alex Ferguson’s position at the club and pointed the way to more silverware in the future. The Cup Winners Cup followed in 1991 and the League Cup in 1992 but the league title itself remained elusive. After coming a close second to Leeds United in 1991/92, they looked to have put a critical piece in the jigsaw the following season when they signed talisman Eric Cantona from the champions.

The Frenchman’s arrival produced an upturn in the club’s form and fortunes, and they climbed to the top of the table. But a poor run of results in March saw them arrive in April third in a three-way tussle for supremacy with Aston Villa and Norwich City. They began the month with a critical 3-1 win at Carrow Road that put them into second, but they still trailed Villa by a point. To retain momentum they would need to follow up their win over Norwich with another, five days later, at home to Sheffield Wednesday.

Wednesday sat in the top half of the table and had led United by three in the reverse fixture before a superb second half fightback saw the Reds pull back the deficit to draw. At Old Trafford, the visitors put up a sturdy defence going in level at half time, then silenced the home crowd after the break when Paul Ince gave away a penalty with a rash challenge on Chris Waddle. At 0-1 down the game, and potentially the league title, looked to be slipping from United’s grasp.

Enter captain Steve Bruce. Bruce, more used to stopping goals at the other end, was at best an occasional goal scorer. He had three to his name so far in the season, but only one was from open play. Still nothing ventured, nothing gained. With four minutes left in the game and United still trailing, he came forward for a corner after Wednesday keeper Chris Woods saved well from Mark Hughes. As the ball came over, Bruce met it perfectly with his head, and saw his header sail across and over Woods into the net. 1-1 now and United had saved a crucial point. Could they get more?

They obviously thought so. They continued to press forward and won another corner with just over a minute on the clock. Giggs’ effort was returned to him, then his cross missed everyone and rolled seemingly harmlessly to the right flank. This time it was Bruce’s fellow centre back, Gary Pallister, also up with the attack, who made a key contribution. He chased the ball down and crossed it back to the box. An inadvertent flick-on from a Wednesday defender and there was Bruce, steaming in from the left, to power in a second header.

The reaction of the players was ecstatic, but it was nothing compared to Ferguson and his assistant Brian Kidd who both ran onto the pitch, arms aloft, jumping up and down uncontrollably. Barry Davis commentating for the BBC wryly observed “there’s still a bit to be done but Brian Kidd and Alex Ferguson are almost celebrating the championship”.

If they were a little premature, they were not wrong. The last minute Wednesday win was the spark for United to go and win all of their remaining games while Villa and Norwich both faltered. The title was back in United’s hands after a 26-year absence. Now they had grabbed the trophy they would relinquish their grip with great reluctance.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cm9CzcbHzlY

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/30th-anniversary-of-man-utd-2-1-sheffield-wednesday-in-1993-premier-league-title-run-in

5. Cantonaaaa!

When United won the inaugural Premier League in 1993, their first league title in 26 years, not many would have predicted that they would win it seven more times in the next decade. Most teams struggle to retain the trophy once, let alone win it multiple times. United, though, had a special ingredient, Eric Cantona. Cantona brought skill, vision, intensity, strength and a never-say-die attitude to the team. He was one of those players who made everyone around him better.

There are so many great Cantona moments it’s difficult to single out just one, but a stand-out was the Manchester derby of 1993/94. United had made a stellar start to the season, winning 11 and drawing one of their first 13 games. A strike force of Hughes, Kanchelskis, Giggs, Sharpe and, of course, Cantona was proving irresistible and United sat comfortably atop the league. A visit to Maine Road, though, could always prove tricky. So, it proved. Two headed goals from Niall Quinn saw United go in two down at the break.

It took only a few minutes for Cantona to change the course of the game. First, he capitalised on a poor defensive header by City’s Michel Vonk to drill the ball past opposition keeper, Tony Coton. Then on 77 minutes he was again in the right place at the right time, finishing a move that he had himself started with a far post tap in to bring the scores level. Commentator Martin Tyler described Cantona “as though he’s got a baton in his hand and is conducting the orchestra”. The Frenchman was not involved in the winner, a Roy Keane finish at the far post from a Lee Sharpe cross, but his relentless probing had put City on the back foot throughout the second half.

United went on to defend their title, the third consecutive title for Cantona after he won it with Leeds in 1992. When he was finished with United he had won four titles in his five years, the only ‘failure’ being when he was suspended after the kung-fu moment. There may have been better players for United over the years, but there have probably never been any as influential and significant.

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/best-manchester-derbies-man-utd-v-man-city-video-highlights-and-digital-collectible

Other classic Cantona moments:

  • United 5-0 Sunderland, Dec 1996 – a great dribble, one-two with McClair, incredible chip over the keeper, then the coolest celebration ever
  • Wimbledon 0-3 United, FA Cup, Feb 1994 – one touch then a volley from outside the box. Swaggering and imperious
  • United 2-2 Liverpool, Oct 1995 – a goal on his very first game back from his suspension
  • Newcastle 0-1 United, Mar 1996 – a back post volley in a win critical to United overhauling Newcastle’s 12-point lead at the top
  • United 1-0 Arsenal, Mar 1996 – one touch on the chest then a thunderbolt to beat David Seaman
  • Liverpool 0-1 United, FA Cup final 1996 – a late winner to clinch the double
  • Sheffield United vs United, FA Cup 1995 – an exquisite chip from the edge of the box

6. The wonder goal – United v Arsenal, FA Cup Semi Final 1999

The Treble-winning season of 1998/99 has rightly been written into United legend as the greatest season ever. It’s easy to forget, though, how close they came to winning nothing. The team that pushed them hardest in both League and FA Cup was Arsenal. In the League, United didn’t lose a match for five months, but still only finished a single point above Arsenal. In the FA Cup the two fought out an epic semi-final.

United had not entirely convinced in the competition, beating Fulham by a single goal, then Liverpool only with an amazing late comeback, before needing a replay to get past Chelsea in the quarters. A replay was needed again in the semis after a 0-0 draw at Villa Park. Returning to Villa Park, Beckham opened the scoring with a long-range strike in the first half, before Bergkamp equalised with an equally long (deflected) shot in the second. The game looked headed for extra time when, in added time, Phil Neville upended Ray Parlour to gift Arsenal a penalty. Surely the great Bergkamp would convert and send his team to the final. To United’s surprise and huge relief he didn’t.  Schmeichel guessed right, diving to his left to palm the ball away.

Extra time beckoned, but United would have to face it without Roy Keane who had been sent off. It was backs-to-the-wall stuff, but United hung on well for twenty minutes. Then a loose ball from Patrick Vieira was collected in his own half by Ryan Giggs. The Welshman immediately set off, first leaving Vieira in his wake. He was not finished, weaving inside and out past England defenders Martin Keown and Lee Dixon, before getting into position to shoot. Despite another England international, Tony Adams, attempting a desperate block, Giggs pulled the trigger. His shot passed Dave Seaman before the keeper had a chance to move.

If the goal itself was memorable, Giggs’ celebration was even more unforgettable. He pulled off his shirt to reveal his gloriously hairy chest and sprinted back up the pitch twirling his shirt over and over in the air. One of the greatest FA Cup moments of all time, it was certainly a critical moment in United’s epic season.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/av/football/46840751

7. The second leg – United 3-0 Barcelona (United win 3-2 on aggregate), March 1984

Although United’s 1984 Cup Winners Cup campaign ended in a semi-final defeat to Juventus, the quarter final provided a comeback to end all comebacks. And many who were there claim that the atmosphere in the second leg was the greatest ever experienced at Old Trafford.

Barca were perhaps not quite the force they were to become in the next decade, but still boasted within their ranks the great Diego Maradona and Germany’s midfield supremo, Bernd Schuster, and were managed by Argentina’s World Cup winning Cesar Luis Menotti. They had shown their mettle in a dominant 2-0 victory at the Camp Nou, leaving United with it all to do in the return at Old Trafford.

United’s strength was in midfield, with Bryan Robson and Ray Wilkins ably supported by Dutchman Arnold Muhren and Remi Moses. And it was Robson who started the revival, scoring with a far post header after the relatively unheralded Graham Hogg had nodded on a corner. Captain Courageous added a second just after the break, getting first to a rebound from the keeper, and following a howler of a defensive error from Barca. When two minutes later, Frank Stapleton scored the third, heading in from a pinpoint Arthur Albiston cross, United were ahead on aggregate and the crowd were going absolutely ballistic.

With away goals counting double, United needed not to concede in the rest of the game, and they managed this relatively comfortably. Barcelona had never been beaten after taking a 2-0 lead in a tie but United, backed by the incredible support of their fans, had done it. Sadly, they were to be undone in the semi-final by another European power house, Juventus, who scored a last minute goal in another dramatic second leg to win by 3-2.

Juventus’ opponents in the final were Porto, who had also squeezed past a British club in the semis. They had beaten the unexpected holders of the trophy, Aberdeen. And who was Aberdeen’s manager? None other than Alex Ferguson, two years away from joining United and already achieving great things.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2020/may/12/my-favourite-game-manchester-united-v-barcelona-cup-winners-cup-1984

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/my-dream-match-ray-wilkins-man-utd-3-barcelona-0-1984

8. Hello Wayne! – United 6-2 Fenerbahce, Sept 2004

Wayne Rooney burst into the public eye aged only 16-years-old with a wonder goal on his debut for Everton against Arsenal. He gained his first cap for England less than a year later, becoming at 17 his country’s youngest-ever goalscorer. At 18 he signed for the biggest club in the land.

If United had any doubts about the youngster, they were brushed aside in his incredible debut performance for the club. His introduction came in the Champions League, in a home tie against Fenerbahce of Turkey.

It took only 17 minutes for him to make his mark. United were already 1-0 up when Ruud van Nistelrooy collected the ball just inside the Fenerbahce half. He found Rooney making a diagonal right-to-left run and the youngster shot first time with his left foot. His strike bulleted into the net. 11 minutes later, Giggs played a short pass to Rooney outside the box. A feint to his right, a little touch to control, then another supremely clean strike, this time with the right foot, saw him beat the Turkish keeper low to his right. Come the second half everyone was excitedly wondering whether Rooney could get his hat-trick. His opportunity came on 54 minutes when a free kick was awarded on the edge of the box. With extraordinary coolness, he stepped up and curled a beaut into the top left corner. Three goals on debut was a hell of a way to start.

Rooney, of course, went on to become one of the legends of Manchester United and England. He scored 183 Premier League goals for the club in 393 appearances and a record 253 goals in total. He won five PL titles, five domestic cups and two European titles. His incredible debut performance was no flash in the pan, it was merely an aperitif for what was to come.

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/2311879/rooney-grabs-debut-hat-trick

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZ3Uv0tfPkk

9. The emotional return – United 3-0 Sheffield Wednesday, 1958

The Munich Air Disaster robbed United of pretty much their entire first team. As well as the eight players who tragically died, two (Blanchflower and Berry) suffered such severe injuries that they never played again, and others (Viollet, Scanlon, Wood and Charlton) took time to recover before they returned to action. The side that would represent United in their first fixture after the tragedy would bear little resemblance to the side they had had before.

There was some dispensation given by the football authorities to United regarding fulfilling their fixtures, but nowhere near as much as you might have thought. The crash took place on 6th February… United’s first game back was a mere 13 days later. United’s stand-in manager, assistant Jimmy Murphy, had to work miracles to pull a side together, but selected a bunch of United’s youth players plus crash survivors Bill Foulkes and Harry Gregg, and (very) late signing, Stan Crowther from Aston Villa.

The visitors were Sheffield Wednesday for a fifth round FA Cup tie. The match was a sell-out with many more fans outside to pay their respects. The atmosphere was sombre beforehand, but raw and passionate once the whistle sounded. The United eleven played like men possessed, fighting for every ball, chasing down the opposition, playing not only for themselves but for their departed colleagues. And there was plenty of skill on show as well.

The young team scored three without reply. 20-year-old full back Shay Brennan, playing as a winger, scored direct from a corner on thirty minutes. He then doubled the lead in the second half before the young Scot, Alex Dawson, two days before his 18th birthday added a third. United’s hastily cobbled together team had somehow risen from the ashes to win their first game back. There would be many challenges ahead, but this bittersweet victory had at least brought some hope and enjoyment to the club and its supporters.

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/old-trafford-greatest-games-5-sheff-wed-1958

10. Terry’s gift – UEFA Champions League Final, May 2008

The arrival in 2004 of Portuguese manager, Jose Mourinho, at Chelsea shook up not only his own club but also the whole of the Premier League. For twelve years the title had been dominated by United with only Arsenal (and, for one season only, Blackburn) presenting a real and consistent challenge. Under the self-proclaimed ‘special one’, there was a new challenger to United’s, and indeed Alex Ferguson’s supremacy. Mourinho transformed his team into winners, and in his first full season, 2004/05, they comfortably won the title (losing only one game all season), before following it up with another win the next year.

Ferguson was too good and too determined to concede anything to his new adversary. and he led United back to the top in 2006/07 with Chelsea coming in second. Although Mourinho left in 2007 (not the first or last time he fell out with the owners of the club he was managing), Chelsea remained United’s closest competitors.  

In 2008 the competition between the two clubs reached a new, higher level. The Premier League was close throughout and went to the final day, but United came out on top by two points to retain their title. The two then had another chance to show who was best in that year’s Champions League final. United had made it past a very strong Barcelona side in their semi-final, Chelsea had scraped past Liverpool in theirs. The first ever final to feature two English sides would be staged in Moscow.

History was perhaps on United’s side. It was the 100th anniversary of their first Division One title, the 40th anniversary of their first European Cup in 1968, and, more poignantly, the 50th anniversary of the Munich air crash. History, though, doesn’t win you anything. 

After a cagey start, the final was a decent contest. United opened the scoring through a Ronaldo header in the 26th minute. Frank Lampard equalised for Chelsea just before the interval. There were chances at both ends, but the game finished level at 1-1 so went into extra time. Extra time also saw opportunities but the deadlock was not broken, so the cup would have to be decided by penalties.

United went first in the shoot-out and both teams scored their first two efforts. Surprisingly it was Cristiano Ronaldo who was first to falter, striking a weak penalty that Chelsea keeper Petr Cech beat away easily. Chelsea’s penalty takers meanwhile were impeccable and took the score to 4-4 with just captain, John Terry, to take the final penalty and seal the deal. To the great delight of United fans across the world, ‘Mr Chelsea’ slipped as he got to the ball and sent the ball onto the outside of the right post and away. United, unexpectedly, were back from the dead.

It now seemed as though the gods were with United. With the shoot-out now in sudden-death, successful kicks from Anderson and Giggs meant it was down to Frenchman Nicolas Anelka to keep Chelsea in the contest. His kick was too close to Van der Sar who went the right way and saved it. United had won their third Champions League and had the added satisfaction of doing so against their fiercest opponents. And Alex Ferguson had once again proved himself to be the only boss.  

11. Duncan Edwards’ last game – Arsenal 4–5 United, Feb 1958

He was the best player I ever saw, or am likely to see in my life. If I was asked to name a team of the players I played with, his name would be the first one I would put in, no question about it.” These were the words of arguably England’s greatest ever player, Sir Bobby Charlton, when asked about Duncan Edwards.

In his brief career, Edwards made an incredible impression. Only 21 when he died of injuries sustained in the Munich air crash, he had already played over 150 games for United and 18 times for his country. He was considered the most complete player of his generation, a box-to-box midfielder equally at home breaking up opposition attacks or creating chances for his own side. Tall, strong and physical, he was equally adept with both left and right foot, and was capable of clever short interplay, width of the field passes and shots from outside the box.

Looking at old video, he looks like a blend of the best of Bryan Robson and Steven Gerrard. He had no discernible weaknesses, with legendary manager Matt Busby declaring “We looked at Duncan and gave up trying to spot flaws in his game”. Contemporaries were in no doubt that had he lived he would have gone on to be one of England’s greatest ever players.

His final game for United, indeed the tragic last domestic game for the Busby babes was a classic. They travelled to Highbury Stadium to face Arsenal. United’s first goal was not long in coming, fellow youngster Kenny Morgans crossing for Edwards to fire home. United went further ahead when Bobby Charlton, himself still only 20, fired home for 2-0, then added another on half time through Tommy Taylor.

Arsenal responded after the break with three quick goals to bring the scores level. But United, whose attack was running on all cylinders, were not to be stopped. Goals for Viollet and Taylor reinstated United’s lead before Arsenal pulled a late one back. A pulsating game finished with United winning 5-4. None of the 63,578 fans in attendance could have known what was to happen in Munich, but all would have left with memories of a superb side and of at least one brilliant footballer.  

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/duncan-edwards-tribute-article-ahead-of-munich-air-disaster-anniversary

12. The dog that saved United

In 1901 things were not going well at Newton Heath FC. The Manchester club had finished 10th in the Second Division and been knocked out of the FA Cup in the first round. Their travails on the pitch were matched by troubles off the pitch. Chronically short of cash and facing potential bankruptcy, the club had launched a four-day fundraising bazaar at St James’s Hall on Oxford Road. Their target, a meagre £1,000 (or £80,000 in today’s money) that would help secure the club’s survival. The fundraiser was not a success. Despite a contribution from local rivals, Manchester City, it fell well short of target, with some calculating that it had cost more than it had raised.

The ‘rank failure’ was made worse when a key participant in the fundraising effort, a giant St Bernard dog belonging to club captain, Harry Stafford, went missing. The dog, Major, had been a fixture at home matches, wandering through the crowd with a collection box around its neck.

Major’s disappearance, though, turned out to be a blessing in disguise. The dog turned up at a public house where he caught the attention of a wealthy local businessman, John Henry Davies. Davies, the Managing Director of the Manchester Brewers, took the dog home as a gift for his daughter, but then noticed an advertisement in the local paper that Stafford had placed looking for his lost pet. Davies immediately contacted Stafford and the two met.

It was this chance meeting that led to the two men discussing the plight of Newton Heath. Davies was impressed by Stafford and by his passion for the club, so promised to help out. With Newton Heath on the brink of going out of business, Davies and three of his business associates offered £500 each to save the club and take control of it. Their offer was accepted and the Football Association agreed that the club could reform under a new name. After ‘Manchester Celtic’ and ‘Manchester Central’ were rejected the club agreed its new name. It was, of course, Manchester United.

https://vitalfootball.co.uk/the-end-of-newton-heath-fc-and-the-birth-of-manchester-united

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/how-a-missing-st-bernard-dog-helped-to-save-manchester-united-from-bankruptcy

13. Owen to the rescue – United 4–3 City, Sept 2009

When Michael Owen burst onto the scene in the late 1990s he looked a once-in-a-generation footballer. He scored on his Liverpool debut aged only 17, won the Premier League golden boot in his first full season and still aged only 18 was England’s most dangerous attacker in the 1998 World Cup. He won the BBC Sports Personality of the Year and became only the fourth Englishman ever to win the prestigious Ballon d’Or. Injuries meant that he never quite lived up to his early promise, but as he approached his thirties, he could still reflect on a pretty successful career.

One thing that was missing from Owen’s CV, despite all the goals, was a league title and it was perhaps for this reason that he accepted a ‘pay as you play’ deal with Manchester United in 2009. Whilst the deal did deliver that precious Premier League title for Owen, it perhaps delivered less for the team he had joined. To be fair, he did pretty well in cup games and in Europe, but in the league he scored only five times in 31 league games. Amongst these five, however, was one of the favourite goals scored for United in recent years.

The occasion was the first Manchester derby of the 2009/10 season hosted at Old Trafford. City had been taken-over in August 2008 by the Abu Dhabi United Group and were already spending heavily. Robinho, Gareth Barry, Roque Santa Cruz, Kolo Toure and Emmanual Adebayor had all been signed by the club, as, more controversially, had Carlos Tevez, making the jump across the city of Manchester. City were picking up steam, but still had a long way to go to get past United.

This derby was an epic. Wayne Rooney opened the scoring but an error from Ben Foster allowed Tevez to supply Gareth Barry for City’s first half equaliser. The game really came to life in the second half. Darren Fletcher scored twice but his goals were cancelled out by a brace from Craig Bellamy, the second coming in the 90th minute. Four minutes of added time were signalled, but referee Martin Atkinson allowed play to run on due to the length of City’s celebrations after the late equaliser. Added time had slipped into a sixth minute when Ryan Giggs collected a ball from a City clearance. He spotted Owen, on as a 79th minute substitute, in space on the left of the penalty area and passed to him. Owen took one touch to control the ball before sending it past Shay Given with the outside of his right foot. The TV commentators described it as “What a finish… one chance, one goal, brilliant”.

No-one was quite sure where the extra time had come from but no-one (other than City fans) really cared. Fergie time had once again made a welcome appearance, and Michael Owen had made his mark on United for posterity. 

Some other derby highlights from recent history

  • City 1 – 2 United, FA Cup Final 2024 – after a mediocre season a chance to stop City winning the double (and also gain revenge for the 2023 final). A great all-round performance from Mainoo, including a goal, helped United clinch the trophy
  • City 2 – 3 United, 2012/13 – a win that proved critical in dethroning the recent champions, 2-0 up then pulled back to 2-2 before a deliciously deflected winner from Robin van Persie.
  • United 5 – 0 City, 1994/95 – The biggest win in the derby included a hat-trick from Andrei Kanchelskis.
  • City 1 – 2 United, 2024/25 – In an otherwise dismal season, this was a rare shining light, late goals from Fernandes (pen.) and Amad delivering a turnoaround from 0-1 down.
  • City 2 – 3 United, 1993/94 – 2-0 down but an epic comeback spearheaded by Cantona (two goals) before a late winner from Roy Keane put United on track for the title.
  • United 2 – 1 City, 2010/11 – featuring one of the greatest goals of all time, Rooney’s overhead kick, to win it. Rooney admitted to having a real off day before the goal.

The best and worst of the Ashes

Like most of us, I approached this winter’s Ashes with some optimism. Sadly, it took only three deliveries for that optimism to be quashed, Zack Crawley once again falling to a waft outside off stump. Worse was the capitulation on day two of the first test. To lose a test in two days, when we started the day with a great chance of winning, was truly demoralising. And, Root and Bethell aside, things didn’t get much better in the rest of the series.

Well, this blog may cheer you up. It features 25 stories from the history of the Ashes, looking at great series and matches, great individual performances and great moments as well as a few of the worst. Obviously, what’s best to the England fan may be worst to the Australian but all the stories are, I hope, interesting.

If you feel I’ve missed anything please add your comments – the beauty of a blog is that it can always be rewritten.

Wishing you all an exciting series, with some success for England, this winter.

1. Mission impossible – Ben Stokes, Headingley 2019

The 2019 home Ashes pretty much had it all. A 2-2 tied series where at least four of the tests could have gone either way, and where great performances from some – Steve Smith, Pat Cummins, Ben Stokes, Jofra Archer – were balanced by mediocrity from others, in particular and to the great pleasure of England fans, David Warner. It also had possibly the most unlikely win for England in any era, in a test that provided thrills and spills and one of the greatest innings of all time.

The venue was Headingley, the test the third in the series. England had been well beaten in the first despite getting off to a strong start, then had seen Australia hang on for a draw in the second. They came to Headingley needing some sort of result if their opponents were not to hang on to the Ashes. They started well, bowling Australia out for only 179, but things went seriously south when England replied. Only one batter, Joe Denly, was able to reach double figures (and he scored just 12) as Australia’s high-class pace attack rolled England over. The score of 67 was the home side’s lowest since 1948.

In Australia’s second innings, England bowled well to restrict their opponents to 246 (frustratingly the top scorer was Marnus Labuschagne, in the side only due to a concussion suffered by Steve Smith) but that still left a mountain to climb. The target of 359 was greater than any run chase that England had ever achieved, and the first innings would hardly have filled the team with confidence.

When both England openers fell cheaply, victory looked out of the question, but a recovery was mounted by Joe Root and Denly, who put together an old-fashioned stand of 126 in 53 overs, almost twice the length of the entire first innings. When Denly fell, it brought all-rounder Ben Stokes to the crease. The version of Stokes that came out was unrecognisable from any previous version we had seen. On the ground where Geoffrey Boycott had scored his hundredth hundred (and many more) Stokes showed he could out-Boycott the great man, scoring only three singles from the first 73 balls that he faced. Once Root had gone, he batted more conventionally with Jonny Bairstow, and the two went to lunch needed ‘only’ another 121 runs but with six wickets still in hand.

In test cricket, most such run chases falter, with optimism giving way to realism as soon as wickets begin to fall. This was no exception. After lunch, Stokes found himself increasingly isolated as England collapsed to 286/9. 73 runs were still needed and Stokes could not rely on his partner, number 11 batsman Jack Leach, to contribute many of them. The plan, therefore, was simple. Stokes would hit out and try and retain the strike, Leach would simply survive when he had to.

The plan worked well. Despite the fielders being spread around the boundary, Stokes kept managing to clear the rope. Meanwhile, at the other end, Leach resisted doggedly when called upon. The target came down and down. A big scare came with only 17 left, when Stokes miscued and the ball sailed out to third man, but fielder Marcus Harris, who had endured a torried time in the series with the bat, failed to make the catch.

As the target approached, the tension both in the ground and in households across the UK and Australia ratcheted up and up. Then with just eight required Australia made a fatal error, going for their last DRS review on a ball clearly pitching outside Jack Leach’s leg stump. This was to come back and haunt them as with only two runs left to get, Stokes survived an LBW appeal, when DRS would have convicted him. There was also time on the same score for a comedy fielding error by the most experienced player on Australia’s side, spinner Nathan Lyon, that should have run out Leach and won the match for Australia.

The cricket gods, though, were clearly on Stokes’ and England’s side. After Leach had scored his first and only single in the partnership to level up the scores, Stokes crashed a ball from Pat Cummins to the boundary to complete an amazing innings and an incredible victory.

England cricket greats were fulsome in their praise. “The greatest ever innings by an Englishman” Alastair Cook;  “The most incredible performance by anyone, ever” David Gower;  “I’ve seen some remarkable cricket moments in my life, but that is the best I’ve seen in over 50 years” Geoffrey Boycott;  and the final word from his teammate Joe Root “He’s a bit of a freak”.

2. The return of the king – Ian Botham, Headingley 1981

Rarely has an Ashes series been dominated by just one individual, but at the end of the 1981 series there was only one name on peoples’ lips, that of Ian Terence Botham. Not only had the young all-rounder been the pivotal character in England’s series victory, but he had done so after plumbing the depths of despair earlier in the summer.

Botham, still only 25, was the undoubted star of English cricket. Since his test debut four years earlier, he had comfortably been England’s top wicket-taking bowler, added to which he had scored six centuries, normally in aggressive and entertaining style. His all-round talents had led to him being named captain of England in 1980, but it was then that his star began to tarnish. He had the misfortune to lead his side in two series against the dominant side of the time, the West Indies, but the responsibilities of captaincy seemed anyway not to suit him and his own form had been affected. He came to the 1981 series against Australia as captain but with no test wins under his belt and lacking confidence in his own game.

The first test was a low scoring affair in which Australia just managed to get over the line chasing down a target of 132 (they reached it with only four wickets in hand). The second test, at Lords, was drawn but it saw an almost unrecognisable Botham at his lowest ebb. He suffered the ignominy of his first pair (a duck in both innings), and was greeted with an eerie silence when he returned to the pavilion after his second dismissal. He resigned as captain immediately after the match, although it was thought by those in the know that he had done so only moments before he would have been sacked.

A lesser character might have slunk off to ‘regroup’ but not Botham. Freed from the pressure of captaincy, and once again under the guidance of his unlikely ‘svengali’ Mike Brearley, Botham staged an immediate Lazarus-like recovery, taking six wickets in Australia’s first innings in the third test at Headingley. He also top-scored, with 50, in England’s first innings but failures from his fellow batsmen meant that his team followed on. When wickets fell rapidly in the second innings, a defeat looked utterly inevitable. As England’s seventh wicket went down they were still almost 100 runs away from making Australia bat again, and Ladbrokes were offering 500-1 against an England win (a bet that Australians Dennis Lillee and Rodney Marsh were happy to make). It was then though that something remarkable happened.

Fast bowler Graham Dilley came out to join Botham at the crease.  “You don’t fancy hanging around on this wicket for a day and a half, do you?” said Botham to Dilley, who concurred. “Right. Come on, let’s give it some humpty.” Dilley was not much of a batsman with a previous test highest of 38, but he could hit the ball. Together the two added 117 in only 80 minutes flaying the ball to all parts.  Botham continued the assault after Dilley was out, adding 104 more with first Chris Old then Bob Willis. One of his straight sixes, off Terry Alderman, elicited the memorable commentary from Richie Benaud “Don’t bother looking for that, let alone chasing it. That’s gone straight into the confectionery stall and out again”. When Willis was finally out, England had scored 356 and Botham was 149 not out.

Notwithstanding his incredible effort, Australia were still hot favourites to win, requiring only 130 runs. Botham, for once, relinquished the limelight in favour of one of his teammates. After taking the first wicket, he handed over match-winning responsibilities to fast bowler Bob Willis. Willis, wicketless in the first innings, ran in like a man possessed. Australia collapsed from 56-1 to 75-8, with Willis taking six of the seven wickets to fall. A brief fightback from Ray Bright and Dennis Lillee threatened to turn the game back Australia’s way, but Willis was not to be denied. When Ray Bright was bowled, England had won a gripping and unforgettable test by 18 runs.

Botham, freed from the shackles of captaincy, was unstoppable in the rest of the series. He produced a match-winning spell of five wickets for one run to clinch the fourth test, a match-winning hundred in the fifth test, and took a further 10 wickets in the final, drawn, test. The man who had been down and out at Lords had become an all-time legend in the space of an incredible six weeks.

3. The squeakiest bum time – Edgbaston 2005

The 1990s and early noughties were a barren and desolate period for England in the Ashes. After a crushing home series defeat in 1989 (0-4 that could easily have been 0-6 without the helpful intervention of rain) England had been decidedly second-best for the next 16 years and seven series.

The 2005 home Ashes saw a reversal of fortunes in what many believe to be the greatest and most entertaining series ever. England had been improving steadily under the leadership of captain Michael Vaughan and coach Duncan Fletcher, but Australia remained the dominant force in world cricket. The visitors had lost only one test series in over six years (away to India in 2001) and boasted a team of all talents in all departments of the game. Their bowling was especially strong, led by two of the greatest wicket-takers and match-winners of all-time, Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath.

It was McGrath who struck first, taking nine wickets in the first test at Lords to quash a promising England start and lead the Aussies to victory. England had, though, in defeat put a shot across the bows of their visitors with some aggressive fast bowling, and a promising performance from debutant Kevin Pietersen.

The second test at Edgbaston was an absolute epic. England, enjoying the absence of McGrath from the Australian bowling line up (the stray cricket ball that he stood on before play should be mounted in the Edgbaston trophy cabinet), batted well to get to 407 in their first innings, before bowling out the tourists out for a lead of 99. Shane Warne then delivered one his many masterclasses against England, taking six wickets (including a ball to Andrew Strauss every bit as remarkable as the one that bowled Gatting in 1989) as the home side were scuttled out for only 182. A target of 282 looked eminently doable for the strong Australian batting line-up.

England’s bowlers had, however, shown that they could take Australian wickets and so it proved. All five bowlers chipped in and with Australia at 140-7 on the third day (this test had moved very fast) England claimed the extra half hour to try and force a result. It looked a forlorn hope until, with the final ball of the day, Steve Harmison conjured up a beautifully disguised slower ball to utterly bamboozle Australia’s last recognised batsman, Michael Clarke. Stumps were drawn with Australia on 175-8, still needing over 100 and with only lower order batsman Warne, Brett Lee and Mike Kasprowicz available to score them.

What followed on the fourth morning was one of the most engrossing and excruciating pieces of drama ever served up on a British sports field. The morning started with Warne and Lee adding 45 before Warne trod on his stumps avoiding a full ball from Flintoff. With 62 still required England were hot favourites, but Lee and Kasprowicz could not be moved. England’s bowling and fielding became a little ragged as the Aussies accumulated runs and got closer and closer to the target. A (difficult) missed catch at third man by Simon Jones seemed to symbolise England’s collective loss of nerve. Then, with only three required, Kasprowicz faced up to Harmison. A short ball was directed at the Australian’s body and in trying to protect himself he gloved the ball down the leg side. Keeper Geraint Jones flung himself to his left and just held on to the catch. When umpire Billy Bowden signalled it was out, the whole of Edgbaston erupted.

In the midst of one great sporting moment, we witnessed another as Freddie Flintoff went over to commiserate with a disconsolate Brett Lee in a touching act of sportsmanship. Even amongst the euphoria and relief it was possible to feel for the opposition … until the next match at least.

4. Bodyline – Australia, 1932/3

In November 1928 a young Australian batsman by the name of Donald Bradman made his debut in the first test against England at Brisbane. It was not a great success (Bradman scored only 18 and 1 in what was a crushing defeat for his team – England won by a massive margin of 675 runs) and the 20-year-old was dropped for the following match. It was to be a short exile. Recalled for the third test, Bradman scored his first century. He never looked back. Within a couple of years, the South Australian had become the most feared batsman in cricket, utterly dominant against every type of bowling and capable of scoring big runs whenever and wherever they were needed.

When England toured Australia in 1932/33 they had one principal objective. Stop Bradman. They had vivid memories of the 1930 home series where Bradman had hit England’s bowlers to all corners in scoring 974 runs (still a record in a series), and knew that their only chance on away soil would be if they could neutralise the world’s best batsman.

The tactic they developed became known as ‘bodyline’ or ‘leg theory’ and its use made the series the most controversial in cricket history. The idea of bodyline was simple – direct fast short-pitched bowling at the batsman’s legs and body and flood the leg side with fielders (there were no restrictions at this time on where you could place fielders). Batsmen who were aggressive would risk being caught pulling or hooking, those who were more fearful would fend off to short fielders or, in some cases, get injured. England had two very quick and strong bowlers – Harold Larwood and Bill Voce – and they would lead this hostile attack against the Australian batsmen.

The first Test, played in Sydney, did not actually feature Bradman who was in dispute with the Australian cricket administrators. Leg theory was still employed, with Larwood and Voce taking 16 wickets between them in a 10-wicket win for England. Only Stan McCabe of Australia stood firm, making an unbeaten 187 in an innings still rated amongst the best ever played in his country. Bradman returned for the second Test where he was dismissed first ball in the first innings, playing on trying to hook. An unbeaten century in the second innings, though, propelled Australia to a 111-run victory, and there was some talk that maybe bodyline was not all it was cracked up to be.

The talk changed during the third Test. After England were bowled out for 341, Australia came into bat in front of a crowd of over 50,000. In the third over, delivered by Larwood, Aussie skipper Bill Woodfull narrowly avoided a head high bouncer before being struck just over the heart with the next ball. As Woodfull staggered around the wicket and with the crowd in uproar, England captain Douglas Jardine, the architect of the strategy and an uncompromising competitor, pointedly called “Well bowled, Harold!” to his bowler. When Woodfull next faced Larwood, Jardine adjusted the field to place more fielders on the leg side. There was more tumult in the ground, but the game continued.

Later that day the England manager, Pelham (Plum) Warner visited the Australian dressing room to express sympathy to the Australian captain. He was met with a frosty and hostile response with Woodfull uttering the famous words “I don’t want to see you, Mr Warner. There are two teams out there. One is trying to play cricket and the other is not.” When this exchange was leaked to the press, the flames were fanned even further.

Matters were not helped after a rest day when Australia resumed their first innings. Wicket keeper Bert Oldfield had been leading a fightback with Bill Ponsford when he edged another bouncer from Larwood into his head, fracturing his own skull. The crowd seemed on the verge of a riot, although it was thankfully averted.

Riot or not, the match and the series came very close to being called off following an exchange of cables between the MCC and the Australian Board of Control that led to a full-blown diplomatic incident. The Australian cable contained the lines “(Bodyline) In our experience is unsportsmanlike, Unless stopped at once likely to upset friendly relations between Australia and England.” The MCC’s response was extremely robust “We deplore your cable. We deprecate your opinion that there has been unsportsmanlike play. We have the fullest confidence in our captain, team and managers and are sure that they would do nothing to infringe either the laws of cricket or the spirit of the game.”  The situation was only defused when the Australians climbed down from their accusation of poor sportsmanship, almost certainly influenced by diplomats fearful of trade sanctions being imposed by Britain.

The tour continued in pretty poor odour, with bodyline tactics occasionally deployed by England, but generally with more conventional cricket. England managed to win the final two tests to capture a rare away series victory by 4-1.

There was still some bad blood when the two sides next met, in England in 1934. But England were without Larwood, Voce and, perhaps most critically, their captain Jardine. Bradman if not quite hitting the heights of four years earlier, still managed 758 runs at average of 95, and helped his side to a 2-1 series victory. Captain Bill Woodfull would doubtless have enjoyed this ‘revenge’ as much as anyone.

5. The ball of the century – Shane Warne, Old Trafford 1993

On the 2nd of January 1992 an inexperienced Australian leg-spinner made his debut in test cricket against India. It was an inauspicious start. Figures of 1-150 from 45 overs were followed by 0-78 in his next test before he was dropped. Recalled for the tour to Sri Lanka, his figures improved only slightly. The selectors might, at this point, have given up on him. Thankfully for Australian cricket, indeed for world cricket, they did not, and the marvel that was Shane Keith Warne graced the game of cricket for years to come.

He began to show his class in series against West Indies and New Zealand, but it was against England in 1993 that he really arrived. The first Test that year was played at Old Trafford. Australia had batted first, and posted a disappointing total of only 289 after having been 183/1. Unusually for the first day of a test in England, eight of the wickets had gone to spin. The home side’s reply began solidly and when the first wicket fell at 71, it brought together England’s two most experienced batsmen, Mike Gatting and Graham Gooch. With these two looking relatively comfortable, Australian captain Allan Border turned to his young leg spinner hoping for a breakthrough. He got his breakthrough, and how!  

Warne trotted up with his short run and rolled his arm over. The ball was flighted down the leg side, with the spin causing it to swing slightly further to leg. It pitched well outside the line of leg stump and Gatting, judged to be the best player of spin in the England side, plonked his front leg down with his bat tucked in behind his pad to cover any possible movement of the ball. The next thing he heard was the sound of the ball clipping his off stump. Gatting was incredulous and stood his ground for a second or two. Surely the ball must have rebounded off the Australian keeper back into the stumps.

In fact, as we all know now, Warne had spun the ball prodigiously and it had shot across Gatting at an angle no batsman in the world could have predicted or played. With one ball Warne had changed the face of test cricket. When he retired from test cricket 14 years later he had taken over 700 wickets (almost 200 against England) and had played a massive part in the most successful test team in history. This incredible delivery the start of more than a decade of greatness.

6. The demon and the birth of the Ashes – Fred Spofforth, 1882

In 1878 a 6ft 3in Australian well and truly announced himself to the cricketing world. Playing for his Australian touring side at Lords, the 24-year-old Frederick Spofforth helped dismiss the MCC, the de facto England team of the time, for scores of 33 and 19. He helped himself to 10 wickets at a cost of only 20 runs, and could count the great WG Grace, clean bowled for a duck, amongst his victims. On his return to the dressing room he reportedly said “Ain’t I a demon? Ain’t I a demon?” and so his sobriquet of ‘the Demon’ was born.

On his day, which came pretty regularly and reliably, Spofforth was close to unplayable. He demonstrated this to devastating effect in the only test of the 1882 tour to England, played at the Oval. On what was clearly a difficult pitch for batting, Australian scored only 63 in their first innings. When England replied, Spofforth prevented them from taking a significant lead, taking seven wickets, including the last four in 11 overs for the cost of only one scoring shot, a two. Australia fared a little better in their second than they had in their first but at least set a target for England to clinch the victory, just 85 runs. Spofforth refused to concede victory telling his teammates “Boys, this thing can be done”. And it could.

England, got off to a solid start in their chase and were within 20 runs of victory with only four wickets down. A flurry of wickets, though, saw them collapse, losing their remaining six wickets for the addition of a dismal 11 runs. They had fallen to a seven-run defeat with ‘the demon’ taking 14 wickets, seven in each innings, at a cost of only 90 runs.

Following the loss, the Sporting Times published a mock obituary for English cricket. It read “In Affectionate Remembrance of English Cricket, which died at the Oval on 29th August, 1882. Deeply lamented by a large circle of sorrowing friends and acquaintances. R.I.P.” then the killer line: “N.B. The body will be cremated and the ashes taken to Australia.” And so, the legend of the Ashes was born with the famous urn making its appearance the following year.

Spofforth, who had done so much to take ‘the ashes’ to Australia, eventually settled in England, becoming a tea merchant in Derbyshire.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2013/jun/27/20-great-ashes-moments-fred-spofforth

7. The day of the squeegees – The Oval, 1968

1968 saw two relatively evenly matched sides come together to contest the Ashes. With each game in the balance at some point, it could have been one of the great series, but after Australia edged the first Test, both the second and third were spoiled by rain with England ahead in both. The fourth might have produced a win for either side but finished in a draw, all of which meant that England went into the final Test at the Oval trailing by 0-1.

Centuries from Edrich and D’Oliveira helped England to a total of 494 in their first innings, good enough for a lead of 170 after Australia had replied. England then set Australia a target, a stiff 352 to either chase or survive for just over the day of play that remained. The visitors got off to a poor start, and stood at a precarious 86 for 5 when they were reprieved by a light shower just before lunch on the fifth day. The Australians must then have been delighted to see this shower transform over lunch into a freak rainstorm that flooded the playing area. The game surely could not go on and the series must be theirs.

Or maybe not. As fast as the rain had come, it went and the sun came out. If the water could be mopped up, perhaps the game could restart. Unfortunately, it quickly became clear that there were not enough groundstaff available to mop up the water. England captain had a brainwave – why not get the crowd involved. He invited them over the loudspeakers and hundreds volunteered to help. Using whatever cloth they could get their hands on – jackets, blankets, handkerchiefs – they tried to soak up the water. By 4:45pm the impossible had been achieved and the ground was judged ready for play.

This left just 75 minutes (no extension was given despite the rain) for England to take the remaining five wickets. The pitch, now a ‘sticky dog’, was helpful but England could just not take a wicket. After forty agonising minutes, they finally broke through when Basil D’Oliveira, the all-rounder, bowled Australian keeper. Spinner Derek Underwood was brought back on and struck immediately with two wickets in an over. Aussie spinner Jack Gleeson survived for a bit before he fell, leaving England 12 minutes to capture the final wicket. Finally, with only five minutes left on the clock, opening batsman John Inverarity, who had defended stoutly throughout the whole innings, padded up to an arm ball from Underwood and was given out LBW. England had won the Test by the skin of their teeth and squared the series. Those whose jackets and other items had been soaked and potentially ruined must have felt thoroughly delighted.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2020/may/09/my-favourite-game-england-australia-fifth-ashes-test-1968-the-oval-cricket

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/cricket/8062579.stm

8. The ‘stumping’ – Jonny Bairstow / Alex Carey, Lords 2023

Cricket is a game with a vast array of rules, but it’s also a game of customs and practices in which playing the game in the right spirit is (or at least has been) considered as important as keeping within those rules. Not claiming a catch that you know you didn’t take cleanly, walking when you’ve nicked it, admitting you’ve stepped on the boundary rope when fielding – all of these and many, many more are ways of playing the game ‘the right way’. Although much of this sportsmanship has gone out of the professional game in recent years (indeed it was probably never quite as well-mannered in the past as some like to think), there are still certain things that are considered beyond the pale.

The 2023 Ashes series threw up an incident that many (mainly English) felt went completely against the spirit of cricket. The Australians had won an extremely tight first test at Edgbaston, and the second, at Lords, looked like it was headed to another close finish. England were chasing a big total of 371, but had shown under captain Ben Stokes and coach Brendon McCullum that anything was possible. When Jonny Bairstow, came to the crease to join Stokes at 177/5, victory was unlikely but both were explosive batsman who could knock big lumps out of the target.

Bairstow had progressed calmly to 10 when he faced the last ball of a Cameron Green over. He evaded a bouncer then stepped out of his crease, as he often did, to pat down the spot where the ball had pitched. Aussie keeper, Alex Carey, having caught the ball, saw Bairstow out of his crease and under-armed it back to the stumps hitting them. Australia, to everyone’s surprise, appealed for a stumping. As the ball was not deemed to be dead at the point where Bairstow had left his crease, he was, according to the letter of the law, out and the umpires had no choice but to send him on his way. Australia could, as had happened in similar incidents in the past, have withdrawn their appeal and allowed the umpires to reinstate Bairstow, but they elected not to do so.

England – team, management, supporters and, in this case infamously, Lords members – were shocked and appalled. The Australians, in their quest to win the test (which they went on to do despite another incredible innings from Ben Stokes) had committed an unpardonable act of poor sportsmanship. Thousands of column inches were dedicated to discussing it. In England it was universally condemned, in Australia it was either praised or at the very least excused.

Perhaps it was worth it, but the main upshot for the Aussies (as well as outrage) was that they succeeded in firing up not only the England team but also the whole of the country. From 2-0 down, and with crowds barracking the Aussies – particularly Carey and captain Cummins – at every opportunity, the home side fought back to square the series. They would have won the series had it not rained in Manchester. Perhaps the cricketing gods were getting a little bit of revenge on those who had so flagrantly betrayed the spirit of the game.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-8Rrb7yd6o

9. Utterly unplayable – Jim Laker, Old Trafford 1956

In all sports, records are there to be broken. Bob Beamon’s long jump, Mark Spitz’s seven gold medals on one Games, Hank Aaron’s career home runs, Bobby Charlton’s goals … all looked unbeatable until one day they were. It’s safe, though, to say that one record in cricket will never be beaten – Jim Laker’s 19 wickets in one Test match in 1956. 9 for 37 in the first innings, 10 for 53 in the second, an incredible 19 for 90 in the match. And this on a pitch where his fellow spinner, Tony Lock, no mug with the ball, took only one wicket in 69 overs.

Laker was helped by the pitch, but perhaps more so by the inexperience of the Australians in facing right arm finger spin, or off-spin. Pitches in Australia had become so unresponsive to finger-spin that the off-break had largely disappeared from the game there, with pace and wrist-spin prevailing. The Aussie batsmen found it difficult to line themselves up against the ball spinning in to them, particularly with Laker coming from round the wicket, so became vulnerable to LBWs and, particularly, to catches close to the wicket. Laker had, incredibly, already taken 10 wickets in an innings in an earlier match against the tourists – 10/88 for his county Surrey – so felt he had something of a psychological advantage over them. Twenty wickets in the first three Tests showed that his confidence was warranted.

At Old Trafford he took things onto a whole new level. England batted first and amassed a big score of 459. Australia’s reply actually got off to a decent start, but Laker struck twice with the score on 48. Once Lock had taken the third wicket, his only one of the match, Laker went on a tear, polishing off the innings with a spell of 7 for 8 in just 22 balls. Following on, the Australians defended more stoutly, even managing (with the help of some rain) to take the game into the final session of the match. But Laker kept chipping away, and when he trapped wicketkeeper Len Maddocks leg before wicket it was all over. Laker had taken all 10 and Australia had been beaten by an innings.

Celebrations were somewhat more muted in 1956 than they are in modern times. After taking his 19th and final wicket, Laker simply took his sweater from the umpire, tossed it over his shoulder, shook hands with a couple of his teammates and walked off the pitch. The crowd swarmed around him, but he looked quite unmoved. He had to stick around to do a few press interviews, but left Old Trafford around 8pm. His reward for his phenomenal achievement – a pint and a sandwich, sitting quietly, unnoticed by the other customers in a local pub.

https://www.wisden.com/cricket-news/watch-jim-laker-first-bowler-19-wickets-test-match-10-innings-old-trafford-1956-ashes

10. The miracle spell – Stuart Broad, Trent Bridge 2015

The 2015 home Ashes was, according to Wisden, “a series that defied predictions, statistics, narrative, and at times appeared to defy even gravity”. It was a series in which every Test produced a one-sided result, but where you never knew beforehand which of the two sides would be the one to come out on top.  The first Test delivered a comfortable win for England, the second an even more emphatic victory for Australia, the third was back in England hands, this time in only three days. When the two teams arrived at Trent Bridge for the fourth Test it was at best educated guesswork as to whether either, both or neither would turn up. The answer, thumpingly, was England.

Stuart Broad is one of only five bowlers in the history of cricket to have taken over 600 test wickets. Of the five, only two, Broad and long-time teammate Jimmy Anderson, are pace bowlers. By any standards his career is exceptional, but Broad tends not to be ranked amongst the all-time great pacers, sitting behind the likes of McGrath, Hadlee, Lillee, Steyn and Marshall. Perhaps it’s because, unlike these, he could go through extended periods when he looked out of rhythm and unthreatening. When, however, he was on song, there were few better and his ability to bowl match-winning spells is up with the very best. So, it was on the first morning of the Trent Bridge Test of 2015.

The weather was damp and grey and the pitch a little green, so conditions looked tailor-made for seam. Winning the toss was critical, and once captain Alastair Cook had called correctly, he had no hesitation in putting Australia in to bat. With Anderson missing through injury, Broad was called upon to bowl the first over, his first time in four years. And what an over. Chris Rogers caught behind on the third ball and the dangerous Steve Smith nicking to slip on the sixth. Australia 10-2 after one over. Mark Wood then joined in the fun striking in the second over, before Broad took another in the third. 15-4. The coup de grace came in Broad’s third over when Adam Voges got a thick edge to a ball a little short of a length. It looked a certain boundary, but Ben Stokes leapt to his right from fifth slip and grasped it one-handed after it seemed to have already passed him. No-one who saw it could believe it. Stokes, like Botham in times past, had created another impossible piece of cricketing magic.

Australia did not last long. All out for 60, their innings had lasted only 111 balls, the shortest first innings in Test history. Broad’s 8-15 was the best Test analysis ever at Trent Bridge. England had no such problems and got to 274-4 on the first day for a decisive and humiliating lead of 214. Broad’s heroics, ably supported by Stokes, had given them a platform to win by an innings and clinch the series.

11. The king of the swingers – Bob Massie, Lords 1972

In 1970 the right-arm fast-medium swing bowling of Bob Massie produced figures of 3 for 166 in two trial matches for Northamptonshire second XI. The 23-year-old Australian was not offered a contract by the county, so returned home to try and cement his place in the Western Australia side and perhaps force his way into the thinking of the national team’s selectors.

This he managed, being selected for the unofficial 1971/72 series against a Rest of the World XI. An analysis of 7/76, which included the prized wicket of Gary Sobers, in his second outing saw him selected for the tour to England in 1972. His first cap proper was to come at the home of cricket, Lords, after England had won a low-scoring first Test at Old Trafford.

England at this time were a solid team that had not lost to Australia in the 11 previous tests. The batting line up was built on the experienced opening pair of Geoff Boycott and John Edrich and, if not especially exciting, was staffed with seasoned run-scorers. This was of no concern to Massie who exploited the swing-friendly conditions to take five wickets, including Boycott clean bowled, on the first day. When he polished off the innings on the second morning, he had become only the second bowler in test history to take eight wickets in his first innings – 8/84.

If England thought he was finished they were sadly disabused in the second innings. Massie, if anything, was even more potent, finishing with 8/53. His match figures of 16/137 were the best ever by a debutant (they were surpassed 16 years later by Narendra Hirwani of India with 16/136) and remain the fourth best analysis ever in Test cricket.

Massie’s career was unlikely to improve from this point, but it was still a surprise that it faded so quickly. He took five wickets in the third Test but was then relatively innocuous in the following two. He was selected for Australia’s home series that winter against Pakistan, but the third Test – when, oddly, it was his batting that shone – was the last he played for his country. In fact, he only played another five first class matches after this, but he had, in his brief Test career left an indelible mark and memory on the game.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2013/jul/16/the-spin-ashes-massies-match

12. The Jessop Miracle – Gilbert Jessop, The Oval 1902

The 1902 home series had already been conceded to Australia when the two sides met at The Oval for the fifth and final Test. The fact that it was dead rubber did not, though, stop it from becoming one of the most dramatic matches in Ashes history.

The hero was Gilbert Laird Jessop of Gloucestershire, a batsman renowned as the most dashing stroke player of his era. Relatively short (5ft 7in) but blessed with exceptionally quick footwork and a great eye for the ball, he scored runs from all types of bowling and all around the wicket. His approach to the game was to score runs as quickly as possible and, seemingly, to hell with defending. He was good enough to score over 26,000 runs in first-class cricket, but his cavalier attitude probably restricted his test career, which numbered only 18 appearances for England.

Jessop’s finest hour came in 1902 when England were set 263 to beat Australia. He came to the crease with his side destined for certain defeat at 48 for 5. Jessop decided, certainly not for the first time in his career, that attack was the best form of defence and set about the Australian bowling. His first 50 runs came in 43 minutes and his century in 75 minutes and off only 74 balls. It was not without some luck and, indeed unusually for Jessop, without some restraint (he suppressed his urge to hit across the line to top bowler Trumble) but it was still very very good. When he was out for 104 (out of 139 scored while he was at the crease) England had got to within sight of their target. It still required a lot of work, not least from Yorkshire’s George Hirst, but they managed to get across the line with just one wicket remaining.

The normally restrained Wisden recorded that “All things considered a more astonishing display has never been seen” and CB Fry added “I should say Jessop’s 104 must rank as the greatest innings by a pure hitter ever played.” His century remains the fastest ever scored by an Englishman in a Test, indeed it would have been even quicker had the rules on scoring sixes been the same as they are today (until 1907 a six was only awarded when the ball left the ground, not when it cleared the ropes). Even with today’s bigger bats and more aggressive approach it has not been beaten which shows just how remarkable Jessop’s innings was.

https://cricmash.com/clashes/ashes-1902-the-jessop-miraclehttps://www.espncricinfo.com/wisdenalmanack/content/story/155500.html

13. The fightback – Brisbane 2010/11

Having won the Ashes in thrilling style in 2009, England were desperate not to ‘do a 2006/7’ (losing the series 5-0 when holding the urn) when they arrived in Australia in 2010. The sides seemed evenly matched, with England perhaps having the stronger batting line-up, but Australia always dangerous bowling on home soil.  

The first test at Brisbane started worryingly. Opener Andrew Strauss was out for a duck, and despite reasonable knocks from Alastair Cook, Kevin Pietersen and Ian Bell, England were able to muster only 260 all out. When Australia ran up 481 with Michael Hussey and Brad Haddin both scoring hundreds, it suggested that England had really underachieved. They needed to make a statement in their second innings, otherwise the tour could become yet another walkover for the Aussies. Fortunately, something seemed to click.

Openers Strauss and Cook survived a tricky little period at the end of day three to close on 19-0. When stumps were drawn at the close of the following day’s play only one wicket had been lost and the score had moved on to 309-1. When England declared on the fifth afternoon the score was an incredible 517 still for the loss of only one wicket! Cook was unbeaten on 235* and Jonathan Trott on 135*. In 152 overs Australia had taken a single, solitary wicket.

As a statement of intent, nothing could have been clearer. England were showing that they had the skill and application to defeat the Australian bowlers, and that they would fight for every wicket. In the course of the series they put together previously unimaginable scores of 620-5, 513 and 644. Apart from a little upset at Perth they were unbeatable, grinding the spirit out of the Australians.

At the end of the series, as England celebrated a 3-1 series victory in an empty SCG, a peculiar sensation came over many England fans – were we feeling just a tiny bit sorry for the Aussies? No way! We knew they’d be back, and they were, so had to enjoy this victory to the maximum.

14. The substitute – Gary Pratt, Trent Bridge 2005

Gary Pratt was a decent cricketer, good enough to play first class cricket for Durham for a handful of seasons in the early 2000s. He would, though, be a forgotten footnote in the annals of cricketing history were it not for his unlikely and significant contribution to the 2005 Ashes.

Pratt had been brought onto the pitch as a substitute fielder for the injured Simon Jones. A specialist fielder, he was available for duties with England only because his batting form for Durham had been so poor that he had been released from their first team.

His significant action came in Australia’s second innings. The visitors were fighting back having followed on, and looked well set at 155/2 with captain Ricky Ponting seemingly back to his best. Ponting was at the bowler’s end when partner Damian Martyn pushed the ball to cover and called for a quick single. The ball was picked up smartly by Pratt who twisted his body and threw in one motion at the one stump he could see. He hit the target and the bails flew with Ponting well out of his crease. Australia went on to lose the test, a loss that was key to England’s historic series win.

Ponting was furious, having complained earlier in the series about England’s use of substitute fielders, feeling they were using them tactically to give bowlers a rest. When he had cooled down – and it did take until the series was over – he was magnanimous enough to present Pratt with a pair of signed boots. Pratt was invited to join the England team on the open top bus tour through London and was greeted with chants of ‘there’s only one Gary Pratt’. Sadly, for Pratt, his new fame did not resuscitate his first-class career, in fact it may have hindered it as he became known only as a fielder and not as the decent batsman he was. Released by Durham in 2006, only a year after his heroics, he never played first class cricket again.

15. One for every day of the year (almost) – Len Hutton, The Oval 1938

The 1938 Ashes was an interesting series, although principally for cricketing statisticians. It featured a string of all-time greats on both sides – Wally Hammond, Len Hutton, Denis Compton, Hedley Verity for England and Don Bradman, Stan McCabe and Bill O’Reilly for Australia – but not many great matches.

The first test saw England rack up 658 with four centurions, Charlie Barnett, Hutton, Eddie Paynter and Compton. Australia’s reply was notable mainly for an astonishing innings from McCabe, which moved the great Bradman to implore his teammates to “Come and look at this. You’ve never seen anything like it!” McCabe scored 232 out of 300 while he was at the wicket, including 72 in his final 28 minutes. The match was drawn as was the second test, while the third test became only the second in test history to be completely rained off. (It may not surprise you to know that it was ‘played’ at Manchester.)

The fourth test – a strangely low-scoring affair in a summer of many runs – went the way of the tourists, in part due to a century, his third of the series, from Bradman. Then onto The Oval for the fifth and final test.

The test was designated as ‘timeless’ so was to be played to a result, however long it took.

England batted first and set their stall out to bat for as long as was humanly possible. At the end of day one their score stood at 347-1 with opener Len Hutton on 160 not out and Maurice Leyland on 156. Hutton was still there at 300 not out at the end of day two with England’s score having moved to 634-5. (Strangely, three wickets had fallen for 9 runs including Paynter and Compton for just one run between them). When Hutton was finally out on the third day, he had scored a test record of 364 runs. And the fun wasn’t over as England added another 133 runs to declare at another record, of 903-7. One unfortunate bowler – Chuck Fleetwood-Smith – had bowled 87 overs for the dubious figures of 1 for 298.

Australian, at the end of a long tour and what must have seemed like an equally long time in the field, were tired and demoralised, and without Bradman in their ranks the England score must have looked like Mount Everest. They subsided in both innings to finish the game with a record defeat of an innings and 579 runs.  The game may not have been the best spectacle or the most exciting, but if a young Norris McWhirter had been watching he would have seen much to delight him.

16. The edge that never was – Stuart Broad, Trent Bridge 2013

To paraphrase Shakespeare “to walk or not to walk, that is the question.” The answer for most professional cricketers is simple … not. If the ball makes a light contact as it passes the bat, most will wait to see if they can get away with it. Perhaps the bowling team won’t appeal; maybe the umpire might have missed it; it’s even possible that the DRS review may be inconclusive; maybe they’ve run out of reviews. In 2013, England bowling legend Stuart Broad decided not to walk… and he had not just had a faint edge, he’d virtually nicked the ball to first slip.

The setting was the first Test of the series at Trent Bridge, Broad’s home ground. The context was a very tight test in which England badly needed second innings runs in order to set Australia a testing target. That Australia were in the game at all was largely due to an astounding innings by their 19-year-old test debutant Ashton Agar. Coming to the crease at 117 for 9 he had broken all sorts of test records for a number 11, scoring 98 in a partnership of 163 that gave his team a wholly unexpected advantage. Little did Agar know, but he would also be a central character in the following day’s drama.

England were teetering at 218-6 when Broad, no longer thought of as much of a batsman, came out to join a well-set Ian Bell. England, only 153 ahead, needed Broad to stick around and support Bell for as long as he was able. And he did, with the pair having added 79 runs – enough to set a decent but still very gettable chase – when Agar bowled a short and wide off-spinner to Broad. Broad edged and the ball deflected off keeper Brad Haddin’s glove straight into first slip Michael Clarke’s hands. The Australians were so confident they barely bothered to appeal, but Broad stood his ground waiting for the umpire’s decision. And the decision, amazingly, was in his favour. Pakistani umpire Aleem Dar was in a very small minority who did not see the nick, possibly confused by the deflection off Haddin’s gloves. A DRS appeal would have shown a big nick, but the Aussies had used up all out of their reviews, so Broad stayed put.  

Broad and Bell added a further 58 invaluable runs, enabling England to set Australia a target of 311 to win. In their chase, Australia looked down and out when, still 80 runs short, last man James Pattinson came out to join Haddin. With a mix, though, of dogged defence and some occasional hitting out, the pair took Australia to within an unlikely 15 runs of their target. With tremendous irony, it took a DRS review on a nick that the umpire had not seen – Haddin edging James Anderson to the keeper – to clinch the victory for England.

Broad remained blithely unapologetic about not walking. Had he not stood his ground, it’s unlikely England would have won the Test, and this would have made winning the series (which England did 3-0) considerably more difficult. It may not have been entirely within the spirit of cricket, but most England followers could not have cared less.

https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/the-ashes-stuart-broad-on-not-walking-at-trent-bridge-1381302

17. George Davis is innocent – Headingley, 1975

In 1974 the London Electricity Board (LEB) offices in Ilford were subject to an armed payroll robbery. Four people were accused of the crime, but only one, George Davis, was convicted, being handed a 20-year prison sentence. Friends and family, however, believed that the conviction was unsafe, and that the police had suppressed evidence that might have exonerated Davis. They mounted a campaign centred around the slogan ‘George Davis is innocent’.

The case came to the wider attention of the public during the third Ashes Test of 1975 played at Headingley. Australia had won the first Test well at Edgbaston (a test noteworthy for Graham Gooch bagging a pair on debut) then held on for a draw at Lords. England had had the best of the Headingley test, setting Australia a target of 445 with almost two days of play remaining. At close of day four, the visitors had progressed to 220-3 and the match was poised for a potentially thrilling final day.

The drama was never to take place. Groundsmen arrived for their day’s work to find the pitch had been vandalised overnight with holes dug out and oil poured in by Davis’s supporters. The pitch was irreparable so the match was abandoned and called a draw. As it happens, the game would probably have finished that way anyway as it rained heavily from noon to 4pm, but cricket fans around the world were nevertheless upset and disgusted.

Davis was eventually released from prison although his conviction was not actually overturned. And it transpired that he may well not have been the innocent victim of justice that his supporters claimed him to be. In 1978 he pleaded guilty to involvement in an armed raid and was sent to jail, then after his release he was again jailed in 1987 for robbery. The campaigners who dug up the pitch were also tried and one, Peter Chappell, jailed for 18 months. Most cricket fans would have been glad to see both Chappell and Davis convicted – never mind the armed robbery, they had spoiled our enjoyment of a test match.

https://www.theguardian.com/law/article/2024/may/13/george-davis-is-innocent-ok-londoner-recalls-campaign-to-free-him-in-new-tv-series

18. The hundredth hundred – Geoffrey Boycott, Headingley 1977

It’s fair to say that Geoffrey Boycott was not everyone’s cup of tea. A determined and disciplined opening batsman, he made his debut for his home county Yorkshire, then the dominant force in county cricket, aged only 21, and his first appearance for England just two years later. Despite the weight of runs that he scored throughout his career, he was never entirely accepted by his teammates and fans. Although he never gave his wicket away without a fight, he also had a reputation for scoring runs slowly, sometimes at the expense of his team’s requirements. And his introverted and focused personality meant that he could be seen as aloof and selfish. During his career he fell out at some point or another with many other strong personalities in the game.

He had nevertheless been a regular presence in the England team for a decade until 1974 when he made himself unavailable for selection. He claimed that he had lost his appetite for Test cricket but it was thought that he did not want to play under captain Mike Denness, a player he considered unworthy of playing for his country. (It may also have been that he did not fancy facing Jeff Thomson and Dennis Lillee bowling 90+ mph.) He was out of the team for three years before a loss of form from opener Dennis Amiss caused the selectors to reach again for his phone number. His much anticipated return was to be at Trent Bridge against Australia in 1977. (Coincidentally this was also Ian Botham’s debut.)

Boycott’s impact was certainly dramatic. England were struggling at 34/2 when Nottinghamshire hero Derek Randall joined Boycott at the crease. 18 runs were added before Boycott, a notoriously poor runner between the wickets, caused Randall to be run out. With the crowd calling for blood, Boycott somehow redeemed himself by scoring a century and constructing match-winning partnerships with first Alan Knott then, in the second innings, Mike Brearley to lead England to a Test win.

One Test later and Boycott was on more familiar territory, his home ground of Headingley, where he was adored by fans whatever his idiosyncrasies. He had an opportunity to achieve something never before done in the game – to score his hundredth hundred in a Test match. He moved relatively serenely to his fifty then, with the crowd getting more excited with every run, closed in on his hundred. Finally he was presented with a half volley from occasional bowler, Greg Chappell, and a sweet on-drive for four took him to his landmark. Cries of ‘Yorkshire, Yorkshire’ rang out around the stadium as Boycott celebrated. He had done it when he wanted it and where he wanted it, and even those who did not warm to the man could appreciate his achievement.

19. The wide – Steve Harmison, 2006/7 Brisbane

In 2005 England’s bowlers had put a marker down in the first test of the Ashes with some of the most aggressive bowling seen since the infamous bodyline series. Chief assailant had been Durham’s Steve Harmison who struck both Australian openers, Justin Langer and Matthew Hayden, on their body in his first three overs, before rattling captain Ricky Ponting’s helmet still within the first hour. The message was ‘we mean business’ and, although the Lords test was lost, the approach was critical to England’s series victory.

When England travelled to Australia to defend the Ashes just over a year later, they would have wanted to make a similar statement. At Brisbane, the venue for the first test, Steve Harmison was again chosen to bowl the first over, and as at Lords he faced Australian opener, Langer. If Langer had been concerned he need not have been. Harmison delivered a ball so wide it ended in the hands of England captain, Andrew Flintoff, at SECOND slip!

It was, sadly, a taste of things to come. Harmison bowled poorly all innings and Australia strolled to a total of 602/9, setting themselves up for a massive win. And things did not improve much in the rest of the series. Australia dominated with bat and ball and more than gained revenge for 2005 with a 5-0 whitewash. Harmison later said “I can’t think of a worse ball to bowl than that. In fact, I can’t remember ever bowling a ball as bad as that. I guess it set the tone.” Sadly, Steve, it did.

20. The legend departs – Don Bradman / Eric Hollies, The Oval 1948

For a lover of statistics there can be no more satisfying sport to follow than cricket. The game is built on numbers, and there’s an inexhaustible variety of ways of looking at and analysing the game and the performance of the teams/players/umpires/grounds/etc in it. Within the world of cricketing statistics, there is one that stands out above all other, that of Don Bradman’s batting average in tests. Bradman, after a stellar career of 52 tests and 80 innings finished with a batting average of 99.94, exactly four runs short of a career average of 100!

Bradman’s final series was with the all-conquering Australians on their historic 1948 tour to England. Tours in this era were whole season affairs and Australia played 34 matches on this, winning 25, many by huge margins, drawing nine and losing none! Known as ‘the Invincibles’ they are often judged to be the greatest Australian side of all-time. Bradman, although in the latter stages of his career, was still ‘the Don’. He was top run scorer on the tour with 11 hundreds and averaged just under 90. In the first four tests he had scored two hundreds and over 500 runs.

The final test was played at the Oval. Already 3-0 down and with the series lost, England looked beaten and demoralised. After a start delayed by rain they subsided to their second lowest total in tests, a miserable 52 all out. Australia’s openers, Sid Barnes and Arthur Morris, passed that total without alarm and when Barnes fell for 61, out stepped the great man. Bradman had given notice that this was to be his last tour so he was greeted with a standing ovation from the crowd and a guard of honour from the England team who saluted him with three cheers.

Perhaps Bradman had a tear in his eye, or lost his concentration. Whether that was true or not, his second ball was a googly from Eric Hollies, the Warwickshire leg-spinner playing his seventh test match. For once, Bradman’s impenetrable defence let him down and he was clean bowled. He returned to the pavilion to another standing ovation from the crowd, but with a rare duck to his name.

Had England batted better in their second innings Bradman might have had a chance to score the four runs he needed for his average. Instead, they lost by an innings so he was left stranded. Perhaps it’s better that way – 99.94 is so much more memorable than 100.

21. The snarling redemption – Mitchel Johnson, Australia

In 2009 Australian fast bowler Mitchell Johnson had the unwanted distinction of having a song dedicated to him by the Barmy Army. It was not a good one “He bowls to the left, he bowls to the right, Mitchell Johnson, your bowling is sh*te!”. Johnson had taken 20 wickets on the 2009 tour to England, but had gone at just almost four an over. Then in the 2010/11 home series he had again conceded plenty of runs, although he had shown his potency in one match, bowling his team to their only victory in the series in Perth.

Johnson was dropped for disciplinary reasons for the 2013 tour to England, but was back in the side for the return in Australia that winter. If Johnson was looking for revenge against the old enemy, he got it, and some. Aggressive, angry, accurate and above all, fast, Johnson was close to unplayable.

England probably arrived as favourites after winning the home series 3-0. It did not take long for Johnson to shatter any confidence they might have felt. England had a strong batting line-up but they were no match for a fired-up Johnson at Brisbane. Alongside another bowler going through the purplest of patches, Ryan Harris, Johnson helped skittle the tourists out for 136 and 179. The second test at Adelaide, on a docile pitch where Australia had scored 570, saw him take another seven wickets to bowl England out for 172. Perth, venue for the third test, saw an improved performance from England but another six wickets for Johnson and a third consecutive win for his team. Eight wickets in the fourth test and another six in the fifth saw him to 37 wickets in the series at an average of just under 14, the third lowest average in Ashes history.

Johnson had driven Australia to a 5-0 series victory and total domination over England. For Johnson, after the taunts and jibes, it must have been super-satisfying. The song was rarely sung again.

22. The rebound – Geoff Miller / Chris Tavare, Melbourne 1982/83

There was a period at the end of the 1970s and start of the 1980s in which Australian cricket went through something of a lull. World Series Cricket (1977-79) had decimated the team, and even after the game was reunited something was missing. England won three successive series from 1977 and travelled to Australia in 1982 having held the Ashes for five years. This time, though, Australia’s bowling was just a little sharper than England’s and the home side were 2-0 ahead with three Tests having been played.

The Boxing Day Test (the 4th) at Melbourne was a must-win for England if they were to have any chance of retaining the Ashes. After both first innings had been completed the scores were pretty even with a three run advantage to the home side. In their second innings, England’s lower order battled well to set Australia a target of 292 to win.

The game looked done and dusted when Australia’s ninth wicket fell and fast bowler Jeff Thomson walked out to join Allan Border with 74 runs still needed. Great fast bowler that he was (or certainly had been) Thommo was no great shakes as a batsman, and Border himself had not been in the best of form. But, with England offering easy singles to Border that he often turned into twos, the target began to be whittled down. 74 became 60 then 50 then 40 then as stumps were drawn on day four just 37 were required.

When the gates opened on day five, 10,000 Melburnians turned up hoping to see Australia gain an unlikely victory. Despite England taking the new ball, Border and Thomson continued to chip away at the total. The crowd swelled, getting close to 20,000, and every run was cheered enthusiastically. England’s bowlers looked out of ideas and energy. Then with only six runs required Bob Willis found his range. He conceded a two to Border but managed to prevent a single at the end of the over meaning that Thomson would have to face a new over from Ian Botham.

Botham, as so often in his career, got lucky. He bowled a ball short of a length and a little wide of the off stump. A better batsman would simply have left it but Thomson dangled his bat and caught an edge. The ball went straight to second slip Chris Tavare. Tavare, perhaps letting the occasion get to him, got both hands to the ball but felt it bounce out and over his head. He turned despairingly where he saw first slip Geoff Miller react smartly and run round to snaffle the catch. Tavare might have dropped the Test, but Miller had caught it. England had won by only three runs.

https://www.wisden.com/cricket-news/watch-geoff-miller-catch-chris-tavare-ian-botham-jeff-thomson-melbourne-ashes-australia-england-1982-83

23. Warner on toast – Stuart Broad / David Warner, 2019 series

The 2019 Ashes series was a cracker, finishing two Tests apiece and featuring one of, if not the greatest test innings of all time from Ben Stokes at Headingley. If a series draw was something of a disappointment for England fans, one massive consolation came from the struggles of the player on the Australian side, whom we all loved to hate, opener David Warner.

Warner had burst into Test cricket in 2011 with almost no first-class experience. A combative and buccaneering batsman, his reputation had been earned in T20 and one day cricket when the Australian selectors, clearly seeing something in him, chose him to open for the Test side. He got off to a flying start in his debut series against New Zealand and never looked back.

Warner’s aggressive approach, always in the face of his opponents whether batting or fielding, did not endear him to England fans, but his role of lead anti-hero was cemented in 2013 when he got involved in an off-field fracas with Joe Root. It was reinforced when he was suspended from Test cricket for his role in ‘sandpapergate’. When it was announced that his return after suspension was to come on Australia’s 2019 to England, home fans rubbed their hands in anticipation of giving him a supremely hard time from the stands.

Their barracking turned out to be somewhat unnecessary. Warner was terrible, and to rub salt into his wound, his nemesis was Australian anti-hero from 2013, Stuart Broad. Broad had worked out a strategy to defeat Warner and it worked. Bowling round the wicket and aiming to land the ball outside off stump on a full length, he took Warner’s wicket seven times in the series, caught behind (three times), LBW (three) and bowled. The Aussie left-hander ended the series with the lowest runs ever (by far) of any opener to play at least 10 innings in a series and his average facing Broad was a dismal 5.00. Warner played Test cricket for another four years after 2019, but was never again a dominant force against England.

https://www.skysports.com/cricket/news/12175/12917334/the-ashes-stuart-broad-has-david-warner-on-toast-why-is-that-and-is-australia-batters-place-in-jeopardy

24. The first baller – Rory Burns / Mitchell Starc, 2021/2 Brisbane

In 2019 England and Australia had played out one of the classic Ashes series, illuminated with Ben Stokes’ epic match-winning innings at Headingley. The teams had looked evenly matched throughout, and whilst a 2-2 series result will have delighted neither team, it was a fair reflection of the balance of play through the summer. Two years on and England travelled down under with the some optimism that this visit might be more successful than their previous one, a 4-0 series defeat in 2017/8. The optimism lasted about 30 seconds.

The England opening partnership was not their strongest. At the bowler’s end stood Haseeb Hameed, a once promising teenager recalled after a five year gap. Facing the first ball, left-hander Rory Burns, possessor of an idiosyncratic and (let’s be honest) unattractive technique, but normally a solid defender of his wicket. Not today.

Experienced left-armer Mitchell Starc was given the task of bowling the first ball of the series. It looked like he had presented Burns with a juicy half-volley down the leg side and the batsman duly stepped across his stumps to clip it away. Burns, though, completely missed the ball as it swung back to clip his leg stump. The series had started with a golden duck and a tone was set. Australia bowled superbly throughout and England’s batsmen presented little in return and a 5-0 series whitewash was averted only by a last ditch England rearguard at Sydney.

Burns was dropped after two tests but recalled for the last as his opening partner Hameed had completely run out of runs. Burns’ reward – to be run out for a duck in what proved to be his final test for his country.

25. The substitute II – Sydney Copley, Trent Bridge 1930

If Gary Pratt (see above) is a footnote in cricket history, then Syd Copley is probably a toe-note. Copley was a cricketer who played for Nottinghamshire second team between 1924-31. He managed to break into the first team for one solitary game, against Oxford University in 1930. His first-class career therefore comprises seven runs in two innings and no wickets for 28. Hardly the stuff of legend.

He did, however, do something extraordinary and significant in an England shirt. It was the first Test of the Australia series at Trent Bridge. Copley, on the Notts groundstaff, was called upon to field in place of Harold Larwood who had fallen ill with gastritis. Australia were chasing a record 429 to win, but with Don Bradman and Stan McCabe at the crease for the fourth wicket, they looked in with a chance. Then came Copley’s intervention. Fielding at deep mid-on he saw McCabe strike a ball from Maurice Tate to long-on. Wisden described it thus: “(he) made a lot of ground, took the ball at full-length and, although rolling over, retained possession.” His catch proved to be the turning point of the match which England went on to win by 93 runs.

Oddly enough (and this will appeal only to those of a certain disposition), another member of the groundstaff, this time at Lords, made another famous catch in 1984. West Indian Malcolm Marshall hooked Bob Willis and the substitute took a superb one-handed catch, only spoiling the act by stepping over the boundary as he took it. The fielder this time not Copley, but (Don) Topley.

The worst of the Masters

I wrote this blog in readiness for the 2025 Masters. I genuinely thought that if I included Rory’s 2011 meltdown in my list, it would act as a good-luck charm for him. I can, therefore, count myself personally responsible for his dramatic victory, and perhaps even for his 2026 follow-up. Reading the story of his 2011 misadventure is so much more enjoyable knowing that he finally redeemed himself … and how!

If you have more of a taste for triumph and victory, you can read five equally great stories in my companion blog https://bestandworst.net/the-worst-of-the-masters/

5. Hoch as in choke – Scott Hoch, 1989

“that’s just 24 inches away from a green coat … and that’s a career in one putt” – CBS commentary, 1989

At the age of 27 Nick Faldo was dissatisfied. A natural talent, he had already won multiple times on the European tour and had topped the money list in 1983. He felt, though, that his game was not strong enough to win at the very highest level. So, to some surprise around the golfing world, he decided he needed to completely rebuild his swing, working with a little known South African coach, David Leadbetter.

The results at first were not promising, but Faldo was utterly determined to persist, and after a couple of years his swing changes were embedded and his form started to recover… in spades. In 1987 he captured his first Open Championship, then in 1988 he finished in the top four in three of the Majors.

The Englishman was one of the favourites for the 1989 Masters, despite a modest record in his previous appearances. A solid start saw him tied for the lead after two rounds, but a disappointing 77 in round three looked to have taken him out of contention, five shots behind leader American Ben Crenshaw.

Faldo, though, went off like a train in the final round, and fought his way to a superb best-of-the-day 65 and the clubhouse lead at five-under. One by one his main opponents slipped up – Seve, Greg Norman, Crenshaw and American Mike Reid all had chances to lead, but all fluffed them. By the time the final group came to the last only one player had matched Faldo’s 72-hole score, American Scott Hoch after narrowly missing a birdie on the last for an outright win.

The play-off format was sudden death, and the pair started on the par-four 10th. While Hoch made the green in two, Faldo could only find the bunker. Faldo’s escape was poor leaving him a 15-foot putt for par, whilst Hoch had 25-feet for a birdie. When the American rolled his putt to just two feet away, it was clear that Faldo had to hole his 15-footer. He missed, leaving Hoch his simple ‘tap-in’ for the title. Hoch hesitated over the putt, stood up to take another look, readied himself over it for a second time then tapped the ball towards the hole. Agonisingly, it missed the hole… completely. Instead of claiming the title, the pair went on to the second play-off hole. Faldo did not look this massive gift horse in the mouth and birdied it to win the play-off and his first Masters.

Faldo never looked back, winning two more Masters and two more Open Championships to become the most successful British golfer of recent times. Hoch met with considerable success winning 11 PGA Tour events, but never came as close again to winning a Major.

Scott Hoch’s infamous 2 foot putt – Countdown to the Masters (77 days)

Hoch’s 1989 tale part of Masters history – ESPN

4. The meltdown – Jordan Spieth on the 12th, 2016

“I can’t imagine that was fun for everyone to experience, other than Danny (Willett)’s team”  Jordan Spieth 2016

In 1996, American Jordan Spieth seemed to have the golfing world at his feet. Still only 22 years old he was the holder of two golf Majors, the previous year’s Masters and US Open, had won the prestigious Tour Championship and was ranked number one golfer in the world. He arrived at Augusta as favourite to retain his Masters Trophy.

His defence was convincing. A bogey-free opening round of 66 (6-under) shot him into a two-shot lead. He faltered a little in difficult scoring conditions in his second and third rounds, but did enough to go into the final round with a one-shot lead. Having led from gun to tape in 2015, he had now led the Masters for an unprecedented seven consecutive rounds. With no-one shooting the lights out behind him, there were strong odds that he would make it eight in a row for back-to-back victories.

It certainly seemed that way after the front nine. Spieth birdied 6, 7, 8 and 9 to take a five shot lead at the turn. Only three other players were under par – fellow American Dustin Johnson and Britons Lee Westwood and Danny Willett – and none of these had yet won a Major. Spieth had two to his name already and had seemed utterly unruffleable in his career to date.

A small crack, though, opened up on the 10th, a tough par-four. Spieth missed a par putt here for a bogey five. The crack widened on the 11th, where he hooked his tee shot into the trees. He recovered well, but could manage no better than another bogey. Further up the course, Danny Willett had picked up two birdies so, in a matter of minutes, Spieth’s lead had been cut to just one hole. With two par fives ahead of him, though, he was still favourite. He did not remain so after the 12th.

The par three ‘Golden Bell’ is a nerve-jangling experience for Masters contenders. Hit the ball too short and you risk dropping into Rae’s Creek or the front bunker. Hit it too long and there are two downhill bunkers at the back amidst a host of azalea bushes. Choosing the right club is complicated further by the normally swirling wind.

Club choice could not be blamed for Spieth’s error in 2016. Instead, it was just an awful swing. He aimed left of the flag to try and find a safe spot on the green, but almost shanked the ball, pushing it right and short. It landed on the slope at the front of the green and rolled back into Rae’s Creek.  He took a penalty drop leaving himself around 70 yards to the pin. He had been deadly with his wedges all tournament. Not this time. He chunked it like an amateur and once again found the water. His next attempt, his fifth shot, did at least clear the water but found one of the two back bunkers. He managed to get up and down but when the shots were counted, he had recorded a quadruple bogey seven, his worst ever score as a pro on a par-three.

To his credit, Spieth responded with a birdie on the next hole, then another on the 15th, but the damage had been done. To most pundits’ surprise, the unheralded and unfancied Briton, Willett, held his nerve to record his first (and only) Major. Spieth refused to be defined by the loss, and went on to win his third and (to date last) Major in the following year’s Open Championship. Perhaps, though, he would have won many more had it not been for 2016 and Golden Bell.

Other shockers at the Masters:

  1. Defending champion Sergio Garcia hits five balls each of which spin back into the water in taking 13 on the 15th hole in 2018
  2. Tom Weiskopf, Open Champion in 1973, hits five balls that either roll back or drop straight into Rae’s Creek making a 13 on the 12th in 1980
  3. Ernie Els takes six (yes, that’s six) putts from three feet on first hole in 2016
  4. … and let’s not forget Charlie Kunkle, who crowned his one and only appearance in the Masters in 1956 with a 95 in his final round

Jordan Spieth’s collapse at the Masters the most shocking in golf history – ESPN

A timeline of Jordan Spieth’s sudden Masters meltdown | SB Nation

3. Surely you checked it, yes? – Roberto Di Vicenzo, 1968

“If your returned score for a hole is higher than your actual score, your higher returned score for the hole stands”  The Rule of Golf

The 1968 Masters was a decent tournament, with the lead changing hands several times in the final round, and with many of the top players of the era featuring on the leaderboard. It would, though, probably have been consigned to history had it not been for one remarkable and unfortunate occurence. After four days of intense and close competition, the tournament was decided by a simple error on a scorecard. The beneficiary was American Bob Goalby, claiming his first and only Major. The loser, Argentinian Roberto Di Vicenzo, denied the chance to play-off for the title by a slip of the pencil.

Di Vicenzo was enjoying an Indian summer to his career. A prolific winner across the world, he had won the previous year’s Open Championship aged 44, a full 20 years after placing third in 1948 (he was again third in ’49 and runner-up in ’50). Goalby was also an experienced pro, 39-years old, and with seven tournament wins and a handful of top 10 placings in Majors behind him.  Both were in contention going into the final day, Goalby one behind the leader, Gary Player, and Di Vicenzo one shot further back.

The Argentinian got his final round off to a dream start, eagling the par-four 1st to move immediately into a share of the lead, then adding further birdies on 2 and 3. Goalby, playing a couple of holes behind, also started well. As other, more-fancied, contenders failed to spark, these two stayed out in front and came to look the most-likely winners. When Di Vicenzo birdied the par-5 15th he moved into a one-shot lead, then two holes later (on the 17th) he stuck a superb wedge to four-feet for another birdie chance. Goalby, however, was not done and gave himself an eagle chance on the 15th. The two putts dropped almost simultaneously (TV viewers had for the first time the opportunity to see them using new split-screen technology) bringing both players level.

Di Vicenzo needed only a par on the last to equal the course record and set the clubhouse lead, but he failed to get up and down from the side of the green and finished with a bogey. Feeling like he had given away the Masters, he trudged to the scorer’s hut to check and sign his scorecard. Perhaps he was over-focused on the bogey five that he had recorded on the last, but he failed to notice that his playing partner, Tommy Aaron, had marked his card with a four on the 17th and not a three. So, he signed for a 66 and not the 65 he had actually scored. If the officials in the hut did notice, none mentioned it.

Goalby, meanwhile, had bogeyed the 17th, but finished with a 66 for a final score of 11-under par. Di Vicenzo had also finished on 11-under par, but by the rules of golf he had to accept the score that he had signed for, making him 10-under par. He had lost the Masters by a shot. Di Vicenzo’s famous quote of “What a stupid I am!” may well have included more expletives had his English been better.

Other golfers who have fallen foul of the scorecard rule:

  1. Padraig Harrington was disqualified when leading the 2010 Benson & Hedges International Open after it was discovered that he had not signed his first round scorecard. The error only came to light when the Belfry Hotel asked for the scorecards so they could frame them.
  2. Mark Roe was disqualified from the 2003 Open having equalled the best round of the tournament and when lying just three shots off the lead after the 3rd round. He had failed to swap his card with playing partner Jesper Parnevik, so each had signed the wrong card.
  3. Jordan Spieth was disqualified in the 2024 Genesis Open after giving himself one shot too few on his scorecard. The rules had changed to allow him to correct it within 15 minutes, but Spieth had had to rush to the toilet after signing so had no time to come back and fix it.
  4. Johnny Miller in the 1976 World Series of Golf played a round having forgotten to take his six-year-old son’s 23-inch putter out of his bag. His even par 72 turned into a 76 after the four-shot penalty was applied.
  5. PGA Tour Canada pro Justin Doeden admitted to deliberately changing his scorecard to make the half way cut in an event in 2023. Despite copious apologies his career has not recovered.

War, murder and an incorrect scorecard: The story of the 1968 US Masters – The Irish Times

How a scorecard error cost Roberto de Vicenzo the Masters

2. The prodigy implodes – Rory McIlroy, 2011

“I’ll get over it. I’ll have plenty more chances – I know that.” – Rory McIlroy, 2011

By 2011 21-year old Rory McIlroy had already made a big splash in the world of golf. The most celebrated youngster since Tiger Woods had won on both the European and the US PGA tours, placed in the top 10 of three of the Majors and risen to the top 10 of the world rankings. It was clearly a matter of when, rather than if, he would win his first Major, and with his game seemingly tailor-made for Augusta, the Masters would surely present him with a great chance.

It looked for all the world that it would come as soon as 2011. McIlroy got off to a great start, shooting a bogey-free 7-under par 65 on day one to share the lead. A 69 (3-under) on day two took him into the outright lead, and he followed this up with a 70 (2-under) to go into the final day with a four-shot lead at 12-under par.

Come Sunday and McIlroy was clearly nervous. He bogeyed the first after failing to get up and down from the back of the green, then dropped another shot on the 5th. He steadied the ship with a birdie on the 7th, but could now see in his wing mirrors a host of top players queueing up to overtake him. Playing partner and 2009 winner Angel Cabrera, South African Charl Schwartzel and, most ominous of all, Tiger Woods, had all closed to within a shot of the Northern Irishman by the time he reached the turn.  

His one-shot lead was not to last much longer. The 10th hole, nicknamed Camellia, is a tough par-four, one of the most difficult holes on the course based on scoring average. McIlroy had managed the hole decently over the first three rounds (recording two pars and a bogey), but his composure deserted him with the pressure on. His drive was wild and came to rest in a rarely-seen spot close to some houses. The best he could do was chip back onto the fairway from where he badly mishit his approach to the green. His pitch to the green struck an overhanging branch, then his chip to the green (already his fifth shot on a par-four) fell short leaving him a long putt. Two putts later and he had recorded a triple-bogey, taking him in an instant from first to seventh. On the next hole, the 11th, he missed a short par putt, then on the par-3 12th he three-putted from less than three feet. Six shots had gone in three holes and he had played himself completely out of contention.

McIlroy’s final round of 80 (eight over par) was the worst score of the day and left him outside the top 10 (in a tie for 15th). The winner, for what it is worth, was South African Charl Schwartzel, who closed with four consecutive birdies to win his only Major.

McIlroy appeared relatively unscarred by his experience. In fact, he went on to win that same year’s US Open at Congressional by an incredible eight-shot margin. And by the close of 2014 had won four Majors – an Open and two PGA Championships to add to his US Open – and seemed odds on to complete a career Grand Slam. We all know now that it would in fact take 11 years and a heap of near misses (21 top 10s) for him to add to his Major tally. Had he got over the line in 2011 he might have won more, or he might have won fewer. His story, though, would surely not have been as compelling.  

1. The great white shark gets harpooned – Greg Norman, 1996

“Well Greg, not even you can f*** this up now” – veteran journalist, Peter Dobereiner to Greg Norman on the Saturday night at the Masters

For a golfer who won 90 tournaments worldwide and was ranked world number one for over six years, Australian Greg Norman has an unfortunate reputation as a loser. Yes, he did capture two Majors – the Open Championships of 1986 and 1993 – but to many his near misses better define his career. He finished in the top 10 of a Major 30 times and, incredibly, came second or third in 12 of these tournaments. Half of his near misses came in the Masters, a tournament he was destined never to win.  

Norman had a fantastic chance in 1986 when a par at the last would have taken him into a play-off with the charging Jack Nicklaus. He had a better chance in 1987 when Larry Mize produced his miracle chip to rob Norman in the play-off. In 1989 he bogeyed the last to miss another play-off. There was another top 10 finish in 1992 and a tie for third in 1995. He kept getting close, but there was no cigar for the cigar-loving Australian.

His fortunes seemed sure to change in 1996 when he arrived at Augusta ranked world number one and seemingly in full control of his game. He demonstrated this in spades with a record-equalling nine-under-par 63 in the opening round. Having started undramatically with with six straight pars, he went on to make an amazing nine birdies in the remaining 12 holes. A second round 69 took him four shots ahead of the field, then a 71 saw him finish day three with a huge six shot lead. Seemingly the only cloud on his horizon was that in second place was two-time Masters winner, the unflappable Nick Faldo, and the two would play together on the Sunday.

Another cloud was spotted, though, by CBS golf analyst and experienced coach, Peter Kostis. Kostis observed that Norman had changed his grip during the tournament, and felt that this had led to more erratic ball striking. In reality, it was only the Australian’s superb chipping and putting that had kept his score going after the first day. Kostis predicted a long final round for Norman if he could not sort this out.

Whether or not Kostis was right, Norman himself did not feel that all was well. He slept badly on the Saturday night (in truth, not uncommon for someone leading a Major) and woke on the Sunday with a stiff back. On top of this he claims he was dealing with a difficult personal issue.

His final round started poorly with a missed fairway on the 1st leading to a bogey five. Norman responded with a birdie but a second bogey, up against a strong start from Faldo, saw his lead halved to three shots coming off the 8th. The 9th gave perhaps the clearest signal that all was not well with the Aussie. He had a straightforward 9-iron to the green but chose instead to play his wedge. The ball came up short and then rolled 30 yards back towards Norman on the fairway. Bogey. This was followed by another on 10, then another on 11. His six-shot lead had now evaporated. He was in no state of mind to face the perilous 12th, the par-three ‘Golden Bell’, and, once Faldo had safely found the green, Norman dunked his into the water. Double-bogey and five shots dropped in four holes. Norman was now two behind his playing partner.

Faldo was too good and too mentally strong to let go. Three birdies in his final six holes saw him clinch his third Masters triumph, his closing score a full five shots better than Norman. The final round had seen an incredible 11 shot swing. Norman’s career was far from over – he still won a handful of tournaments – but despite placing in the odd Major he never really looked like winning another to add to his two Opens.

Norman’s other near misses

  1. 1987 Masters – Larry Mize’s miracle chip-in on the first extra hole of the play-off defeated a much better placed Norman. 
  2. 1986 US PGA – Norman led all the way and by four coming into the final round. Journeyman Bob Tway drew level with three holes left. Tway scrambled unlikely pars on 16 and 17 before holing his bunker shot on the last. Norman could not follow suit and finished runner-up.
  3. 1984 US Open – Norman birdied 17 and saved par with a long putt on 18 to make a play-off against Fuzzy Zoeller. But he collapsed in the 18-hole play-off losing by eight shots to Zoeller.
  4. 1986 Masters – after a run of birdies, a poor four-iron approach at the last led to a bogey that meant Norman failed by one shot to make a play-off with Jack Nicklaus.
  5. 1989 Open – Norman played stunning golf on the final day (a 7-under par 64) to make a play-off against Mark Calcavecchia and Wayne Grady. Level with Calcavecchia with only one hole to play he found a fairway bunker then another then found the out of bounds. Another play-off defeat.

The Inside Story of Greg Norman’s Masters Collapse | Golf News and Tour Information | Golf Digest

How sports science explains Greg Norman’s 1996 Masters meltdown – ESPN

The best and worst of the Ryder Cup

Updated Sept 2025 – Well that was unexpected. Having gone to the final day singles with no realistic hope of winning, the US team almost delivered a comeback that would have been greater than any before. A triumphant relaxing coast to the finish line was transformed into a roiling nail-biting scramble. Fantastic drama from start to finish and almost worthy of a place in this list.

It was a reminder of how great the Ryder Cup is as a sporting event and competition. It’s easy to forget that it was not ever thus. Such was the level of American domination – they won 21 of the first 25 contests never once losing on home soil – that the competition nearly folded in the 1970s through lack of interest.

It was only in 1979 when Great Britain and Ireland teamed up with the rest of Europe (a proposal put forward by Jack Nicklaus) that the event revived, becoming a genuine sporting contest. There have been big wins for sure, but many of the matches have been settled by the narrowest of margins. As the official website itself puts it “Drama, tension, incredible golf, camaraderie and sportsmanship are served in equal measure … It’s an event that transcends sport”. There have also been moments of controversy, gamesmanship and incompetence. In this blog I try and pick out the best of the great moments and also the not-so-great.

I fully expect 2025 to generate more of both. Hopefully this blog will get you in the mood for what is to come.

1. The greatest comeback – The Miracle at Medinah 2012

The Ryder Cup had been contested for 60 years before GB or Europe first won the trophy in the USA. Once the duck was broken, at Muirfield Village in 1987, there were further wins for Europe – in 1995 and 2004 – but the US team always started as strong favourites on home soil. This was the case in September 2012, when the two teams lined up at Medinah, Il. 

    The US team’s status as favourites looked solid on day one which they edged 5-3. It began to look better still on the second morning when they stretched their lead to 8-4. Wins then in the first two afternoon fourballs saw them to a huge 10-4 lead. If the Americans could clinch either of the two unfinished matches still on the course, their lead would surely be unassailable going into the final day.

    Their irresistible run to victory was slowed temporarily by European duo Luke Donald and Sergio Garcia who narrowly beat Tiger Woods and Steve Stricker. This was, remarkably, the American pair’s third loss out of three. That left Ian Poulter and Rory McIlroy on the course against Zach Johnson and Jason Dufner. If Europe were to have any chance, however slim, of winning the trophy they needed a point from this one.

    It did not look likely. With six holes left the Americans were two up, and McIlroy, world ranked number one, seemed slightly off his game. Thankfully he picked up a birdie on the 13th to halve the deficit, and this lit the blue touchpaper for his partner, Poulter. The Englishman went on a tear, birdieing 14, 15 and 16 to put the Europeans into a one-hole lead. And he wasn’t finished. He birdied 17 to halve the hole, then sank a 12-footer on the 18th for a stunning fifth consecutive birdie and another half to clinch the match one-up.

    Poulter’s incredible run, accompanying by his customary fist-pumping, eyeballs-out passion, was the spark for an incredible day three. Europe still required an unlikely eight points from the 12 singles matches to halve the match and retain the trophy. But one by one the wins came – Donald, a still-inspired Poulter, McIlroy and Lawrie took the first four matches. There was a brief flurry from the Americans but another unlikely comeback, this time by Justin Rose over Phil Mickelson, seemed to be the clincher. Eventually a five-foot putt for German, Martin Kaymer, on the last was enough to clinch a one-shot victory (over the hapless Steve Stricker, a captain’s pick who won no points in his four matches) and retain the cup for Europe.

    The match became known as ‘the Miracle at Medinah’. Europe have had more convincing triumphs, but none will be as memorable as this one.

    2. The greatest sportsmanship – Nicklaus vs Jacklin, Royal Birkdale 1969

    The rather arcane rules imposed at the time by the US PGA meant that Jack Nicklaus had won seven major championships, including the career grand slam, before he qualified to represent America in the Ryder Cup. His belated debut came at Royal Birkdale in 1969. Aged 29, Nicklaus was going through a rare major ‘drought’, but was still by most accounts the best golfer in the world.

    His first Ryder Cup was to be a somewhat feisty one, marred by aggressive behaviour and poor sportsmanship from players on both sides. Before the contest the combative GB captain, Scot Eric Brown, had told his players not to help look for American balls lost in the rough. On the course, American Ken Still got involved in two disputes – one after being asked to move by Maurice Bembridge in the day one foursomes, then another after his partner Dave Hill putted out of turn in the day two fourballs. The second incident led to a shouting match and nearly resulted in an actual fist fight between the American and British pairs.

    Perhaps one reason for all the aggravation was that, unlike most recent runnings of the contest, the GB team thought they might actually have a chance in this one. The US had beaten GB by a humiliating margin of 23 ½ to 8 ½ in 1967, but this looked like it could go either way. The score was 4 ½ to 3 ½ in favour of GB after day one, then tied at 8-all after day two. The first round of the final day singles (in 1969 there were eight singles matches in the morning then a further eight in the afternoon) saw GB move out into a lead of 13-11, but a US recovery in the afternoon saw the scores tied at 15-15 with two matches still on the course.

    The first of these saw Welshman Brian Huggett against American Billy Casper, while the final match pitted Nicklaus against the young star of the GB team, Tony Jacklin. Jacklin had two months earlier become the first Briton in 18 years to win the Open Championship (at nearby Royal Lytham) and was brim-full of confidence after a 4&3 victory over Nicklaus in the morning singles.  He was though trailing Nicklaus until a huge eagle putt on the 17th saw him draw level. Huggett, on the 18th green, heard the cheer and assumed that Jacklin had won. When he sank his own putt he thought he had won the Cup for Europe and was overcome with emotion, only to find out that the match was still very much alive.

    The Ryder Cup in fact came down to the final pair on the final hole. Nicklaus and Jacklin both hit good drives, then found the green with their approaches. Both had long putts for birdie with Jacklin first to go. His putt finished 2-3 feet short so Nicklaus had his putt to win. Always fearless, he putted aggressively but missed and rolled the ball an uncomfortable 6-7 feet past the hole. Nervelessly, though, he sank the return putt, then to almost everybody’s surprise, the American picked up Jacklin’s marker to concede the Briton’s putt. The hole was halved, their match was halved and the Ryder Cup was halved.

    Nicklaus told Jacklin “I don’t think you would have missed it, but I wasn’t going to give you the chance either.” US team captain, Sam Snead, was apparently furious that Nicklaus’ concession had thrown away the chance of outright victory. But, most observers considered his act to be one of the great acts of sportsmanship.

    3. The greatest shot – Christy O’Connor Jr’s 2 iron, The Belfry 1989

    Irish golfer Christy O’Connor Jr was perhaps a tad unlucky to share the name of his uncle, Christy O’Connor Sr. O’Connor senior was an all-time legend of Irish golf, winning over 20 tournaments on the British PGA tour and being selected for a then-record 10 consecutive Ryder Cup teams. O’Connor junior, whilst a very fine golfer, never hit the heights of his uncle and probably suffered by comparison. He is, though, remembered for one shot of genius in the Ryder Cup, a shot that was critical to Europe’s famous 1989 victory.

    O’Connor had first competed in the Ryder Cup as a 27-year-old. His debut appearance, though, at Laurel Valley, Pennsylvania in 1975 was not auspicious. Heavily beaten twice in the fourballs, he was not called upon for either of the two rounds of singles, so left America with a record of played two, lost two. He failed to qualify for the next few teams, and when he was controversially not selected for the 1985 Ryder Cup (he missed automatic qualification by only £115.89 of prize winnings), it looked as though this would be his lasting record.

    He was, though, to get a chance to set the record straight. In 1989 he put together a strong run of form, and again very narrowly missed out on automatic qualification. To many people’s surprise he was awarded a captain’s pick by Tony Jacklin. Now aged 41, O’Connor was considered to be past his best, a best that had not been considered good enough four years earlier. Perhaps Jacklin having selected the Irishman, then had second thoughts, as he did not select him for either the foursomes or the fourballs on day one. When O’Connor finally did appear, alongside Ronan Rafferty in the second day’s foursomes, he fell to another defeat. His only and final chance of breaking his cup points duck would come in the singles. Drawn against world number 15, Fred Couples, (O’Connor was the lowest-ranked player on either side at 71) it seemed inevitable that he would suffer yet another defeat.

    The reality was different. Europe had entered the final day leading by 9-7. After much drama in the first six matches, they still led by two points at 12-10. This meant that only two points were required to retain the trophy. O’Connor and Couples were the seventh game out. O’Connor was behind but levelled with Couples on the 16th, then halved the 17th to go down the last all square. The 18th, with both the drive and the approach over water, had caused problems for the US team all day. O’Connor played safe from the tee, leaving himself a very testing 230 yards to the flag. Couples hit a beaut, leaving only a nine iron to the green. O’Connor was definitely behind on points, but had the advantage, if you can call it that, of playing his approach shot before the American.

    O’Connor picked his two-iron from his bag. Amateur golfers throughout Europe looked away. O’Connor, however, brought up on the links of Ireland, struck the ball low and true. It cleared the water, landed on the front of the green then ran up the slope to finish no more than four feet from the pin. Couples, unsettled by the unexpected brilliance of the shot, played a poor approach then failed to get down in par. He conceded O’Connor’s putt meaning not only that O’Connor had gained his first point in the Ryder Cup, but also he had also laid the foundation for a 14-14 draw that was enough to see the cup remain in European hands. He had also, arguably, created a more memorable moment than anything his uncle ever had.

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/that-1980s-sports-blog/2016/jan/06/christy-oconnor-jr-european-hero-1989-ryder-cup

    4. The biggest controversy – Brookline 1999

    Not for nothing is the 1999 Ryder Cup known as the ‘Battle of Brookline’. Played in front of a rowdy home crowd, whipped up into a partisan frenzy, the event was marked by some of the worst behaviour ever seen at a golf tournament, both on and off the course. European players and in some cases their family members were jeered, insulted, and jostled by over-boisterous US spectators. More egregiously, the American team got in on the act, committing a violation of golfing etiquette that has gone down in the annals of the sport as one of the worst ever.

    The Ryder Cup in the decade from 1987 to 1997 was an extraordinarily close affair. Four wins for Europe and two to the USA but none with a margin greater than 15-13. (There was also one tie). The 1995 event had been won by Europe on American soil by a single point, then retained in 1997 at Valderrama by the same score. In 1999 the US team were desperate for revenge and confident they could achieve it. 10 of their players were ranked in the world’s top 16, while only three Europeans could claim likewise. Seven of the European team were Ryder Cup rookies against only one of the Americans. With home field advantage only one result seemed possible.

    Day one chucked all predictions into the air. Europe won the foursomes 2 ½ to 1 ½ then romped to a 3 ½ to ½ win in the afternoon fourballs. 6-2 on the day. Day two was closer, but Europe still finished with a 10-6 lead. No team had ever come back this sort of deficit.

    American captain, Ben Crenshaw, felt that a fast start was needed if the USA team was to have any sort of a chance, so he loaded his stronger players up front in the playing order. Europe captain, Mark James took the opposite approach, instead putting out most of his rookies, including three (Coltart, Van de Velde ad Sandelin) who had not played at all on the first two days. Crenshaw’s strategy looked vindicated as the scorecard flashed red, red the red again. The first seven results went USA’s way, shooting them into a 13-10 lead. Europe, though, were not finished. Wins for Padraig Harrington and Paul Lawrie partially rebalanced the score, before a loss for 19-year-old Sergio Garcia took the score to 12-14. The Americans needed only half a point from the two remaining games on the course to recapture the trophy.

    Europe, though, was ahead in both. In the final game, top-ranked European Colin Montgomerie narrowly led Payne Stewart, while in the other, Spaniard Jose-Maria Olazabal went 4-up on Jason Leonard. Leonard, with the unenviable record of no wins from six previous Ryder Cup matches, chose this moment to go on a charge. He won 12, 13, 14 and 15 to square the match. The pair came down the 17th all square with Leonard knowing that if he could avoid defeat, the Ryder Cup would be back in US hands. Both players made the 17th green in two and were faced with long distance putts for birdie. Leonard putted first, from 40-feet. His putt never looked like missing, zeroing in on the hole before finding the middle of the cup. Leonard celebrated wildly before being joined on the green by most members of the US team plus a bevy of wives, vice-captains and caddies.

    There was one critical detail that they had all either missed or had chosen to ignore. The hole was not yet over, Leonard had not yet won it, the US team were not yet assured of the half point they needed for the overall win. Their storming of the green was completely out of order with Olazabal still facing a 25-foot putt to keep the match and Europe’s Ryder Cup alive. By the time Leonard belatedly called for the green to be cleared, the damage had been done. A clearly rattled Olazabal was unable to make his birdie and with that the US team had actually secured the trophy.

    In the aftermath, there was outrage and not just from this side of the Atlantic. European Ryder cup veteran Sam Torrance was particularly affronted: “It was the most disgraceful and disgusting day in the history of professional golf … The spectators behaved like animals and some of the American players acted like madmen”. He was not alone in his condemnation.  In the US, the LA Times wrote “The entire US team violated every principle of proper golf decorum and decent manners” and the Washington Post was similarly critical: “It seems an American team can’t get through an international competition without acting like jackasses at some point”.

    https://www.skysports.com/golf/video/31003/12967453/the-most-controversial-moment-in-ryder-cup-history-explained

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2004/sep/17/rydercup2004.rydercup3

    5. The best individual performance – Francesco Molinari, Le Golf National 2018

    All professional golfers are capable of moments or periods when they perform at a world-class level. The purple patch might last for a run of holes, a couple of rounds, a tournament or two or even for a whole season or more. The purple patch of Francesco Molinari, which lasted throughout 2018 was one of the more sustained and spectacular.

    Molinari was no journeyman. A pro since 2004 he had four European tour victories under his belt and had been a consistent presence around the top of the European Order of Merit. There was, though, a sense that he had underachieved, his excellent ball-striking let down by his relatively poor putting and what seemed at times to be a lack of nerve. In 2018 things seemed to click into place for the Italian. He gained some length off the tee, his putting stats improved and, most of all, his mental attitude seemed markedly more positive.

    He picked up the prestigious BMW PGA Championship at Wentworth holding off Rory McIlroy, then convincingly won his first US PGA victory in the Quicken Loans National. The piece de resistance was his capture of the Open Championship at Carnoustie, the first major victory ever for an Italian, where he coolly came through the field on the final day.  He was a shoo-in for the Ryder Cup team, but there were some reservations – Molinari had played in both the 2010 and 2012 teams, but despite being part of two winning teams he himself had yet to win a match. In six matches he had only two half points to his name.

    2018 in Paris was to be different. He found his perfect partner in Englishman Tommy Fleetwood. The pair were Europe’s only winners in the first morning’s fourballs, then they won again in the afternoon foursomes. They were at it again on day two, sending back Patrick Reed and Tiger Woods in the fourballs, then Woods and Bryson Dechambeau in the foursomes. It was not often that Woods was made to look ordinary (although his record in the Ryder Cup was not great) but Molinari had bested him three times out of three. While his partner, Fleetwood, ran out of puff in the singles, there was no such issue for Molinari. He took on and beat (a somewhat subdued) Phil Mickelson and finished his third Ryder Cup with a record of played five, won five, the only European ever to achieve this.

    Molinari’s form continued into 2019 before he, too, ran out of momentum. He won a second tournament in the US, the Arnold Palmer Invitational, and looked a likely winner of the Masters before falling away, but that was largely that for him. His purple patch was over, but boy oh boy, what a purple patch it was.

    https://www.skysports.com/golf/news/12176/11578924/reviewing-francesco-molinaris-history-making-exploits-in-2018

    6. The worst capitulation – Mark Calcavecchia, Kiawah Island 1991

    Withstanding the intense pressure of the Ryder Cup is a challenge for any golfer. You’re playing not only for yourself, but for your country, your fans and for your teammates. Listen to Jose Maria Olazabal “Anybody who doesn’t feel his legs trembling must be a dead man”; American David Toms “I expected to be nervous, but not that nervous. You don’t know what the pressure of a Ryder Cup is like unless you’ve been in one”; and Tom Lehman “I was way more nervous on the opening day of the Ryder Cup than the first round of any Major. Every Ryder Cup match is like being in the last group on Sunday in a Major”.

    It’s forgivable, therefore, that from time to time your performance might slip a little as you realise the magnitude of what you’re involved in. Many have fallen off, but perhaps none as dramatically as Mark Calcavecchia in 1991.

    Calcavecchia was a multiple winner on the US tour and had one Major, the 1989 Open, to his name. He was also a seasoned Ryder Cup campaigner having played in 1987 and 1989, with three wins balancing his four losses. He played well at Kiawah on the first two days winning two and losing one as the two days finished with the teams all square at 8-8. He was sent out third on singles day, where he was drawn against Colin Montgomerie, making his first appearance in the event.

    The American played extremely well … for fourteen holes. He led Montgomerie by four with four to play, a position from which he could not lose. It seemed another point for the US was in the bag. On the 15th, though, he hit a terrible drive and lost the hole. On 16 he got a little unlucky with his approach shot, then narrowly missed a long putt that would have clinched the win. On the par-3 17th he fell apart. Monty, playing first, put his tee shot into the water protecting the green. All Calcavecchia needed to do was keep his ball in play. Instead, he hit a smother shank and followed the Scotsman into the water. When both found the green with their second shots, a simple two putt would have done it. Calcavecchia put his approach putt to two feet, a tiddler that in other any circumstances Montgomerie would have conceded. He didn’t and the American missed it … badly. By the 18th his brain was fried. A tentative chip was followed by a dreadful putt and Calcavecchia had thrown away certain victory.

    He was so distraught he took himself off to the beach where he tried to contain his emotions. His consolation was that the US team won when Bernhard Langer missed a six-foot putt on the last that would have tied the match. A European had also succumbed to nerves.

    Happily, neither Calcavecchia nor Langer were permanently scarred by their tribulations. Both went on to further tournament victories, indeed Langer became the most successful seniors golfer ever. I suspect though that neither ever watch their DVDs of the 1991 Ryder Cup.

    7. The worst performance – Scheffler and Koepka, Marco Simone 2023

    There are many dismal defeats in Ryder Cup history but none were more surprising that the abject capitulation of Scottie Scheffler and Brooks Koepka in the Saturday morning foursomes in Italy in 2023.

    Scheffler came to the event as the recently crowned number one ranked golfer in the world. Aged only 27 he had won six tournaments on the PGA tour, and had already managed nine top 10 finishes in majors including a win in the 2022 Masters. Koepka arrived as the reigning PGA Champion, his fifth Major victory. Although there was some controversy over his selection as a member of the LiV tour, he was considered to be a reliable and dangerous member of the US team.

    Up against them was the Scandinavian duo of Norwegian, Viktor Hovland and Swede, Ludwig Aberg. Hovland was on a hot streak having recently captured the season-defining Fedex Championship. Aberg was super inexperienced, having only recently turned professional, but was rated the best newcomer to the tour since Tiger Woods.

    The first day had very much gone Europe’s way with no wins for the USA in a thumping 6 ½ to 1 ½ score. A fightback was expected. It did not come from Scheffler and Koepka. They started double bogey, double bogey, bogey to lose the first three then lost again to a tap in birdie for the Europeans on the par-3 4th . The 5th saw a rare half, but another birdie for the Scandinavian pair on the 6th took them to five-up. The 8th was conceded and the 9th saw another tap-in birdie. Seven down after nine and things did not get any better. A bogey on the 10th followed by another concession on the 11th and the match was all over.

    The score of 9&7 was the most crushing defeat in a Ryder Cup foursomes match ever, and was inflicted on two of the world’s best players. Scheffler was inconsolable, Koepka seemingly less bothered but possibly just been shell-shocked. Both recovered soon enough, with Koepka actually beating Aberg in the following day’s singles, but I suspect neither will be putting their hands up to play with each other again in foursomes.

    8. The worst teamwork – USA team, Gleneagles 2014

    A Ryder Cup player lavishing praise on their captain is something that you often see at the end of competition. Captains and their support team play a critical role in building the teamwork and creating the conditions in which the players can perform to their best. Tony Jacklin, Paul McGinley and American Billy Casper are amongst those who have been praised to the heavens for their leadership.

    So, when Phil Mickelson, in the immediate aftermath of the unsuccessful US campaign of 2014, extolled the virtues of his captain it might have been expected. Or it would have been had he been talking about his current captain, Tom Watson, and not his previous (successful) captain from six years before, Paul Azinger. And had Watson, not been sitting right alongside him in the press conference. Mickelson, whilst not mentioning Watson by name, was, with every word, aiming barbs and taking pot-shots at him.

    On Paul Azinger “He got everybody invested in the process… We were all invested in each other’s play… We had a real game plan”. On Tom Watson, nothing. When asked whether he was taking shots at Watson or his leadership style he denied it, but it was obvious to everybody that he was. His clincher was the line “Nobody here was (involved) in any decision”.

    Watson had been, of course, a brilliant golfer and had successfully captained the US team to a famous away victory at The Belfry in 1993 (their most recent win on European soil). His captaincy then had been praised for lowering the temperature after a feisty contest two years previously at Kiawah Island. He was nevertheless a surprise choice for 2014, considered a little out-of-touch with the current top players, and with a management style that was a little autocratic in an era of consultation and collaboration.

    Watson’s captaincy style was certainly not to Mickelson’s tastes. Mickelson, in the absence of the injured Tiger Woods, was the senior player and unofficial team leader on the US team. Despite a modest record in the competition, he was respected and well-liked by his teammates. As a veteran of nine Ryder Cups, he clearly felt he should be involved in key decisions about pairings and players. Watson felt otherwise. His selections on day one were questionable, particularly not playing Jordan Spieth and Patrick Reed in the afternoon after they had completed a thumping win in the morning. On day two, he lit the blue touch paper by not picking his senior player for either the morning or afternoon sessions. It was the first time in 10 events that Mickelson had sat out an entire day. The US team ended day two 6-10 behind, and were unable to make up any ground in the final day singles.

    Watson was gracious in defeat, certainly more so than Mickelson. “As for Phil’s comments, I completely understand his reaction in the moment… The bottom line is this: I was their captain. In hindsight, whatever mistakes that were made were mine. And I take complete and full responsibility for them.” Following a review, changes were made to team structure and captaincy for 2016 at Hazeltine. Perhaps Mickelson was right. The USA won that one 17-11.

    https://golf.com/news/tournaments/ryder-cup-revolution-the-day-and-press-conference-that-changed-team-usa

    https://www.golfdigest.com/story/ryder-cup-meltdown

    9. The worst pairing – Woods and Mickelson, Oakland Hills 2004

    Few things have been as pleasurable for European fans in the past 30 years as seeing the Ryder Cup struggles of both Tiger Woods and Phil Mickelson. The indisputable world number one during much of that period, Woods, played in eight Ryder Cups finishing on the winning side only once (in Brookline 1999), with a win-loss ratio of 13 wins to 21 losses (or 39% of points available). The almost-indisputable number two, Mickelson, has a slightly better record, winning 46% of possible points, but that’s still well below-par (or above-par depending on how you look at it) for a player with his ability.

    The two were never the best of buddies, with two very different and strong personalities, and in Ryder Cups they had always been kept apart from each other in any of the pairings. Being charitable, one could say that team captains wanted to distribute their genius amongst the ‘lesser’ team members. That was until 2004 when US team captain, Hal Sutton, went against history and decided that his two top players should be paired together.

    If the pair went out first it should guarantee a strong start for his team. They were drawn against the top-ranked European Padraig Harrington and Ryder Cup veteran, Colin Montgomerie in the fourballs. To be fair to Woods and Mickelson, their performance was not terrible, it was simply that the Europeans were better. The ‘dream team’ lost 2&1 as part of a 3 ½ to ½ morning romp by the visitors. Sutton had very much not got the start he had wished for.

    Their foursomes performance in the afternoon was also not awful, until the 18th hole that is. Playing another strong European pair of Darren Clarke and Lee Westwood, the match was all square coming down the last. In the unforgiving format that is foursomes, Mickelson sprayed his drive to the left, causing Woods to take a penalty drop. A double bogey followed and another defeat was incurred.

    Unsurprisingly the experiment was not repeated on day two, in fact it was never tried again. Either way, it did not help the US team – they subsided to a massive 18 ½ to 9 ½ defeat, the largest ever meted out by Europe on American soil.

    https://www.rydercup.com/news-media/that-tiger-woods-and-phil-mickelson-2004-ryder-cup-pairing-might-not-be-as-bad-as-we-remember

    10. The best pairing – Seve and Jose-Maria, 1987 to 1993

    To many people, it is Severiano Ballesteros who is the single most significant figure in the revival of the Ryder Cup as a contest since the early 1980s. After a somewhat inauspicious debut in 1979 (and refusing to play in 1981) he became the face of the European team and was its spiritual leader and most successful points winner for over a decade. His super strength came when he was one half of a pair – in both foursomes and four-balls – and his partnership with fellow Spaniard Jose Maria Olazabal became the most successful in Ryder Cup history.

    Olazabal was nine years Ballesteros’s junior and like his fellow Spaniard was something of a prodigy. He turned pro aged only 19, and in his rookie season finished second in the European Order of Merit. Seve came first. He was selected for his first Ryder Cup the following year, still only 21, to be played at Muirfield Village in Ohio. Captain Tony Jacklin obviously saw something he liked in Olazabal and picked him for the opening foursomes. He partnered him with Ballesteros and there was immediately a strong chemistry.

    In 1987 the pair kicked off with first day wins in both the foursomes and the four-ball before capturing another point in the next day’s foursomes. 1989 they achieved three wins and a half. In Brookline 1991 they repeated the feat. In total they played 15 matches together winning 11 and tying two. Olazabal was always fulsome in his praise for his partner.  “I was mesmerised. Seve had a will to win and determination that I don’t think has ever been matched. There were times you just had to wonder what he was made of. He took all the pressure off me, telling me not to worry if I hit into the rough or the trees or whatever.’’

    When Seve died at the tragically young age of 54 Olazabal was distraught. “He has been a real inspiration for me, the best friend I’ve had in my career. He was really the master.” He was able, though, to create a fitting tribute to Ballesteros as captain of the 2012 European Ryder Cup team. Decked out in navy blue and white clothing – Seve’s traditional colours – on the final day, and with the silhouette of the Spaniard on their kit, the team completed their unbelieveable comeback – the Miracle of Medinah. Even in death, Seve had been the perfect teammate.

    https://www.golfmonthly.com/news/seve-and-ollie-the-unheard-story-of-the-ryder-cups-greatest-partnership

    https://www.rydercup.com/news-media/who-is-europes-most-successful-partnership-at-the-ryder-cup

    11. The greatest exception to the rule – Lindrick 1959

    Between 1935 and 1983 there was really only one team in the Ryder Cup. In 20 outings the US team won 18 times and halved once. The exception to the rule was at Lindrick Golf Club in South Yorkshire in 1957.

    The US team was arguably one of the weakest they ever put out. Two of their two all-time greats, Sam Snead and Ben Hogan, elected to sit out the competition, and Major-winners Julius Boros and Cary Middlecoff were excluded having not played in the most recent PGA Championships. Notwithstanding these omissions, the team still included seven players who had already or would go on to win Major tournaments.

    The Great Britain team boasted no such riches – only one player, Max Faulkner had a Major to his name – but did have a new selection process based entirely on results. They also had a team with experience (there was only one rookie), albeit most players’ experience had been in losing!

    The format in 1957 was four games of foursomes on day one, followed on day two by eight singles matches. All were played to a maximum of 36 holes. As was customary in these times, the US team got off to a good start in the foursomes and led after day one by 3-1. The singles were a different matter. The GB team were inspired. At the half way point, they had comfortable leads in four of the eight matches;  by the end, six of the head-to-heads had been won against one solitary loss and a half. GB had won a (very) rare victory by the convincing margin of 7 ½ to 4 ½.

    The only sour note was sounded by Englishman Harry Weetman who was one of the two GB players left out of the singles by captain Dai Rees (not all the team played in the singles in the earlier years). Weetman was so upset that he stated publicly that he would not play for another team captained by Rees. Such dissent was frowned upon, and Weetman was suspended by the PGA before representations from Rees saw him reinstated. He may have wished his suspension had never been lifted. He played in a further three Ryder Cups only to finish with a dismal playing record of 2-11-2.

    12. The most surprising statistic – Ian Woosnam in singles, 1983 to 1997

    Ian Woosnam began his career as a golf professional at a time when European golf was in the doldrums. The Ryder Cup had not been captured since Lindrick in 1957, and only Seve Ballesteros was really flying the flag for Europe in the Major tournaments. By the time his career at the top began to wind down, he could say with confidence that he had been part of a great European revival. Sandy Lyle, Nick Faldo, Jose Maria Olazabal and Bernhard Langer had all joined Seve as Major champions, and Woosnam himself had a Masters title to his name as well as a spell ranked as number one in the world.

    He was an ever-present in the Ryder Cup from 1983 to 1997 and, overall, has a record to be proud of. In fourballs he reigned supreme with 10 wins to go against only 3 defeats and a tie. He also had a positive record in foursomes, gaining 56% of the points on offer. Mystifyingly, though, in eight attempts he never won a single singles match, losing six and tying two.

    His six losses were occasionally close, twice losing on the last and twice on the 17th, but not always. He also lost in the most embarrassing manner, 8&7 to Fred Couples in 1997, the worst defeat ever in an 18-hole singles match. He lost to higher ranked and to lower ranked players. He lost when he was sent out first and when he was sent out last. Apart from his two ties – also with Fred Couples in 1993 and 1995 – he simply lost.

    Woosnam, though, for all of his singles losses, was part of four wins for Europe, added to which he led the team to victory as captain in 2006. Ultimately, the Ryder Cup is all about the team, and Woosie proved himself to be the ultimate team man.

    The worst of the British Lions

    The history of the British (and for the past few decades the British and Irish) Lions is, to say the least, a little patchy. Whilst tours to Australia and Argentina have generally been successful, those to New Zealand and South Africa have been anything but. In 14 tours to South Africa there have been only four series wins (and two of these were in the 19th century) and our record is even worse in New Zealand with only one win in 12 attempts.

    As such, there are probably more bad moments than great moments, but fortunately many have been consigned to history. I’ve picked out just six of these, which if they do nothing else will remind us all that winning on these tours is not easy and should be celebrated however it comes.

    6. The worst tour ever? – South Africa 1924

    Not much is written about the 1924 British Isles tour to South Africa, but results would suggest that it was one of the least successful Lions tours. Not only was the test series lost 0-3 plus one game drawn, but six other defeats were experienced on the tour to leave the team with a record of won nine, lost nine, drawn three.

    There were several reasons put forward for the relatively poor performance. The British game was still weakened by the loss of so many young men after the First World War, and some of the better players may have been unavailable due to work commitments (the game was still resolutely amateur). Those that did go were unused to the hard, dry pitches in South Africa and injuries were rife. Home town refereeing may also have played a part. Most of the test matches were actually pretty close, but the South Africans came out on top in three and held on for a draw in the other.

    The tour was difficult, but does have the distinction of being the first in which the ‘Lions’ name was used (due to the heraldic lion in the badge) although it was not officially adopted until 1950. The team was captained by Ronald Cove-Smith of England. He will perhaps have enjoyed his England career more than his Lions career. He played in both the 1923 and 1924 Grand Slams before captaining his country to another in 1928. Cove-Smith was clearly a very good player and is almost certainly the only player in history to be described as a ‘rampaging Mephistopheles’ as he was by journalist Denzil Batchelor. These were different times in more ways than one.

    5. The interception – Second Test vs Australia, Melbourne 2001

    Jonny Wilkinson was a teenage phenomenon, prodigious enough to make his full England debut aged only 18. Two months on and he was chosen for his first overseas tour. He may well have wished it had come a little later. On what became known as ‘The Tour of Hell’ Jonny made his overseas test debut in a crushing 0-76 defeat to Australia at Brisbane before playing in another crushing defeat to the All Blacks. His first experience of the Southern hemisphere was brutal.

    If Wilkinson did have any scar tissue, he did not show it in the early stages of the 2001 Lions tour. He returned to the scene of the crime, Brisbane, for the first test and was an integral part of a superb 29-13 victory, embellished by a brilliant debut try for Jason Robinson.

    The second test looked like going the same way when two Wilkinson penalties and a Neil Back try saw the Lions into an 11-6 half time lead. The test, however, turned in the opening seconds of the second half. Receiving the ball from a scrum in his own half, Wilkinson sent a long, speculative pass towards Irish centre Rob Henderson. Aussie winger Joe Roff, anticipating, intercepted the pass then was able to beat the covering defence for a try. Interception tries in tight games can often change momentum and nowhere was it more true than here. The Lions seemed to droop, and Australia scored two more tries plus a handful of penalties to run away with the game.

    Although the third test was closer, Australia finished on top to win the series. Wilkinson’s error obviously was not the sole reason, but it was a significant turning point in a critical game. Wilkinson, of course, made amends (for England at least) in Australia in 2003, but never actually played in a series-winning Lions team.

    4. The ‘abject surrender’ – Fourth Test vs New Zealand, Auckland 1983

    The early 1980s was not a golden period for home nations rugby. The great Wales side of the 1970s had largely broken up, England had failed to build on their unexpected Grand Slam of 1980, and neither Scotland nor Ireland were dominant forces. In what were tough economic times, British and Irish rugby union had seemingly slipped into its own recession. 1983 was therefore not the best time for a Lions team to take on a tour to the stronghold that is New Zealand.

    Alarm bells were tinkled when the Lions lost 13-12 in only their second warm-up match, to strong provincial side Auckland. The ringing increased with defeat in the first test (12-16) then a shutout (0-9) in the second. When the third test was lost 15-8, despite scoring two tries to one, the series was lost and the Lions were now just playing for pride. Captain Ciaran Fitzgerald reflected this in his comments before the fourth and final test… “Individual pride and self respect for our rugby can win this test.” His optimism was misplaced.

    Played at Eden Park, Auckland, the fourth test was lost by the crushing margin of 38-6. The All Blacks, who had in truth found tries a little hard to come by in the first three tests (only one scored in each), managed to locate their scoring boots and ran in six.  Wing Stu Wilson scored a hat-trick which was added to by a trio of ‘H’s – Hobbs, Hewson and Haden. A Lions squad lacking in quality in forwards and backs alike was steamrollered.

    It remains the worst Lions defeat ever, and the team came home to talk as ‘the worst Lions ever’. That was somewhat unfair given the quality of the All Blacks, but this 0-4 whitewash was certainly a low point in recent Lions history.

    https://that1980ssportsblog.blogspot.com/2017/07/1983-new-zealand-v-lions-fourth-test.html

    3. Rog’s error of judgement – Second Test vs South Africa, Pretoria 2009

    Ronan O’Gara (or Rog pronounced ‘Roj’ to his pals) has proven throughout his career as a player, coach and, latterly, TV pundit that he has the very highest level of RI or ‘rugby intelligence’. Sadly, he temporarily mislaid this to damaging effect in the closing stages of the Second Test against the Springboks in 2009.

    The Lions had narrowly and controversially lost the first test. They had come back strongly from a 26-7 deficit to get within one score of a win, but were twice denied match-winning tries by the TMO in the last 10 minutes.

    The second test was another tight affair, with the Lions leading for almost all of the game. With an hour of the match gone, they held a convincing lead of 19-8. The lead was narrowed by a Bryan Habana try then, with minutes left on the clock, Springbok centre Jaque Fourie crossed the line to put his team in front for the first time in the match. It looked all over for the Lions but a Stephen Jones penalty levelled the scores with almost no time left for a decisive score. With the clock running down, and the scores tied at 25 points each, the Lions were still in the series.

    Enter Ronan O’Gara. O’Gara had come on as a replacement and had taken a knock to the head early on. He had been at fault for the Fourie try, perhaps suffering from his head injury in failing to make a tackle, but remained on the pitch. With thirty seconds remaining he collected a stray ball in the Lions 22. With coaches and commentators all calling for him to punt the ball as far as possible off the pitch he inexplicably opted for an up-and-under. As the high ball was caught by the South African number eight, O’Gara, chasing hard, collided with him, upending him while he was still in the air. The referee instantly and correctly gave a penalty to the Springboks. There was still a lot for Morne Steyn to do, but he landed the kick from inside his own half to give his side a match and a series win.

    To be fair to O’Gara, had it not been for a refereeing error, the Lions might have run away with the match before his fateful error. In the first minute of the game, Springbok flanker Schalk Burger was yellow carded for a suspected eye gouge. On any other day of the week this would have earned him a straight red card (in fact he was suspended for eight weeks on review) but French referee Christophe Berdos thought otherwise. C’est la vie.

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2009/jun/27/lions-south-africa-penalty-loss

    2. The tour that never really was – South Africa 2021

    There is no sporting event that is better without spectators. Whether they’re cheering you on or booing your every move, loud and raucous or eerily quiet, enjoying it or hating every minute, the crowd makes the atmosphere and the atmosphere makes it real. So, sport under COVID-19 was sport but not as we know it. Without fans in the stadium, everything felt a little flat, even (or especially) when crowd noise was artificially piped in.

    The 2021 Lions tour to South Africa had been much anticipated, but the pandemic put it under threat of relocation, postponement or even cancellation. In the event, it was played in South Africa as planned, but with no spectators present. Not only would the noisy and one-eyed Springbok support be absent, but there would also be none of the 10s of 1000s of travelling Lions fans.

    The tour started with disturbing echoes of 2005, when captain Alun Wyn Jones was forced out with a dislocated shoulder (the same injury suffered by skipper Brian O’Driscoll in 2005) in the warm-up match against Japan. Unlike that tour, however, the Lions, after four excellent wins and one defeat (to South Africa A) in the provincial games, managed to win the first test in Cape Town.

    This, though, was to be the high point for the Lions on the tour. The South Africans recovered to take a convincing victory in the second test, before narrowly edging the final test with a penalty kick in the 79th minute. The Springboks, midway between two Rugby World Cup victories, could lay claim to being the best rugby side in the world, but they were a long way from being the most entertaining or likeable. Their victories were built on a powerful set of forwards (in fact two powerful sets of forwards) and an attritional style in which they relentlessly ground down the opposition. To be fair, that is mainly sour grapes… the real problem with this tour was the lack of atmosphere. Defeat felt a little less real and important without the crowds, perhaps victory would also have tasted a little hollow.

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2021/aug/08/a-tour-that-failed-to-sparkle-has-done-the-lions-concept-few-favours

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/aug/07/steyn-shatters-lions-with-late-kick-to-edge-south-africa-to-series-win

    1. The spear tackle – First Test vs New Zealand, Christchurch 2005

    A tour to New Zealand is tough at the best of times, in fact there’s only been one Lions series victory – on the epic tour of 1971. If there was to be a glimmer of a chance for the tourists, though, perhaps it might have come in 2005. England had won the World Cup two years earlier and their players made up the bulk of the Lions squad. Meanwhile the All Blacks’ sheen of invincibility had been tarnished slightly with away defeats to both Australia and South Africa in 2004. The All Blacks were, of course, still an outstandingly good side and were extremely hard to beat on home soil.

    The Lions tour was led by World-Cup-winning England coach Clive Woodward. For someone who had got so much right with England, he made a number of missteps with the Lions. His squad selection seemed overly biased towards England, a team that in some decline since 2003;  he ended the practice of players rooming together, something that had fostered great team bonding in the past;  he allowed a them-and-us attitude to develop between the midweek and weekend teams;  and he brought along a massive back-up team, including spin doctor Alastair Campbell, that seemed over the top and unnecessary.

    A disappointing, error-strewn draw against Argentina in the warm-up game was a worrying sign of things to come. The Lions managed to win their first two games on tour – albeit at the cost of losing Lawrence Dallaglio to injury – but then suffered an unexpected loss to the New Zealand Maori. Three tough and relatively unconvincing wins later and they arrived in Christchurch to face the All Blacks in the first test.

    The series was arguably lost within the first two minutes. The player chosen to captain the 2005 Lions team was talismanic Irish centre, Brian O’Driscoll, probably the best player in the home nations at the time. The All Blacks clearly saw him as a threat, and set out to neutralise him as early as possible. Less than one minute into the game the Irishman made a tackle on the halfway line and helped to form a ruck over the ball. He was then targeted by All Black centre Tana Umaga and hooker Kevan Mealamu, both of who grabbed a leg of O’Driscoll before lifting him up and dumping him headfirst on the ground. O’Driscoll was fortunate not to break his neck, but still found himself in agonising pain with a badly dislocated shoulder. He was to play no further part in the tour, in fact he did not play again at all for five months.

    Alarmingly, neither Umaga nor Mealamu were penalised for the offence. Had it taken place in recent years, both would have received immediate red cards and long suspensions.

    The Lions did not recover from the loss of their captain and best player, and crashed to a 21-3 defeat, the first leg of a depressing 0-3 whitewash in the series. Perhaps they would still have lost with O’Driscoll, but it would certainly have been closer … and fairer, had he not been so brutally and illegally forced out of it.

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jun/25/british-and-irish-lions-australia-new-zealand-tour-brian-o-driscoll-rugby-union

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-union/2017/05/29/special-report-inside-story-worst-lions-tour-history

    The best of the British Lions

    The greatest sporting events are those that come around sparingly. The football World Cup, the Olympic Games, the rugby World Cup, an away Ashes series. With these, the stakes are so much higher for fans and players alike when the next chance to win may be four years away.

    The tours of the British and Irish Lions are, if anything, even more sparing. Yes, they work to the same four-year cycle, but it’s 12 years if you’re a Kiwi, a Wallaby or a Springbok. For most of these, a Lions tour really is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

    Players from Britain and Ireland have a chance every four years, but it’s extra special for them too. Being selected for the tour and then picked for the matchday XV means that you are officially one of the best of the best from the four home countries. You’ll be playing alongside men who have been your bitter and fierce rivals for years, and will be carried along by extraordinary support from tens of thousands of travelling fans. A Lions tour really is the pinnacle for most rugby players.

    Lions tours have produced so many memorable moments that choosing the very best is a tough task. I hope you find this selection agreeable and, even if not, that it brings back some happy and vivid memories from years gone by. 

    6. Warburton’s intervention – Third test, Auckland 2017

    For some Lions fans, the drawn series against the All Blacks in 2017 was something of an anticlimax. Having been comprehensively outplayed in the first test, the Lions had clawed their way back into the series and came to the third and final test in sight of the rarest of the rare – a series win in New Zealand. To ‘only’ draw the final test and, with that, the series, seemed like an opportunity lost. Only it wasn’t. The Lions came extremely close to losing the match and the series, and it may only have been the intervention of Lions captain, Sam Warburton, that saved the day.

    Warburton was one of those guys born to be a leader. Captain of Wales at U-18, U-19 and U-20 levels, he was made captain of his national side at just 22 years old, with only the great Gareth Edwards having achieved the honour sooner. In 2013, still only 24, he became the youngest captain of the British and Irish Lions for their tour to Australia, and four years later, he was the obvious choice to lead the 2017 tour to New Zealand.

    Warburton had had to miss the final test on the 2013 tour due to a hamstring injury, so felt he had “unfinished business”. The final test of 2017 was his chance to finish the business. The match was extremely tight. The All Blacks scored two tries, but four penalties for the Lions meant the game entered the final quarter all square at 12-12. A Beauden Barrett penalty for the home side was squared up by a late penalty from the Lions’ Owen Farrell and with three minutes remaining on the clock a draw seemed inevitable.

    That was until the All Blacks restart. They lofted the ball into the Lions half where full-back Liam Williams leapt but failed to collect in the air, knocking the ball slightly forward. Lions replacement hooker, Ken Owens, tracking back just in front of Williams, made to catch the ball before dropping it like a hot potato. Owens knew he was in front of Williams, and the French referee, Romain Poite, signalled immediately for a penalty for offside. As the stadium erupted, Warburton remained cool and politely encouraged Poite to reconsider. Poite consulted with his assistants and revised his decision from penalty to scrum – he had judged Owen’s offside to be accidental.

    Another captain might have blundered in or been overly aggressive. Warburton was respectful and measured. Poite is too good a referee to be unduly influenced, but Warburton’s measured approach could not have hurt. The Lions drew the match and tied the series – still a superb achievement in New Zealand.

    https://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/40543506

    https://www.espn.co.uk/rugby/story/_/id/31723243/romain-poite-admits-wrong-decision-2017-british-irish-lions-test

    5. George North announces himself – First test, Brisbane 2013

    George North was just 18 when he was selected to represent Wales in 2010. A measure of how prodigious his talent was is that he was picked for what was then the strongest team in the Six Nations, then proved to be a significant factor in Wales winning two successive Six Nations campaigns, including the Grand Slam in 2012. By 2013, and still only 21, North was a pretty unanimous choice not only for the Lions squad but also for the starting line-up in the tests. (NB. It’s worth remembering that compared to the 2025 series in which only two Welshmen made the squad, in 2013 EIGHT Welshmen were picked for the starting XV in the first test.)

    Lined up against North was the Australian superstar wing Israel Folau, himself only 24. A recent convert from rugby league, Folau was a similar size and speed to North and was making his debut in a Wallaby shirt. It was Folau who made the first impact, backing up a superb run by scrum-half Will Genia to finish a length-of-the-pitch try in the corner.

    North, though, was not to be outshone. On 25 minutes the ball was hoisted high into the Lions half by Aussie fly-half Berrick Barnes. North caught the ball just behind his own 10-metre line. A shuffle of the feet and he had evaded the first chasing Aussie flanker. Then an acceleration past James O’Connor’s attempted ankle tap and a poorly placed Folau. The field opened up but North still had plenty work to do. Appearing to apply the afterburners, he skipped past a despairing dive from Barnes before rounding Genia on the outside to finish off a stunning solo try. Perhaps it was unnecessary for him to goad Genia as he passed him, but sometimes you can forgive the audacity of youth.

    The game was too young for North’s try to be the decisive action, in fact it was a game that could easily have gone to the Wallabies. Folau, who added a second superb try to his first, arguably had more impact on the game than North. But, once Australia’s Kurtley Beale missed a very gettable penalty in the closing moments, the result went the way of the Lions. The 21-year-old Welshman would go on to create other moments of magic in the series, but his debut Lions try was unforgettable.

    4. Campese’s gift – Third Test, Sydney 1989

    If there’s one thing that a Lions team really does not want on tour, it’s a defeat in first test of a series. Only once have the Lions come back from a 0-1 deficit.  That time was in 1989 in Australia, and one of the principal contributors to their comeback was one of the best rugby players in the world (and also one of the most arrogant), Wallaby wing David Campese.

    The tour was the first since 1899 to come exclusively to Australia. Australian rugby union had not been considered strong enough to host a Lions tour (it is a minority sport in the country after Aussie rules, rugby league and cricket) so the country had been visited only as part of a wider tour to New Zealand. The success, though, of the 1984 Wallabies, who completed an unprecedented grand slam on a tour of the four home nations, signalled that the team and the country were ready.

    The Wallabies certainly started the series with a bang. A strong, aggressive performance by their forwards in the first test delivered a solid platform for the excellent half back partnership of Nick Farr-Jones and Michael Lynagh, and Australia dominated pretty much every aspect of the game. The final tally was four tries to nil and a thumping scoreline of 30 points to 12.

    The second test in Brisbane saw some important changes made to the Lions team. Into the forwards came England’s Mike Teague and Wade Dooley, two tough-as-teak operators, and into the backs came Rob Andrew, Jeremy Guscott and Scott Hastings. The Lions came out fighting, literally (the match was christened ‘The Battle of Ballymore’ by the Aussie press), in an attempt to wrestle back the advantage that the Aussie pack had gained a week earlier. They certainly succeeded in evening up the score, but the match was still incredibly tight and was decided in the Lions favour only with two tries in the final five minutes.

    So, onto Sydney for the third test and series decider. By now the Lions forwards had warmed to the task and scented blood. They dominated their hosts, but the Lions struggled to convert possession and pressure into points. By half time they should have been well ahead, but the scores were tied at 9-9. The critical moment came six minutes into the second half. Lions fly half Rob Andrew badly fluffed a drop goal attempt and the ball was collected easily just behind his goal line by winger David Campese. Campese could, and should, have touched down for a 22-metre drop out but, instead and inexplicably, he ran the ball out of his goal area before lobbing a hospital pass to his full back, Greg Martin. Martin, totally unprepared for the pass, dropped the ball over his line where Lions wing, Ieuan Evans, lurking without any realistic expectation, pounced greedily upon it to claim a try. An enraged Australian TV commentator declared “you don’t wear a green and gold jersey to pull out that sort of mickey mouse rugby!”.

    It was to be the decisive score of the match. Although the Aussies never stopped battling, and brought the score back to only a one-point game (18-19) with time still on the clock, the Lions were able to hold and clinch the tightest of series wins.

    Campese met with a barrage of criticism for his error, but was largely unrepentant. He was a player who tried to make things happen and his view was that sometimes this can rebound on you. It certainly didn’t affect his rugby career. He went on to be voted player of the tournament in Australia’s victorious rugby world cup campaign of 1991, to be the first Wallaby to play 100 times for the country and was the world’s leading international try scorer by the time he hung up his boots.  For all his successes, though, he never won a series against the Lions.

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/the-lions-down-under-1989

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/that-1980s-sports-blog/2013/jul/05/david-campese-stray-pass-lions-1989

    3. “This is your Everest” – First Test, Newlands 1997

    Tours to South Africa are extraordinarily tough. Rugby is the symbol of South African national price, and the Springboks are typically big and strong, aggressive in defence and attack and prepared to go to any lengths, legal or otherwise, to win. As the final Lions tour of the 20th century approached, the tourists could look back on a hundred-year period in which they had played nine series and won only one (the epic series of 1974) having lost seven.

    The touring side was built on a rump of players from England, by some distance the best home country in that year’s Five Nations. They were captained by Martin Johnson, not yet England captain but already on his way to all-time-great status, and coached by two Scots, both former Lions, Ian McGeechan and Jim Telfer.

    It was Telfer who was to provide one of the most memorable moments from this or indeed any tour, a moment that might have gone unnoticed had it not been for the behind-the-scenes documentary, ‘Living with Lions’. Granted unprecedented access to the training ground and changing room, the filmmakers were able to capture a truly inspirational speech by the Scotsman.

    The 1997 tour saw eight matches to be navigated before the start of the test series.  The Lions played well, winning seven out of eight games against the provinces, but some doubts remained about the strength and depth of their forwards. When they arrive at Newlands, Cape Town for the first test it was the job of Telfer, the forwards coach, to prepare them for battle. His speech is worth listening to in full, but this excerpt captures the essence of it.

    The easy bit has passed. Selection for the Test team is the easy bit. You have an awesome responsibility on the eight individual forwards’ shoulders. An awesome responsibility. This is your Everest, boys. Very few ever get a chance in rugby terms to get for the top of Everest. You have the chance today. Being picked is the easy bit. To win for the Lions in a Test match is the ultimate, but you’ll not do it unless you put your bodies on the line, every one jack of you for 80 minutes. Defeat doesn’t worry me. I’ve had it often and so have you. It’s performance that matters. If you put in the performance, you’ll get what you deserve. No luck attached to it. 

    You are privileged. You are the chosen few. Many are considered but few are chosen. They don’t think f*** all of us. Nothing. We’re here just to make up the f***ing numbers. No one’s going to do it for you. You have to find your own solace — your own drive, your ambition, your own inner strength, because the moment’s arrived for the greatest game of your f***ing life.”

    We’ll never know the extent to which Telfer’s passionate oratory did or didn’t made the difference – representing the Lions anyway creates a huge amount of self-motivation – but what we did see was a fiercely determined effort from the forwards. They didn’t dominate, but they did compete against a South African pack built behind the immovable man-mountain prop, Os Du Randt. And the game was extremely close with the Springboks ahead for most of it. It turned, however, on a moment of magic in the 72nd minute, a moment that could itself easily rank as one of the greatest Lions moments.

    The Lions trailed 16-15, knowing that a single score would see them into the lead. They won a scrum just outside the South African 22-metre line. The scrum held firm and wheeled slightly to the right. Scrum half Matt Dawson, only in the team only because of an injury to first-choice Rob Howley, picked up and took off down the blind side towards the touchline. With no room to squeeze through, he made to pass the ball back inside to his forwards. This move, though, was a huge dummy that utterly flummoxed the two closest South African defenders, stopping them dead in their tracks. It created a gap that Dawson sprinted through for the most glorious of tries. A second try, five minutes later, for Scotsman Alan Tait, put the icing on the cake for a 25-16 opening victory.

    The second test delivered another magic moment for the Lions. The contest was again super tight with the Lions recovering from a 6-point deficit to tie the score at 15-15 with minutes remaining. The Lions forwards had progressed to within five or so metres of the try line when a ruck formed. Dawson, again playing his part, spotted centre Jeremy Guscott standing a little back from the attacking line, and delivered a perfect pass to his England teammate. Guscott, ever the star, landed an unlikely but perfect drop goal to take the Lions to a second and decisive win.

    McGeechan and Telfer had led their Lions to only their second series victory in South Africa in a century. Their leadership and inspiration had been key to giving the Lions the little extra that made all the difference.

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/feature-the-story-of-everest

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/on-this-day-dawson-sets-1997-lions-up-for-series-victory

    2. The King delivers a masterclass – Third Test, Wellington 1971

    The holy grail for the British and Irish Lions is a series win against the All Blacks. Since they first toured New Zealand in 1904, there has only been one such victory, in 1971, when what may be the greatest-ever Lions team visited the country.

    The Lions team was built around the then-dominant Wales team. They supplied 14 (including uncapped flanker Derek Quinnell) of the 33-man squad and were well-supported by greats from the other home countries including Willie-John McBride and Mike Gibson of Ireland, Ian ‘Mighty Mouse’ McLauchlan of Scotland and David Duckham of England.

    The tour got off to a poor start in Australia with a defeat to state side Queensland. The home coach described the team as the worst Lions ever, but this was typical Australian bravado. There was to be only one further defeat for the Lions in their remaining 25 matches.

    The first test against the All Blacks, in Dunedin, was a somewhat turgid affair, but the Lions prevailed 9-3 with a try and two penalties versus just one penalty. Going into the second test, the Lions, after 15 straight wins on tour, were perhaps a little over-confident, and they lost convincingly by 22-12, conceding five tries to two of their own. With three weeks between tests, though, they had time to re-group, and they arrived in Wellington for the third test having rebuilt their confidence with four solid wins against the provinces.

    The star of the 1971 team was 26-year-old fly half, Barry John of Cardiff and Wales. John was a beautifully balanced runner who could ghost past opposition defenders, could defend well and was a superb kicker from both feet as well as from the ground. A great reader of the game, John seemed to have more time than anyone around him and had a gift for seeing space where none appeared to exist. He had played well in the first two tests but in the third he really came into his own. He contributed a try, a drop goal and two conversions, and his tactical kicking consistently put the All Blacks on the defensive. His points plus another try, from his Welsh teammate Gerald Davies, saw the Lions to a superb 13-3 victory.

    There was still, though, more for the Lions to do as the 1971 series comprised four tests, not three like today. A win for New Zealand in the final test, at fortress Eden Park in Auckland, would see the series tied and the Lions denied their first-ever series victory. It was another terribly close match, in which the decisive score was that rarest of rarities, a drop goal by Welsh full-back JPR Williams. JPR had never scored a drop goal in internationals (and never did so again) but attempted a long-range one here with the match tied at 11-11. It sailed over the posts and, despite their best efforts, the All Blacks could only find one more score, a penalty, so the game finished in a draw. The Lions had won the series 2-1 with this test tied.

    Barry John, ‘The King’, who was coolness personified on the pitch, did not much enjoy his fame and celebrity off it. A humble man, he lived in a rugby-mad country where he was treated like a God. He found the pressure too much and retired within a year of his epic Lions tour. He was only 27, but he had secured his legacy in helping the Lions achieve their holy grail. That it has not been achieved since is testament to his brilliance and to the talents and endeavours of his 1971 teammates.

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/history/year-by-year/the-greatest-ever-tour

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/a-remarkable-achievement

    https://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/58128404

    1. The Battle of Boet Erasmus – Third Test, Port Elizabeth 1974

    There is a strong case to be made that the Lions tour to South Africa of 1974 should never have taken place. The apartheid state of South Africa was shunned by nations across the world, and its sports teams were excluded from almost every international competition. In Britain, the labour government under Harold Wilson was utterly opposed to the Lions tour, and much of the British public felt that it should be called off. Despite all of this, it did go ahead, and it produced possibly the greatest ever tour performance by a Lions squad.

    The Lions had not won a test series in South Africa since 1896, experiencing 3-0 series whitewashes on each of the two most recent tours, in 1962 and 1968. The squad of 1974, however, arrived with justifiable optimism. Many of the players, including inspirational captain Willie John McBride (on his fifth tour!), had been on the successful 1971 tour to New Zealand and several were at or approaching their peak. The Springboks, meanwhile, had played only one full international in three years (a home defeat to England in 1972). While the home side would undoubtedly be a little ring-rusty, but there was no question that they would be as physical and aggressive as ever, pushing the laws of the game to their limits, and occasionally well beyond.

    The Lions were prepared for this and determined not to cede supremacy in the physical battle. They decided that if retaliation was needed, they would get it in first. Thus the ’99 call’ was created. It was a policy of ‘one in, all in’. If one Lion got involved in a scuffle, all of his teammates were expected to get stuck in, regardless of where they were on the pitch. The premise was that, if 15 fights were breaking out around him, the referee would be unable to pick out any individual player and penalise them. The call itself was used sparingly, but the principle worked, with the Lions more than holding their own in what was often more of a fight than a rugby match.

    The Lions were, of course, not all about aggression. Their back line was perhaps their best ever with the world-class pairing of Gareth Edwards and Phil Bennett at half-back, serial try scorer JJ Williams on the wing and the inestimable JPR Williams at full-back. There were no obvious weaknesses in the team.

    After breezing through their warm up games, the first two tests (of four) were won fairly comfortably by the Lions, who managed to prevent the Springboks scoring a single try. The tourists came to the third test, at Boet Erasmus stadium in Port Elizabeth, knowing that a win or draw would see a series victory secured. They knew that the Springboks would come out hard, and that the contest would be extremely physical. The result was a game that former Wales and Lions flanker, Clem Thomas, described this as “the most violent I have ever witnessed”.

    The Springboks, with the series on the line, were relentless from the first whistle, but the Lions defence stood firm. Scuffles broke out sporadically, but the Lions fought as a team. Then just before half time, on a rare foray into the South African 25, Scot Gordon Brown bundled over following a line-out and the tourists went into a 7-3 lead. The second half saw the tourists take control, and with JJ Williams scoring two superb tries, they ran out 26-9 winners for an unassailable 3-0 lead in the series. Willie-John was chaired from the pitch by his teammates.

    The game is also remembered for an incident that has probably featured in more after-dinner speeches than any other. Springbok lock Johan de Bruyn lost his glass eye after being punched by Lions try-scorer Gordon Brown. The game was halted while all 30 players and the officials searched for the eye on the ground. Once found, de Bruyn coolly popped it back in its socket and the game continued. Brown, who sadly died at the age of only 53, always joked that de Bruyn had not removed all the grass and that some blades poked out for the remainder of the game.

    The Lions should probably have completed a 4-0 clean sweep, but some controversial refereeing decisions (home referees were still employed in the 70s) meant the fourth and final game finished in a 13-13 draw. A 3-0-1 series and an unbeaten tour was still an incredible achievement for ‘the Invincibles’.

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-union/2021/07/24/battle-boet-erasmus-99-invincibles-lions-1974-tour-south-africa

    https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/history/year-by-year/1974-the-invincibles-win-21-out-of-22

    The worst of Wimbledon

    It’s not easy picking the worst of Wimbledon. After all, one man’s disaster is almost always another’s triumph. A shock defeat for the top seed in the first round may well represent the greatest victory in a career for a journeyman. A collapse when on the verge of victory means an incredible comeback for the opponent who was ready to pack their bags.

    I’ve tried, therefore to find games that failed to meet expectations, where there was little contest or entertainment or where the sentimental favourite failed to turn up. See what you think. You may have other memories of games that disappointed.

    7. Novotna v Graf, Women’s Final 1993

    I’ve referenced this in my best moments blog (1998 womens final) but have to include the original disappointment in my list of the worst moments.

    Jana Novotna was a talented stroke maker whose all-round game could work on all surfaces, but whose strengths were best-suited to the grass courts of SW19. In 1993, seeded eighth, she surpassed expectations by beating fourth seed, Gabriela Sabatini (for the first time in seven matches) in the quarter final, and her hero, Martina Navratilova (second seed) in the semis. The final saw her pitted against top seed and four-time champion Steffi Graf.

    The first set went to Graf on a tie break but Novotna then upped her levels. She cruised to 6-1 in the second then swiftly to 4-1 in the third. With a game point on serve the final looked hers to lose. And lose it she did. A nervy double fault on game point, gave Graf an opening that she grasped in both hands. More double faults and a series of unforced errors (and, let’s not forget, consistent pressure applied by Graf) saw Novotna lose five games in a row to throw away her best chance at the title.

    She knew she had bottled it and this came out in her emotional outburst at the prize-giving. Professional athletes are normally conditioned to show little emotion when they lose but Novotna was inconsolable, sobbing uncontrollably as she was presented with her runner-up plate by Princess Michael of Kent. Thank goodness she came back to win five years later – for this or her subsequent defeat in 1997 to have been the final chapter in her Wimbledon story would have been thoroughly sad.

    6. Sampras v Ivanisevic, Men’s Final 1994

    Men’s grass court tennis in the 1980s and 1990s was not always especially entertaining. A succession of tall and strong purveyors of serve and volley tennis dominated with only the exceptional Andre Agassi interrupting the flow. The apotheosis was reached with Pete Sampras, winner of thirteen Grand Slam titles from 1990 to 2002. With a game built upon his powerful first AND second serve and superb volleying, he was almost unbeatable on grass, winning the Wimbledon Championships seven times over an eight-year period.

    In 1994 he strolled through the tournament, losing only one set (to another big-serving American, Todd Martin) on his way to the final. To win his second title he would face Croat, Goran Ivanisevic, arguably an even bigger server than Sampras, who had similarly lost only one set in his six matches to date.

    The final was played on a hot day, the mercury in the thermometer expanding to record a very non-British 30 degrees centigrade. Warmer temperatures mean that the ball speeds up, so the fast-serving contest that was anticipated became even more inevitable.

    The first two sets could not be described as interesting. Neither player looked like breaking the other’s serve and both sets went to a tie-break that Sampras won. In the third set, Ivanisevic cracked and Sampras broke three times to win 7-6 7-6 6-0. In just under two hours of power tennis there had not been a single rally of more than six strokes.

    The game was sufficiently dull that it precipitated a change to Wimbledon’s set-up. The organisers commissioned a new ball that would be a little softer and slower, and changed the composition and cut of the grass to try and slow down the surface. The big servers would continue to dominate for a few more years, but once the change did come it meant, thankfully, that finals like 1994 became a relic of the past.

    5. Tsonga v Tomic, Men’s First Round 2019

    Bernard Tomic was a good enough tennis player to reach a world ranking as high at number 17 and to earn over $6m in prize money. A prodigious talent as a teenager, he became at 17 the youngest player ever to represent Australia in the Davis Cup, and he reached the quarter finals of Wimbledon before his 19th birthday.

    Alongside his undoubted tennis talent, he also, unfortunately had a talent for controversy. In the course of his career there were altercations with officials, with playing partners and with his seemingly overbearing father, added to which there were one or two issues of law breaking. Perhaps most damaging to his reputation, however, was the thought that when playing tennis, Tomic was not really trying.

    The Australian himself, did little to scotch this reputation. There were matches at the 2016 Sydney International and at the same year’s Madrid Masters where he appeared not to bother, and in 2017 he was fined at Wimbledon for saying in his post-match news conference that he had been a ‘little bored’ in his first round defeat to Sascha Zverev. It was in 2017 that he gave an infamous interview on Australia’s The Seven Network in which he claimed “I think all my career’s been around 50% and I haven’t really tried … so just amazing what I’ve done.” The response of the tennis world, indeed the wider sporting world was not positive.

    Tomic may well have been suffering from burn-out and poor mental health, but he got little sympathy when two years later he once again seemed not to try at Wimbledon. Despite the decline in his world ranking, he qualified for the 2019 first round where he faced Frenchman Jo-Wilfried Tsonga.  The match was a match in name only. Tsonga romped to victory in straight sets in a match that took only 58 minutes. Tomic claimed he had felt unwell, but this cut no ice with the Grand Slam board who fined the Australian 100% of his match fee, £45,000, for not performing “to a professional standard”. Their decision letter was cutting “A review of your historical record of misconduct at Grand Slams, never mind elsewhere, provides little justification for [any mitigation]”, adding “there is no historical evidence to give comfort to the theory that you can reform your behaviour.” With Tomic it probably was a case of too much too soon and after he had got as far as he could, he simply could not be bothered.  

    4. McEnroe vs Tom Gullikson, Men’s First Round 1981

    In 1981 John McEnroe came to Wimbledon as second seed and as two-time US Open Champion. The first couple of rounds are normally a formality for the top seeds, and McEnroe’s opener was no different – it pitted him against fellow American, Tom Gullikson, a decent doubles player alongside his identical twin, Tim, but no real match in singles for the 22-year-old American. The match would have passed by unnoticed had it not been for the most infamous outburst in Wimbledon’s history.

    The fun started when McEnroe had a first serve called out by the centre line judge. Clips of the incident suggest that the ball hit the centre line, and it’s extremely safe to say that that was McEnroe’s view. When the match umpire, Edward James, upheld the call following McEnroe’s relatively polite query, the American went on the offensive.  “You can’t be serious man. You CANNOT BE SERIOUS! That ball was on the line. Chalk flew up. It was clearly in. How can you possibly call that out?” When McEnroe hit his second serve out to record a double fault, the touchpaper had been well and truly lit.

    A couple of games later Gullikson was serving. At 0-30 and facing a possible break, Gullikson looked to have served long, but no fault was called. When McEnroe made a frustrating error to lose the point, he turned to the line judge and umpire to once again question their judgement. The umpire confirmed that the serve had been in (it does not look in on the video footage) causing a furious McEnroe to utter another memorable phrase “you guys are the absolute pits of the world, you know that”. Cue a penalty point for McEnroe, which led to him walking off the court demanding an audience with the tournament referee, Fred Hoyles.

    The reaction of the 1981 Wimbledon crowd to McEnroe’s altercation with Hoyles is indicative of a more genteel era. Scattered booing, a slow handclap and applause when the penalty point was upheld show that their sympathies were not entirely with the petulant American. McEnroe though could not have cared less what the crowd thought. He was fired with a sense of injustice and a desire to win at all costs.

    McEnroe managed to hold himself enough in check to win the match in straight sets, and started a run that took him all the way to the final. Here he unforgettably managed to avenge his epic defeat of the previous year to Bjorn Borg.

    In subsequent years it was thought that McEnroe amped up the ‘superbrat’ behaviour to not only intimidate the umpires but also to put off his opponents. But in 1981, it just looks like the reaction of a volatile young man unable to control his emotions.

    3. Kraijcek vs Washington, Men’s Final 1996

    It should really be something to be celebrated – the lowest seed in the tournament, Dutchman Richard Krajicek, meeting an unseeded and unheralded outsider, American MaliVai Washington, in the final. The lack of star quality, however, was evident in what was a very underwhelming finale to the 1996 Championships.

    The tournament saw a string of top seeds eliminated in the early stages. Andre Agassi (3rd), Yevgeny Kafelnikov (5th), Michael Chang (6th) and Jim Courier (8th) all went out to unseeded opponents in the first round and Boris Becker (2nd) had to retire in round three with a wrist injury. Only four seeds, one of whom was Krajicek (seeded only because Thomas Muster had dropped out before the tournament), made it through to the quarter-finals.

    In the quarters, Krajicek had to get past top seed Pete Sampras, which was perhaps the performance of the tournament (it was Sampras’s only defeat at Wimbledon between 1993 and 2000). In the semis, Washington had to outlast 13th seed Todd Martin (coming back from 1-5 down in the fifth set) in what was perhaps the match of the tournament.

    The final, though, was one big anti-climax. Krajicek, a big server, powered his way to a straight sets victory in a miserly 94 minutes. Yes, there were a handful of decent rallies, but it was a match that would not have looked out of place on Court 13 on the first Thursday. To be fair to both, it was an era when the grass courts were super fast, so big servers dominated and rallies were short. But even by those standards, this final was particularly unmemorable.

    2. King vs Goolagong – Women’s Final 1975

    In women’s tennis, the best of three sets format can produce some very one-sided games. At Wimbledon there have been several women’s finals that have been won in straight sets, and some that have been over and done with in less than an hour.

    In the Amateur era there were actually a number of finals that finished in less than 30 minutes. One even involved the embarrassment of a double bagel – Dorothea Chambers beating Dora Boothby 6-0 6-0 in 1911. Things have improved in the Open era but there have still been many examples of the loser winning a mere three or four games across the two sets.

    Perhaps the worst of these was Billie Jean King’s dismantling of Evonne Goolagong in 1975. Goolagong, the winner in 1971, had played well to get the final beating home favourite, Virginia Wade in the quarters and Aussie legend, Margaret Court in the semis. But, for whatever reason, she barely turned up for the final. The result was a crushing 6-0 6-1 victory for King, and the game lasted a hardly noticeable 36 minutes.

    Goolagong was not the sort to make excuses. She was off her game and Billie Jean King was completely on top of hers. She was simply not good enough on the day. Strangely, this dominant performance from King was to be her last appearance in a Grand Slam singles final. Goolagong, meanwhile, recovered from her setback to contest six more finals winning three of them.

    Postscript – 12 July 2025 – Having just witnessed the catastrophic falling apart of Amanda Anisimova in the 2025 final vs Iga Swiatek (6-0 6-0 if you weren’t watching) I’m tempted to replace King-Goolagong. Suffice to say that witnessing this was not a pleasant experience and I wish Anisimova a very speedy recovery.

    1. Rosewall vs Connors – Men’s Final 1974

    In 1974 Australian Ken Rosewall made his way to the Wimbledon final. Ordinarily, the fact that the ninth seed and a former world number one had reached the final would not be much of a story, but by 1974 Rosewall was 39 years old and this, his fourth appearance in the final, came a full 20 years after his first.

    Rosewall was very much the sentimental favourite. A winner of eight previous Grand Slams (four Australian, two French and two US Opens), the Australian had never managed to win Wimbledon, losing in each of the three previous finals he had reached. He was considered one of the game’s greatest stylists, something of a relic from a previous, more genteel era, but he was still highly competitive.

    Unfortunately for Rosewall, his opponent in the Wimbledon final was the up-and-coming American Jimmy Connors. Connors was young, fit, strong and aggressive, the best exponent of a new brand of tennis that relied more on pace and power than on clever shot making. He simply blew Rosewall away in the final, winning in straight sets – 6-1 6-1 6-4.  The game was over in a mere 93 minutes.

    Many others would have packed their bags for good after such a thrashing, but Rosewall was resilient. Indeed, he bounced back to make the US Open final later the same year. Perhaps he wished he hadn’t. Up against Connors again, this final was even more one-sided, 6-1 6-0 6-1 in 1hr 18 mins for the shortest major men’s final in history. One era of tennis was clearly ending and another starting.

    The best of Wimbledon

    To most tennis fans Wimbledon is the greatest of the four tennis grand slams. Every year the best players from around the world converge on SW19 to play on grass at the tournament with more history than any other.

    My selection of great moments at Wimbledon has, inevitably, something of a recency bias. My first vague memories of the Championships date back to the early 70s when the sport was becoming professional and games were starting to be broadcast in colour. Over the last 50 or so years we’ve seen tennis players who can be ranked amongst the greatest sportsmen of all time in any sport, incredible duels between players of different styles and characters, and even the advent of a more unusual phenomenon, British players who win.  

    See what you think of my selection. Whether you agree or disagree hopefully reading this will bring back some happy memories.

    8. Wade vs Stove – Women’s Final 1977

    Since the end of the Williams era (Venus and Serena), the ladies singles at Wimbledon has become a very open event. In fact, at time of writing (2025), there have been eight different winners in the last eight years. It was not always like this.

    In the mid 70s and early 80s, there were three women who ruled the roost and gave anyone else barely a look-in – Billie Jean King with three wins, Chris Evert with another three and Martina Navratilova who ended up with nine. Evonne Goolagong managed to break the monopoly with two wins, but the only other player to do so was Britain’s Virginia Wade. That she did so in Queen Elizabeth’s silver jubilee year of 1977, that was also the 100th anniversary of the founding of the Wimbledon Championships added lustre to what was anyway a superb achievement.

    Wade was a proven major winner, with two titles in the bag already, the US Open of 1968 and the Australian Open of 1972. She had first competed at Wimbledon as a 16-yr old, and although her performance arc was upwards, as she embarked upon her 16th attempt in 1977 she was yet to appear in the final.

    In 1977, she made her way to the semi-final without the loss of a set, but here she came face to face with number one seed and reigning champion Chris Evert. This was Wade’s best match of the tournament. The first two sets were shared but in the third, Wade’s relentless drive to dominate the net started to get to Evert and the American lost her usually impeccable baseline game. Wade ran away with the set 6-1 to reach her first final.

    In the final she faced Betty Stove of the Netherlands. Stove, a high-class doubles player, had surprised many by beating Navratilova in the quarters, then disappointed many by besting home favourite Sue Barker in the semis. Could she inflict similar disappointment in the final?

    The crowd was overwhelmingly behind Wade, but she displayed signs of nerves in the first set, losing it 6-4 to the Netherlander. Watching the game now, it seems to be played in slow motion. Wade was the more dynamic, always attacking the net; Stove a less fluid mover but talented stroke maker, staying at the baseline, trying to draw Wade into a position where she can pass or lob. After the first set, Wade began to take control of the game, still aggressively coming to the net, but also moving her less athletic opponent more around the court. She actually won the second and third sets relatively comfortably (6-3 and 6-1) and saw herself to a famous win.

    It was not, in truth, a classic match, but the trophy presentation was unforgettable. Queen Elizabeth II made a rare appearance at the event to pass over the Venus Rosewater Dish and a special centenary silver salver to Wade. When Wade held the trophy up to the crowd, their response was ecstatic. 48 years on we await the next British women’s winner, and it may well be a few years more before we see one.

    7. Murray vs Djokovic, Men’s Final 2013

    No selection of the best of Wimbledon can pass without recalling the end of 77 ‘years of hurt’ in 2013. British men’s tennis had been in the doldrums for many years, but started on an upward trajectory in the late 1990s with the emergence of Tim Henman and the adoption of Greg Rusedski. Neither of these was able to make the final step (although Henman came terribly close with four semi-finals) but Henman’s successor as British number one looked made of sterner stuff.

    Andy Murray was a man for whom winning was everything, and for whom the term ‘plucky loser’ would have been the ultimate insult. He had been focused enough at 15 to leave home for a tennis academy in Spain, and had soon proved that his game was of the highest standard. He made the world top 10 by age 19 and started showing well in Grand Slams. He also developed a reputation as somewhat volatile, who unlike the calm and ever-polite Henman, was a supremely sore loser.

    At Wimbledon there was a thought that, like Henman, he might never quite scale the peak. A quarter final in 2008 was followed by three successive semis, then the final in 2012. Nadal put him out in the semis three times, then in his first final he came up against the genius of Roger Federer. His defeat in that year’s final was his fourth in a Grand Slam without any wins. Surprisingly, though, his painful loss proved a springboard to success. He rode a wave of patriotism to avenge himself against Federer in the Olympic final then won his first major at the 2012 US Open against Djokovic.

    In 2013 he was assisted by shock early round defeats for both Nadal and Federer. That still left the indefatigable Djokovic and the two duly made their way to the final. The Serb had come through an epic five-set semi-final over Argentinian Juan Martin del Potro (in 4 hours 43 minutes) that had perhaps taken its toll on him. Murray may have been a little fresher and got off to a great start winning the first two sets. In the third it became all about which player could hold their serve. Murray broke Djokovic first, then lost his own serve twice, before breaking back twice more to lead 5-4 and serve for the Championship. It wasn’t quite as nervy as Ivanisevic against Rafter, but Murray stuttered with the finishing tape in sight. From 40-0 he saw three Championship points dissolve then found himself facing three separate break points. He fought them off then took himself to fourth match point where a netted backhand from Djokovic saw the Scotsman to the title. 77 years after Fred Perry, Britain finally had a men’s champion again. 

    6. Isner vs Mahut – Mens 1st round 2010

    In most sports, there comes a point when an ‘unbreakable’ world record gets broken. Jack Nicklaus’s 18 Majors, Jonathan Edwards 18.29m triple jump, AP McCoy’s 4,358 winners, Tom Brady’s 7 Super Bowls … there may come a time when any or all of these are broken. One record, though, that will never be broken, and would never have been broken even had the rules not been changed is that of the longest tennis game ever played.

    The statistics of the first round match played between John Isner of the USA and Frenchman Nicolas Mahut are so ridiculous that you would think they were made up. In short:

    • The most games in a match – 183 including the final set of 70-68 which in itself would have been longer than the previous longest match
    • The longest time taken – 11 hours 5 minutes
    • The most aces served – Isner 113, Mahut 103 (Isner also holds the record for the most in the tournament at 214 in 2018)

    There’s little that hasn’t already been said about the match but a recent Times article (https://www.thetimes.com/sport/tennis/article/john-isner-nicolas-mahut-longest-tennis-match-wimbledon-5cgd3gpdk) shed some light on the ‘peripheral’ players in this drama.

    One such was Ronald McIntosh, then at the BBC, a boxing specialist for whom this was his first ever tennis commentary, a supposedly low key game on which to cut his teeth. He stayed with the match all the way on the never-ending second day without a food or toilet break. Another was film journalist, Xan Brooks from the Guardian who was penning the newspaper’s live blog. His postings became increasingly outlandish as he tried to inject some humour into proceedings, for example, “In order to keep their strength Isner and Mahut have now started eating members of the audience. They trudge back to the baseline, gnawing on thigh bones and sucking intestines”. This was at ‘only’ 34-34. And match referee Mohamed Lahyani, who stayed in his chair for seven hours solid on the second day as he did not want to disturb the flow of the game.

    You will doubtless be pleased to know that the game has now finished. Oh, and Isner won, 70-68 in the fifth.

    5. Connors vs Pernfors – Men’s 4th round 1987

    Jimmy Connors is one of the all-time greats of mens tennis. Ranked number one for almost five years at his peak, he won more titles, played more matches and won more matches than any other player … ever.  His eight Grand Slams included two Wimbledons, one a demolition of Ken Rosewall in 1974, the other a full eight years later, an epic and unexpected victory over John McEnroe.

    He was, obviously, a player of great skill and talent, but his strongest attribute was his extreme competitiveness. He was the ultimate never-say-die player, always prepared to push himself to his limits to beat the guy on the other side of the net.

    Never was this seen to greater effect than in his fourth round match in 1987 against Swede Mikael Pernfors. Connors was by then 34 years old, and although his best years were behind him, he was still good enough to be seeded seven in the tournament. Pernfors, 10 years Connors’ junior, had surprisingly reached the previous year’s French Open final (the only time he would get past the first round of that tournament) but was unseeded and most observers expected Connors to roll him over.

    The predictions could not have been more wrong. Connors seemed completely out of touch, and an inspired Pernfors romped through the first two sets – 6-1 6-1. When the Swede went 4-1 up in the third set the game looked well and truly up for the two-time champion. In sight of the line, though, Pernfors tightened up, whilst Connors with nothing to lose came out swinging. Out of nowhere the American won three games to love to get back to 4-4 then went on to take the set 7-5. In the fourth he came back from 0-3 down to win 6-4, then he won the fifth 6-2, despite a break against him. After 3 hours and 37 minutes he had achieved one of the greatest comebacks ever.

    4. Novotna vs Tauziat – Women’s Final 1998

    When Czech player Jana Novotna lost to Steffi Graf in the 1993 final, her heartbroken reaction produced one of the most emotional scenes ever on Centre Court. 4-1 up in the final set to the great Steffi Graf, her game had collapsed with the win in sight, and her tears at the prize-giving presentation reflected her devastation at throwing it away.

    When she lost again to Martina Hingis in 1997, after romping to the first set, it looked as though she was destined never to win the Championship. A talented stroke player, it seemed as though Novotna lacked the mental resolve to clinch the victory on grass that many felt she deserved.

    Another chance came very soon. The following year, 1998, she arrived at the tournament as third seed. After a superb win in the semi-final against her nemesis and top seed, Martina Hingis, she found herself strong favourite in the final against the ‘veteran’, Natalie Tauziat. The Frenchwoman, 30, had never previously been past the quarter final in any major, and grass was not considered her best surface.

    Novotna, a big favourite with the fans as well as the bookmakers, seemed determined to put her supporters through the mill. A nervy start meant she went 2-0 and 15-40 down to begin the match. This, though, seemed to kick her into action, and she came through to win the first set 6-4. She then eased to 5-4 in the second and served for the match. Again, she faltered to lose her serve, and the thought among everyone must have been ‘here we go again’. Mercifully, she recovered her sangfroid and dominated the tiebreak to capture the title.

    There were fewer tears than 1993, but this time they were tears of joy. A superb doubles player, she won 12 majors, including at least two at each Grand Slam, but nothing can have meant more to her than her singles triumph of 1998.

    3. Ivanisevic vs Rafter – Men’s Final 2001

    In 2001 Goran Ivanisevic was widely considered to be washed up as a tennis player. Once ranked number two in the world, the Croatian had not won a title for over three years and had dropped out of the world’s top 100. A shoulder injury had reduced the potency of his principal weapon, his left-handed serve, and he was playing at Wimbledon courtesy only of a wild card. Despite his poor recent form, the wild card was warranted – Ivanisevic was the great nearly man of the tournament – three times a finalist, three times a loser, twice in five-set heartbreakers.

    His form during the tournament was a revelation. After beating a qualifier in the first round he beat 21st seed Carlos Moya, Andy Roddick, Greg Rusedski and 4th seed Marat Safin on his way to a semi-final against home favourite, Tim Henman. Henman had never previously lost to Ivanisevic and felt he could read the Croat’s serve. The first two sets were shared before Henman blitzed Ivanisevic in the third – 6-0 in only 14 minutes. At 2-1 up in the fourth all the momentum was with the Briton, but then the heavens opened. The centre court roof had not yet been built so play was postponed for the day. By the time they reconvened the following day, Ivanisevic was a different player and managed to capture the fourth set on a tie-break. There was then another rain delay. The match was eventually completed on the Sunday, 45 hours after it had started, and Ivanisevic came through to win. There is little doubt that Henman would have won had the match not been disturbed.

    The final, played on a Monday after all the tournament rain delays, was against Australian Pat Rafter, the previous year’s beaten finalist. The Monday finish meant that thousands of Croats and Aussies managed to get tickets so the atmosphere was raucous. The fans witnessed a roller-coaster. Ivanisevic took the first set, Rafter the second then they repeated the act. Two sets all and the two players were into a final decisive set.

    It went with serve until the fifteenth game when Rafter was broken to 15. Surely the next game, with Ivanisevic serving, would be a formality. It wasn’t. The Croat, overcome with nerves, played like he had just learned the game. Three double faults were as bad as any seen on centre court. He gave away three Championship points, two with desperate errors. When he finally somehow managed to string together a couple of decent points and got over the line he was overcome with emotion. The 250-1 outsider and serial runner-up had won the trophy of his dreams.

    2. Federer vs Nadal – Men’s Final 2008

    The rivalry between the big three in men’s tennis illuminated the game for more than a decade following their emergence in the mid 2000s. Roger Federer, Novak Djokovic and Rafael Nadal are arguably the three greatest players in the game ever, and they were all around at the same time. They played against each other in the grand slams 49 times, of which 23 were in finals. So many of their matches were epics that it seems invidious to pick out only one but as the 2008 Wimbledon final is rated by many tennis experts to be the greatest ever, we’ve selected it for this list.

    By 2008. Nadal was already dominating the French Open, with four consecutive titles and Federer was dominating pretty much everything else. The Swiss already had three Australian Open titles, four US Opens and five consecutive Wimbledon Championships in his trophy cabinet. If he was hard to beat on hard courts, he looked utterly unbeatable on the grass of SW19.

    If anyone was going to stop Federer it was the inexhaustible Mallorcan. Nadal had made the two previous Wimbledon finals and had pushed Federer close in both. He got off to a great start in the 2008 final by winning a superb 14-stroke rally. He went on to win the set 6-4, then captured the second 6-4 having come back from 1-4 down. With the score 3-3 in the third Nadal had three break points on Federer’s serve. A break would probably have been decisive, but Federer was not going to relinquish his grip on the title that easily, and fought back to hold. He went on to win the third set tie-break to take the game into a fourth set. This, too, went to a tie-break and looked very much to be going Nadal’s way. At 5-2 and on Nadal’s serve it looked all over, but Federer once again had other ideas. Producing great passing shots under the utmost pressure, Federer managed to take the match into a final set.

    The final set was full of drama, but serve was held until the 15th game of the set. Finally, Nadal broke Federer to leave himself one service game away from his first Championship. Even this game was not straightforward, going to deuce before Nadal produced a superb first serve then Federer netted a forehand for Nadal to prevail. At 9:15pm, in near darkness, one of the greatest matches in tennis history was over.

    1. Borg vs McEnroe – Men’s Final 1980

    When Bjorn Borg met John McEnroe in the gentleman’s singles final in 1980 it was a match that really grabbed the world’s attention. The contrast of personalities and styles was extreme. Borg was ‘the iceman’, emotional impenetrable and cool in any situation;  McEnroe was volatile, angry at anybody and everybody (including himself) and always seemingly on the edge of an outburst. Borg was more of a baseliner (albeit this was something of a caricature – all players came to the net far more than in the present day), who returned everything with interest and wore his opponents down with accuracy and power;  McEnroe was the serve and volleyer, a creative artist who frequently produced the unexpected and used his racket like a wizard uses a wand. Borg was the defending champion, heading for his fifth Wimbledon title in a row;  McEnroe was the coming man, already with one Grand Slam (the 1979 US Open) but as yet no Wimbledon title to his name. Seeded one and two for the tournament, Borg was still only 24 years old, McEnroe three years younger at 21.

    Borg had made his way serenely to his fifth final in a row with only two sets dropped in six matches. McEnroe’s progress had been a little more testing, with a big scare in round two against the unfancied (and largely unremembered) Australian Terry Rocavert, then a feisty semi-final against Jimmy Connors. Although he had yet to produce his infamous ‘you cannot be serious’ line, McEnroe had had a series of angry confrontations with officials in his semi-final win and had alienated a sizeable proportion of the conservative Wimbledon faithful.

    The final lived up to all expectations. McEnroe started like a greyhound out of the traps and stunned Borg by racing into a 6-1 lead. He served well, volleyed with his trademark brilliance and produced a dazzling array of passing shots, lobs and drop shots. Borg though came back strongly and seemed to have worked out his opponent. Reading McEnroe’s serve better and finding his range on his own groundstrokes, he did enough to undermine McEnroe’s game plan and win the second and third sets. The game seemed up for the American when Borg broke in the fourth set and served for the match at 5-4. At 40-15 Borg had two Championship points on his own serve.

    Perhaps Borg tightened up a little. On the other side of the net, McEnroe produced some stunning passing shots and contrived to win four points in a row to break the Swede’s serve. Two service holds later and we were into the tie break to end all tie breaks. Each had several chances to clinch it. Borg had five more match points that he again failed to convert; McEnroe alternated between brilliance and mediocrity, coming up with great winners when behind but unforced errors when on top. Eventually, after 20 minutes of the highest drama, McEnroe produced a series of winning volleys and passing shots to win 18-16.

    After the tie-break the final set was arguably a bit of an anti-climax. Both players held serve until the American cracked in the 14th game. Borg’s powerful returns and groundstrokes put the American’s volleying under pressure before a double-handed backhand passing shot clinched his fifth successive title.

    McEnroe did not have to wait long for his revenge. Two months later, he beat Borg on the hard courts of Flushing Meadows in the US Open, then in 1981 he turned the tables on Borg at Wimbledon.  When McEnroe beat Borg once again in the 1981 US Open final, it precipitated the surprise retirement of the Swede. He was only 25 years old.

    The worst of the Open golf

    For every winner in a golf tournament there are normally over 100 ‘losers’. It’s a game that demands incredible resilience from its competitors, the ability to bounce back repeatedly from defeat and remain positive in the face of all the evidence. The Open has thrown up many tales of unexpected victories and comebacks, but it’s also delivered many disappointments. I don’t glory in them, but here’s my list of the biggest chokes, collapses, unlucky mistakes in the history of golf’s greatest Major.

    6. The wrong scorecard – Mark Roe, Royal St George’s, 2003

    “I’ve just played one of the greatest rounds of my life and I can’t play tomorrow” Mark Roe in 2003

    Mark Roe is probably best known today as a golf pundit for Sky Sports. Like many of his fellow pundits (Nick Dougherty, Robert Lee, Ewen Murray etc), he was a solid professional who had a great career on the European tour, but was not quite good enough to make it the very top table. In 22 years as a pro, he played over 500 tournaments, winning three on the European tour, and getting at one stage to number 40 in the world.

    His performance in Majors, however, was modest. He qualified only once for the Masters, where he failed to make the cut, and once for the US Open, where he finished a very creditable 13th. He did qualify many times for his home Major, the Open, but in 12 appearances up to 2001 made the cut only five times with a best finish of tied 16th. By the time he next qualified, in 2003, he was 40 years old, ranked #303 in the world, and his best days seemed behind him.

    His first round befitted his status as a rank outsider, a six-over par 77 leaving him nine shots off the pace and with a challenge to make the cut. This he managed with one of the best scores on a tough day two, a one-under 70. His third round – on ‘moving day’ – was even better. Playing with Swede Jesper Parnevik, Roe recorded a best-of-the-day 67 to leave him just two off the lead held by Dane, Thomas Bjorn. His score of 214 put him level with unaccustomed company, an esteemed trio of Kenny Perry, Vijay Singh and Tiger Woods.

    Could this finally be Roe’s moment, his opportunity to show how good he was on the biggest stage of them all. Sadly not. It transpired that at the start of play, Roe and Parnevik had not exchanged their scorecards. So, each had scored and signed the wrong card. The fault was not picked up until after both had left the scorer’s hut so both were disqualified. It was no big problem for Parnevik, who had recorded an 81, but a tragedy for Roe, whose big chance simply evaporated.

    Roe took it in incredibly good grace, more so considering that the eventual winner, Ben Curtis, was ranked even lower than Roe, demonstrating that the field was unusually open. Most observers, even the stuffiest traditionalists, felt that the punishment had not fitted the ‘crime’, so much so that the rules were changed a couple of years later. It was, of course, too late for Roe who never played in another Major.

    5. The fifteenth club – Ian Woosnam takes a two-shot penalty for carrying one club too many – Royal Lytham, 2001

    “You’re going to go ballistic about this,” Miles Byrne, caddie, to Ian Woosnam

    In the late 1980s and early 1990s Welshman Ian Woosnam was one of the best golfers in the world. A serial winner on the European tour, he captured the Masters in 1991 and spent 50 weeks as world number one. He continued to win tournaments until the mid 1990s and represent Europe in the Ryder Cup, but by the turn of the century he was considered by most to be a spent force.

    It was therefore something of a surprise when he found himself in contention in the 2001 Open at Royal Lytham. Rounds of 72, 68 and 67 saw him tied for the lead in what was admittedly a very crowded leaderboard (there were 12 players within one shot of each other).

    His final round got off to a great start with a birdie on the par-3 first. It was then that things took an unexpected turn. The rules of golf specify that a golfer must have no more than 14 clubs in their bag. Woosnam had been practising before the round with two different drivers, but his caddie, Miles Byrne, had forgotten to remove one of them before starting the round. The hapless Byrne realised his mistake as the pair got to the second tee. The penalty for carrying an extra club is two shots for each hole played, so Woosnam saw his score transform instantly from 7-under to 5-under. He responded by flinging his extra club to the ground and exclaiming to Byrne “I give you one job to do and this is what happens”, and flinging his extra club to the ground. Still furious, bogeys on 3 and 4 followed, after which Woosnam never got seriously back into contention.

    Woosnam, surprisingly, retained Byrne after the tournament, but sacked him two weeks later when the caddie slept in and was late for a tee-time. Woosnam never contended seriously after 2001;  Byrne gave up caddying and carried bricks on building sites rather than golf bags.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/wales/18869687

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/stories-of-st-andrews-doug-sanders-and-the-best-bunker-shot-you%E2%80%99ve-never-seen

    4. The inescapable bunker – Bjorn takes three to get out of the bunker – Royal St George’s, 2003 

    “There’s one thing I’ve learnt. It’s me. I’m a jinx.” – Thomas Bjorn’s caddie, Billy Foster

    Every amateur golfer has experienced the horrors of trying to get out of a difficult bunker. Go for precision and the ball drops before it’s travelled far enough.  Go for power and thin it into the face. Few professional golfers even think about this. More often than not, they’re thinking about holing the ball, and their sand save statistics are frankly ridiculous.

    In 2003 it was Thomas Bjorn’s turn to feel like an amateur. Bjorn had gone into the final round at St George’s with a one shot lead, and played solidly throughout the round to fend off charges from Vijay Singh, Tiger Woods and unheralded American Ben Curtis. As he came to the 16th, he held a two-shot lead with only three holes left to play. The par-3 was a hole he had parred on each of the first three days so he must have felt confident.

    In fact, his tee shot was about one yard from being great, but it caught a slope on the green and rolled right and dropped into the greenside bunker. The sensible choice from this bunker is to go a little long making sure you don’t roll back into the bunker. Bjorn instead went for a delicate escape and just failed to get his ball far enough up the green. Agonisingly, he saw his ball roll back into the bunker. Then, he did it again. He actually did well with his third bunker shot to get it out of his own footmarks, and even better to sink the 10-foot putt for a double bogey. But his two-shot lead had evaporated as had his confidence and he went on to bogey the next.

    Safe in the clubhouse, earlier finisher Curtis could probably not believe his luck. In his very first major, the world number 396 had seen a string of storied adversaries fall away, before watching Bjorn apply the coup de grace to his own prospects.  

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/thomas-bjorn-iconic-open-moments

    3. The two-shot swing – Jacklin crumbles after Trevino’s outrageous chip-in – Muirfield, 1972

    “Confound it, that’s the fourth time that Trevino chips it in from off the green … it really is diabolical” – Henry Longhurst commentating

    After Max Faulkner won the Open in 1951 it took a further 18 years for a Briton to win another golf major. The wait was broken at Royal Lytham in 1969 by a 25-year old from Scunthorpe, Tony Jacklin. Jacklin confirmed his talent with a second major, the 1970 US Open, and looked set to contend for years to come. And, perhaps he would have done had it not been for a huge setback in 1972.

    He had finished well in the Opens of both 1970 (5th place) and 1971 (3rd), demonstrating his credentials in links golf, and Muirfield witnessed another strong performance. He led after the first round, sat tied with Lee Trevino after the second and entered the final round only a shot behind the American. Jacklin had by any measure played the better all-round golf, but Trevino’s short game saved him time and again.

    Both played steadily on the final day and they made their way to the par-5 17th tied at the top of the leaderboard. Jacklin drove down the middle while Trevino put his into a deep pot bunker on the fairway. The American then struggled to get out, before hooking his third into heavy rough well short of the green. His chip was clumsy and finished 12 foot past the green in lighter rough. Jacklin meanwhile had made the green in three and sat only 15 feet from the pin. Surely, the best Trevino could expect was a six, while the worst for Jacklin was a five.

    Trevino, though, did not see it that way. He sent a delicate chip onto the green and for the fourth time in two days it rolled on before dropping in the hole. He had rescued an improbable par. Jacklin, obviously rattled, sent his approach putt 2-3 feet past before stabbing the return to miss the hole again. Instead of a one-shot lead for Jacklin, it was a one-shot lead for Trevino with only one hole to play.

    Trevino parred the last to win. Jacklin, still shell-shocked, bogeyed it to finish third, and never really recovered from the setback. After five top 10s in six years, he never again achieved the feat. He did go on to become a great Ryder Cup captain, but as a golfer he was never the same after the trauma inflicted by Trevino’s incredible short game.

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/2019/04/my-greatest-shot-lee-trevino

    2. The tap-in that wasn’t – Doug Sanders misses a 30-in putt on the last – St Andrews, 1970

    “Only every four or five minutes” – Doug Sanders when asked in later years whether he ever thought about his miss

    Doug Sanders was one of the most engaging characters in American golf through the 1960s and early 70s. Good looking, dressed in flamboyant clothes, seemingly carefree and upbeat, and always ready with a quip or wisecrack, he was a favourite of crowds and sponsors alike. He was also a pretty useful golfer. He won 20 events on the PGA tour and managed 13 top ten finishes in majors, including four second places.

    His most (in)famous second place came at St Andrews in 1970. Against a strong field, Sanders looked certain to finally lay his majors bogey to rest. He came to the last hole – the relatively straightforward ‘Tom Morris’ – holding a one shot lead. Needing only a par four to seal the deal he made the green in two, but with a slightly longer putt than he might have wished for, some 30 or so feet from the hole. A two-putt and the Claret Jug would be his. Betraying some nerves, his first putt was a little short and left him a 3-foot putt for the title. 99 times out of 100 this would be a ‘gimme’, but Sanders wanted to make sure. He took a long look from both sides of the hole before standing over his putt. He then pulled away to remove a speck of something or another from his line. When he finally putted, he made an unconvincing stab and the ball rolled past the hole without ever looking like going in. Sanders had thrown away his chance of winning outright. Veteran commentator Henry Longhurst summed up what many thought, “And there, but for the grace of God…”

    Sanders, of course, was still in the tournament, but now had to beat the great Jack Nicklaus in an 18-hole play-off to win it. He bounced back from his disappointment to play pretty well in the play-off, and even managed to birdie the last with a putt almost identical to the one he had missed the day before. But Nicklaus was just a little better and beat his fellow American by a stroke. Sanders remains one of the best players never to win a major. Few of the other contenders for this unwanted title will have come as close as he did in 1970.

    1. Le Blow Up – Jean Van de Velde throws a three-shot lead on the final hole – Carnoustie, 1999

    “Would someone kindly go and stop him … give him a large brandy and mop him down.” – Peter Alliss, on Jean van de Velde 1999

    Frenchman Jean Van de Velde is one of those unfortunate sports people who will be forever be known for something they did not achieve rather than for something they did. Leading the Open by three shots as he teed up on the 18th at Carnoustie, he somehow contrived to throw away his best and only chance of winning a major.

    The 1999 Open was brutal. Carnoustie is a challenging course at the best of times – its nickname of ‘Carnasty’ provides a pretty good clue to its difficulty – and when the wind blows it becomes nigh on impossible. The conditions in 1999 were tough. The first round was led by Australian Rodney Pampling with an even-par 71, but he became the only first such player to miss the cut after a second round 86. 19-year-old Sergio Garcia, already a winner on the European tour, left the course in tears after an 89. Few players were able to cope, but the one who did best was qualifier Van de Velde. Rounds of 75, 68 and 70 took him into a five shot lead starting the final day.

    Van de Velde had little experience of being a front-runner, least of all in a major, but he coped well with the pressure. Three bogeys and a birdie saw him to the turn in 2-over, still in the lead. Despite a charge from his playing partner, Craig Parry, that saw him briefly take the lead before dropping away, the Frenchman was able to keep his round on track. And so, he came to the 18th holding a three shot lead.

    The 18th is a tough hole, 487 yards long with a stream – the Barry Burn – weaving its way through it. Van de Velde got lucky with his drive, only just clearing the burn and finding the light rough. Knowledgeable observers all agreed on one thing, that he should exercise caution with his second and lay up before the green. Van de Velde thought differently and decided to go for it. This was his first mistake. His long iron arced to the right, so far that it hit the spectator stands before bouncing back to rest in heavy rough. Again, caution was called for – just get it out and onto the nearest bit of fairway and take your medicine. Van de Velde, his mind now scrambled, went for the green, failed to get a good enough contact and plopped his ball into the burn. The ball was visible in the water and the Frenchman looked for all the world as though he was going to try and play it. After an agonising few minutes, he saw sense and took a drop. He was now playing his fifth shot so an up and down would still have won him the title. But his chip was too delicate and he found the greenside bunker. After getting out he found himself now needing a 10-foot putt simply to get in the play-off.

    He somehow made the putt but the four hole play-off was a bridge too far for him. He played ok, but was no match for Paul Lawrie, on a roll after coming from 10 shots back at the start of the round. Scotsman Lawrie is to some extent a victim of Van de Velde’s tragic collapse – more remember the Frenchman who lost than the Scotsman who won. He does, though, have the considerable consolation of having actually won the claret jug.

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/the-story-of-1999-carnoustie-van-de-velde-lawrie-leonard

    The best of the Open golf

    The Open golf (or the British Open if you’re American) is the greatest of the four majors. Dating back to 1860 it is the tournament the defines a career – if you win it you’ve made it, if not you’ll always have something missing. All of the great golfers have tested themselves on the links courses of Britain and most have risen to the challenge.

    It’s difficult to select only five great moments from the history of this wonderful event, but that’s what I’ve tried to do in this blog. I may add more in time, but for now see whether you think I’ve included your favourite moments from the Open.

    6. The rebuild – Nick Faldo records 18 straight pars to win, Muirfield 1987

    “He hung in when others would have dropped out. Come hell or high water he was determined to get it right.” David Leadbetter on Nick Faldo

    For a late starter (he started playing golf aged 14), Nick Faldo was an incredibly fast developer. With only three years of golf under his belt, he qualified for the English Amateur championship, and just one year later he had captured both that title and the British Youths Open Amateur. He turned pro as a 19-year-old, and starred in his first Ryder Cup in 1977 aged only 20. The then-youngest player ever to be selected won three points out of three, including a fourball win over Jack Nicklaus and a scarcely believable singles win over Open Champion Tom Watson. Within six years he had won 10 European Tour events, including three PGA Championships, and been crowned 1983 Order of Merit winner.

    Most golfers would have considered that things were going pretty well, but not Faldo. He had set his sights on winning Majors and on becoming the best golfer in the world, and judged that his all-round game was not strong enough to achieve this. He had recorded five consecutive top 12 finishes in the Open without winning, plus he had made little impact in the US, so he embarked on a radical reconstruction of his swing.

    Faldo chose a then little-known coach, David Leadbetter, to help him rebuild his game. Initial results were unpromising. In 1985 he failed to win any tournaments and finished outside the top 20 in each of the three Majors he contested. In 1986 he managed to finish fifth in the Open, but again went through the season without winning a title. Many thought he had gone too far with his swing changes, and killed the talent that had brought him his incredible early success.

    We know now, of course, that he had not, and that instead he had painstakingly laid the foundations for becoming Britain’s most successful golfer of modern times. Things started to click into place in 1987. After a slow start to the season, he placed fourth in the Madrid Open then third in the Italian Open, before his big breakthrough, a win in May in the Spanish Open, his first title for three years. He continued to place reasonably well (without winning) in the run-up to the Open so must have felt he was competitive. The bookies gave him a chance, but as an outsider at 33-1.

    Faldo showed at Muirfield that all the work he had put into his game was worth it. He kicked off with an impressive three-under 68 (which should perhaps have been better after he started with three birdies) then followed it up with a 69 and an even-par 71 in conditions that were very tough for scoring. He entered the final round tied for second, one behind American Paul Azinger, and alongside a strong leaderboard featuring Tom Watson, Ray Floyd and Payne Stewart amongst others.

    Faldo’s final round was spectacular for its unspectacularness. He came to the turn in even par having recorded nine straight pars (albeit he did need sand saves on both seven and eight). This kept him in contention with Azinger who, playing in the group behind Faldo, had gone out in two under to stretch his lead to three. Both, though, still had to negotiate the back nine on a Majors Sunday, arguably the ultimate examination of mental strength and technique.

    Faldo was up to the test. Unflappable and, demonstrating total confidence in his new swing, he rolled out par after par. Azinger, meanwhile, faltered, bogeys on 10 and 11 cutting his lead to just one shot. When he came to the 17th he still led by one, but he bogeyed here while Faldo, one hole ahead on the final green, was nervelessly rolling in a five-footer for par to complete a round of 18 straight pars. All square now with Faldo in the clubhouse and Azinger needing a par to make a play-off. The American cracked, pulling his approach into a bunker from which he failed to get up and down. Faldo was the 1987 Open Champion.

    Faldo’s ability to deliver a round of 18 pars under intense pressure utterly vindicated his decision to rebuild his game, and was testament to his immense dedication and drive. He, of course, went on to even greater things with two more Opens and three Masters. Stephen Pye of The Guardian put it nicely when he wrote that at Muirfield Faldo “left the ranks of good to become truly great.” 

    5. The nearly fairy tale – Tom Watson almost wins the Open at 59 – Turnberry, 2009

    “It would have been a hell of a story, wouldn’t it?” Tom Watson 2009

    Over the last 125 years of golf, there have been precisely eight golfers who have won a PGA Tour event after the age of 50. Of these, the oldest was the legendary Sam Snead who won the Greater Greensboro in 1965 aged just under 53. In 2009, one man came close to smashing Snead’s record by winning the Open at the impossible age of 59! That man was Tom Watson.

    Watson, of course, had some pedigree on the links courses of Great Britain. He had won five Open Championships, each at a different venue, plus four other top 10s. Add to this his three other majors and countless top 10 major finishes and you had one of the greatest golfers of the 20th century. By 2009, though, his best years were a long way behind him. His last major win had been 26 years previously and he had finished in the top 10 of the Open only once in two decades. His appearances were more like that of a tribute band than of the real thing.

    All this changed in four magical days at Turnberry, the scene of Watson’s epic victory over Jack Nicklaus 32 years earlier. Good conditions on day one saw Watson record a bogey-free five-under 65 to lie joint second. The 1500-1 rank outsider was in the places but surely it could not last. It could. When the weather worsened on days two and three, Watson’s game remained rock steady and, to everybody’s surprise, he led the field by a stroke going into the final day.

    Watson stuttered a little at the start of his fourth round with two bogeys in the first three holes, but then managed to steady the ship. Plotting his way intelligently around the course and doing his best to avoid trouble, he remained in serious contention. Other players climbed the leaderboard, but then fell away just as quickly. He stayed calm and near the top. Incredibly, a birdie on the penultimate hole meant that Watson teed off on the 18th needing only a par to win the tournament.

    Nerveless, he hit a nice drive to find the right side of the fairway. From 187 yards and with the wind behind, he chose 8-iron for his second. He struck it beautifully and the ball pitched on the front of the green. It looked perfect, but it kept rolling and rolling, past the pin then off the back of the green to finish in a collar of rough. A par was still on, if Watson could get up and down, but he was a little too firm with his approach putt. He was faced with an 8-footer for the title. Putting had been his achilles heel in his later years, and this effort never gave the ball a chance. A bogey meant a play-off with Stewart Cink that a tired Watson was unable to get himself up for.

    The whole golfing world, with the possible exception of the Cink family, had been willing Watson to win. Sadly, he did not manage, but for four days the greatest links player of the 20th century had reminded us of his brilliance.

    4. The one and only – Ben Hogan wins on his only Open appearance – Carnoustie, 1953

    The question this time is not “Who will win?” but “Can Hogan win?” – Glasgow Herald Jul 5 1953

    In 1949 the best golfer of the era, Ben Hogan, was involved in a horrific car accident. A Greyhound bus driving towards him collided head-on with his vehicle, and he would have been killed had he not thrown himself across the car to protect his wife. As it was, the accident left the 36-year-old with terrible injuries that not only threatened to end his golf career, but also threatened his life.

    Hogan did survive, though, and after 59 days in hospital was able to return home to dedicate himself to recovering his fitness. Always a hard worker – it was said that he had ‘invented practice’ – he also set about restoring his ability to compete at the sport he excelled at. It did not take long. In little more than a year he had placed fourth in the Masters and won the US Open despite having to play 36 holes on the final day.

    Playing far fewer tournaments after his accident, and focusing almost exclusively on the majors, brought Hogan more success than he had had before. He won the duo of Masters and US Open in 1951, then repeated the act in 1953. At 40 he now had eight majors, but his cabinet still lacked one essential trophy, the Claret Jug. Coveted by golfers across the world, Hogan had never bothered to compete in the Open. He decided to break his duck in his annus mirabilis. There were two minor issues for him to overcome if he was to win – first, he had never previously played links golf in the UK and second, the ball used in Britain was smaller than that used in the US (1.62” diameter compared to 1.68”).

    Not one to do things by halves, Hogan set about addressing these gaps in his experience. Flying to Scotland two weeks before the tournament, he set himself up at nearby Panmure Golf Club with only English caddie, Cecil Timms, for company. He was clearly a quick learner. He managed to qualify for the tournament (it was required even for the world’s best overseas players) then went to take on Carnoustie. Over the four days, Hogan simply got better and better. A 73 on the first day was followed by a 71, a 70, then finally a 68. His final score of 282 was good enough for a four-shot victory and his third major of the calendar year.

    Although he came close to winning others, the 1953 Open was to be Hogan’s last major. And it was to be his only visit to the Open. British fans would have liked to have seen him more, but those who did saw a champion golfer in every sense of the word.

    https://thejourney.theopen.com/1953

    3. The final round to end all final rounds – Stenson scales unprecedented heights to beat Mickelson – Royal Troon, 2016

     “Henrik, you’re one of the best long iron players in the history of the game. The best I’ve ever seen. You’re going to win your major,“ – Phil Mickelson to Henrik Stenson at the US Open 2016.

    Phil Mickelson is by any measure one of the greatest golfers of all time. His 45 wins on the PGA tour include six major championships – three Masters, two PGA Championships and one Open, and his PGA win in 2021 made him the oldest major winner in history, at almost 51 years old. Despite his massive success, though, he can claim to have been a little unlucky in his career. Had he not been around in the era of a certain Tiger Woods, he may well have dominated the sport for years and won many more majors. It was not Woods, however, who denied him the 2016 Open, it was a 40-year-old Swede playing the most inspired golf of his life.

    The Swede, Henrik Stenson, was an extremely good golfer. Winner of numerous events across the world, he seemed to find his best golf in his mid-late 30s. He won the Race to Dubai and the FedEx Cup in 2013 and reached his highest world ranking of number two the following year. He had contended strongly in majors but never quite got over the line. If he was to win one, it was perhaps the Open that presented his best opportunity – he had two third place finishes and a runners-up, to Mickelson, behind him when he came to Royal Troon in 2016.

    The American got off to a flier, a round of 63 equalling the lowest ever at the Open. Stenson then countered with a 65 in the second, before the two pulled away from the field in the third. On a tough day for scoring, neither seemed especially flustered by the conditions and they ended the day five ahead of third-placed Bill Haas with Stenson one shot ahead of Mickelson.

    The final day saw thrust and counter-thrust with both golfers at the peak of their powers and attacking the pin on almost every hole. The round started with a rare bogey for Stenson, and Mickelson snatched the lead with a birdie. If Stenson was shaken it did not show. Five birdies in seven holes took him to 16-under at the turn, but this was not enough to shake off Mickelson who had an eagle and another birdie of his own. The two were getting looks at birdie on almost every hole and converting most. A second bogey, though, for Stenson saw Mickelson draw level and they came to the 14th tee all square.

    Unfortunately for the American, Stenson went on one of those spurts when the putter gets red hot. He sunk a 20-footer on the 14th, a 50-footer on the 15th and a tricky 5-footer on the 16th. To cap it all, he drained a 20-footer on the last. Despite playing a superb bogey-free final round of 65, Mickelson had come up three shots short of the Swede.

    Stenson’s 63 was the lowest final round in an Open, his 20-under a record for the Open and his total score (264) a new record for any major. Was scoring especially easy? No so. In third place came JB Holmes, a distant 11 shots behind Mickelson. For four glorious days, the Swede and the American played a different game to everyone else. Mickelson was brilliant, but Stenson just a little more brilliant.

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/stenson-mickelson-hole-by-hole-2016-royal-troon

    2. The swashbuckling Spaniard – Seve arrives as a champion – Royal Lytham, 1979  

    “The Gods are smiling on this young man today … he’s been rather wayward and got away with it all so far” – Peter Alliss

    There is some debate as to whether Severiano Ballesteros is the best European golfer of the last half century. Nick Faldo won six majors to Seve’s five, and Rory McIlroy now has the career Grand Slam. There can be little debate, however, as to who was the most popular and well-loved. The charismatic Spaniard played with passion and creativity, always attacked the course and consistently conjured up the unlikeliest of escapes. Seve was the golfer most of us dreamed we might be.

    He had announced himself at the Open aged only 19 at Birkdale in 1976, when he led through each of the first three rounds and finished second, behind only an inspired Johnny Miller. When he arrived at Royal Lytham three years on, he was yet to win his first major but was certainly counted among the favourites. 

    His first round was unexceptional, but a round two best of 65 brought him right back into contention. In tough conditions for scoring, his third round 75 was not too damaging, so he entered the final day only two off the lead. The driver was rarely Seve’s friend and a more cautious player might have left it in the bag on the final day. Not Seve. He kept using it from the tee, despite missing the fairway almost every time he did so. From hole 12 onwards he was constantly in trouble. But Seve’s superpower was his ability to visualise seemingly impossible shots, then go on to execute them.

    On 12 from well out to the right he made a superb up-and-down. On 13 he putted in from off the green. On 15 there was another unlikely rescue, this time from wide on the left. On 16, Seve entered golfing folklore. He drove miles right to finish in the car park underneath a car. Fortunately, he was entitled to a free drop, and after a tidy pitch he sank a 20-foot putt for the unlikeliest of birdies. There was still time for him to miss the green on 17 and drive into the crowd on 18, but in both cases he escaped with par. His roller-coaster 70 was enough to bring him a three-shot victory.

    Seve would go on to claim two more Opens and two Masters, all in his customary swashbuckling style. He would, of course, lose others due to his unwillingness to compromise. But, like Arnold Palmer before him, he won the hearts of the golf-watching public for always going for it and never holding back. He will never be forgotten.

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/seve-story-of-1979

    1. The Duel in the Sun – Watson and Nicklaus battle it out down the straight – Turnberry, 1977

    “This is what it’s all about, isn’t it?” – Tom Watson to Jack Nicklaus on the 16th tee, final round

    In July 1977 Turnberry (now disappointingly ‘Trump Turnberry’) hosted the Open for the very first time.  The 1977 Open pitted two of the greatest golfers of all time against each other. In the right corner, Jack Nicklaus, 37 years old, with 14 majors including a career grand slam already under his belt and still very much in his prime. In the left, 27-year-old Tom Watson, pretender to Nicklaus’s crown and already with two majors to his name. The two produced golf of the very highest quality, and delivered the most compelling drama seen before or since on a golf course.

    The first two days were all about getting into position. Both Nicklaus and Watson scored 68 then 70 to lie one shot off the halfway lead. Day three saw them break free from the pack. On ‘moving day’ both recorded 5-under-par 65s to open up a three-stroke lead on the field.

    The final day, Saturday, was visited by the same fine sunshine that had blessed Turnberry throughout the tournament, but with a slightly brisker wind. Nicklaus got off to the better start, two birdies in the first four against a Watson bogey, taking him into a three-shot lead. Watson though hit straight back with unanswered birdies on 5, 7 and 8.  Nicklaus was stung, but a birdie on 12 and another Watson bogey saw him take back the lead. Watson though hit straight back with a birdie and was one shot behind as they arrived at the 15th.

    The 209-yd par 3 is called ‘Ca Canny’ which means ‘Go Carefully’. Watson’s tee shot was perhaps a little too careful and finished some 60ft from the pin just off the green. Nicklaus’s tee shot was better and left him with a very makeable birdie opportunity. Against all the odds, Watson’s long putt slammed into the pin and dropped (it would have gone at least 10 feet past had it missed) and a rattled Nicklaus missed his. All square with three to play.

    The 16th was uneventful but on 17 something most unusual happened. Nicklaus cracked, or least showed signs of being a mere mortal. A shortish par 5, the 17th offers a cast-iron birdie opportunity. While Watson claimed his birdie easily, Nicklaus scrambled. It took a superb recovery with his third shot to give himself a decent look at birdie, but to the surprise of all those watching he missed the putt. On the 18th he again faltered, a wild drive seeing his tee shot come to rest in thick rough. Watson, meanwhile, found the centre of the fairway, followed up with a stunning 7-iron to within three feet of the hole. Any other golfer would have shown the white flag, but not Nicklaus. From a seemingly unplayable lie, he took an almighty swish and managed not only got his ball out of the rough but also, incredibly, to find the green. He still had an unlikely 32-foot putt to put Watson under any sort of pressure, but like the true champion he was, he drained it. Watson, with the whole golfing world holding its collective breath, stood over his 30” putt and sank it.  Tom had beaten Jack by a single shot.

    The two had been competing in a different game to everyone else. Nicklaus finished 10 shots ahead of next-placed Hubert Green and his losing score of 269 would have won every other Open by at least seven shots. Both would go on to win more Opens and other majors, but none would be as dramatic as their tussle at Turnberry.  

    https://www.theopen.com/latest/duel-in-the-sun-nicklaus-vs-watson-at-the-106th-open